3 ms·
Sure, but having the design frozen is one reason why this may never happen in the first place, after all any kind of deviation and it is back to a recertificati
by jacquesm 4y ago
Sure, but having the design frozen is one reason why this may never happen in the first place, after all any kind of deviation and it is back to a recertification and that gets expensive quickly. No such thing as 'move fast and break stuff' in the nuclear power business, your design works or you're history.
And as you tacitly admit modular is revolutionary and there are a whole pile of challenges right there, having a single (large) point of failure may well be much easier to manage than several smaller ones, I never saw the modularity as the problem to solve, because existing (large) reactors are more often than not also created in sets to deal with downtime due to maintenance and overhauls.
Your third point is accurate, but also may end up being this projects downfall: by changing some core design parameters (such as size) new failure modes may well pop up. MTBF is mostly a function of the number of components, if you increase the number of components, even if the components are smaller you will probably still see more failures.
Four is true, but: here in NL we currently have the same situation and a new reactor was just greenlit (two, actually if I understood all of the material right). But this is a decade+ project and I suspect that given the fickle nature of these projects that there is a fair chance that it will eventually never see the light of day because of the dark horse of economics: a typical nuclear plant will generate power, but it will never generate any money. Without subsidies these are essentially dead ends.