3 ms·
It is fairly normal for victims of violence to seek to explain away the abuse they were subjected to as deserved or necessary when carried out by someone in aut
by vidarh 4y ago
It is fairly normal for victims of violence to seek to explain away the abuse they were subjected to as deserved or necessary when carried out by someone in authority over them.
It doesn't change that it is harmful abuse. I'm sorry you were subjected to that kind of abuse, even though you believe it was justified.
There's nothing to suggest it serves a legitimate purpose.
- slibhb 4y ago> There's nothing to suggest it serves a legitimate purpose. Well there's nothing if you disregard personal testimony as stockholm syndrome.
- vidarh 4y agoIf it served a legitimate purpose you'd expect actual research showing it, not having to rely on the accounts of a subset of victims.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Well there’s nothing if you disregard personal testimony as Stockholm syndrome I don’t disregard anything as Stockholm Syndrome, since that doesn’t exist. However, I do disregard anecdotal conclusory testimony about causative processes, as a general rule. I’ll accept testimony about facts plausibly within the knowledge of the person testifying as being (barring special reason for suspicion on those points) as trustworthy as the person testifying.
- slibhb 4y agoYou disregard anecdote when it clashes with your priors.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> You disregard anecdote when it clashes with your priors. No, I disregard anecdote to the extent it makes claims which are conclusory rather than observational. I weight anecdote very lightly in any case, though.
- roamerz 4y ago>> There's nothing to suggest it serves a legitimate purpose. Well nothing except my personal experience which you clearly disregarded by categorizing me without any evidence as a victim of violence nor do I see this as abuse(obviously). No offense taken by the comment btw I just don’t believe you are correct in your attempt to analyze my particular situation.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> categorizing me without any evidence as a victim of violence You literally describe the violence you were targeted with. Your personal view that this violence was justified and is part of a beneficial pattern of violence does not negate that it is violence.
- zaphirplane 4y agoAh the old any other opinion is mental defect
- vidarh 4y agoNo, a description of why personal anecdotes from victims of violence often contradict the total absence of data showing the purported benefits often used by said victims to try to justify and make sense of the abuse they were subjected to. If there were data showing improved outcomes among this group compared to those not subjected to violence, there'd be reason to listen to their accounts, but since there isn't independent evidence to support these claims, and it's not a controlled sample, their anecdotes have little value.
- sershe 4y agoIs there any evidence for it being "harmful" (specifically institutional punishment, not random poor parenting)? If anything, constant reported decline in kids' (and adults') mental health as schools and parents get more and more protective indicates coddling might be the harmful abuse.