2 ms·
I've always wondered why assault statutes don't apply in these scenarios. I presume in loco parentis is a defense? Is this something that is well tested by th
by kube-system 4y ago
I've always wondered why assault statutes don't apply in these scenarios. I presume in loco parentis is a defense? Is this something that is well tested by the courts in the places where this still takes place?
- tptacek 4y agoMy understanding is that it's explicitly drawn from English common law; it's not derived from "in loco parentis", but rather a specific exception to the rule about assault. In the states that ban it (and the major cities in most of the states that don't), it's assault, of course.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> I've always wondered why assault statutes don't apply in these scenarios. Because assault statutes have an exception for lawful force, and the applicable laws (either statute or common law) provide a legal privilege. > I presume in loco parentis is a defense? Not a “defense”, but in some schemes it may be part of the legal basis. (In states where there is a parental option, this is clearly the case.) > Is this something that is well tested by the courts in the places where this still takes place? It is worth noting that most of the explicit rules prohibiting or regulating corporal punishment are the outcome of debate in the late 70s and into the 80s triggered by a 1977 US Supreme Court decision that found, in the absence of state law to the contrary, that corporal punishment in public schools was legal, even when contrary to the express wishes of parents. Very few states had any explicit law on the issue prior to that point.