4 ms·
I don't think it's safe to measure various health care systems against each other. The prevailing theories these days seem to suggest that most of the problems
by mattmaroon 18y ago
I don't think it's safe to measure various health care systems against each other. The prevailing theories these days seem to suggest that most of the problems are due to lifestyle. Diet, pollution, obesity, exercise levels, etc. all play a major part as well, and those have little to do with the health system. So I don't think it's safe to say that publicly funded health systems would work as well here as they do elsewhere.
Also, I always try to resolve arguments on practical grounds first. For instance, I feel that moral stances on drug laws are irrelevant, because the facts show that drug laws don't stop drug use, cause violent crime and many deaths of dealers/distributors, policemen and civilians. So even if you accept that drug use is immoral, just like with alcohol before it the laws still should not be on the books.
A law that has almost entirely negative effects is not a good law no matter what the moral justification.
- netcan 18y agoI don't think it's safe to measure various health care systems against each other OK. How about measuring various health care systems against themselves? What I am putting forward is that given that we are talking about improvement in the types of metrics used to compare health care systems, the US system would improve it's output by being public to an extent. Various implementations are possible from direct government ownership of hospitals to means-tested health care subsidies & everything in between. Obviously crappy implementation has the ability to make things worse. But within the realm of the currently probable, steps taken in that direction would probably lead to an improved result. But again, that's a purely technical line of argument. I think that in this case the rule of thumb economic liberalism is wrong. I'm reasonable happy to let economists bash that one out. But I do think that in the absense of an overwhelming victory for one of the practical debates, the moral argument here is very strong. practical grounds That's an area worthy of discussion in itself. Even if you do believe that drug use is deeply immoral, but see that the consequences of prohibition on are so severe, it'd be very rational to let it slide. But then, I wonder what I would think if I did understand drug use to be deeply immoral in the same sense as rape or murder is immoral. Would I allow legalised rape if the long term if the consequences of prohibiting it were as severe as the drug case. I dn't know how to answer that. (*Most would say no to a purely utilitarian approach http://www.nysun.com/arts/putting-practice-into-ethics/69595/ http://www.nysun.com/arts/putting-practice-into-ethics/69595...) For me that particular issue is all about practical. It's hard for me to see any justification for drug prohibition on moral grounds, just the opposite. It's an infringement on liberties. So there have to be net benefit reasons. But I would consider the flipside. In Australia (where I live) Alcohol & gambling are legal. Certain communities (usually extremely remote communities) here have severe social problems linked to abuse of these. Very severe. Some have decided that Alcohol prohibition (like dry counties in the states) are necessary to get the situation under control. Even though I think individuals should have the right to consume alcohol, in these circumstances the prohibition creates large net gain for the community. I'm OK with that.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- mattmaroon 18y agoI think even in the case of rape, practical grounds matter. If making it illegal didn't decrease the amount of rapes but increased violence and furthered the profits of organized crime families, why would one make it illegal? You'd simply have to attack the problem from another angle, as we should be doing (but aren't) with drugs. Of course there are gray areas. What if rape laws decreased rape by 10%, but increased other forms of violent crime double that? But in general, if a law's overwhelming result is negative, like our drug and gambling prohibitions, there's no point to them no matter how moral they may be. The money and effort would be much better spent on prevention and rehabilitation. Unless your communities that are so afflicted are much different than ours, I expect prohibition won't work much better for you than it does for us. People are going to get what they want. Demand for vices seems to be inelastic the world over.
- netcan 18y agoI think even in the case of rape, practical grounds matter. People disagree with you instinctively. It seems that we have Deontological tendencies by nature. Mostly people do not find utilitarian arguments compelling. You have to weight the scales very far in favour of utility before people will violate a principle. the dry communities It's an extreme case. These are mostly very small very isolated (like 2 days drive to a store) communities. Generally self imposed by direct democracy or community elders/leaders. I don't know if it works. I don't know if it helps. But that is besides what I was saying. Assuming it's a net gain, I approve. *It's interesting that we arrived here from the public health care questions. I'm actually surprised that someone open to a 100% practical outcome argument would be so against public healthcare. I expected more fundamental objections: despite the net loss..
- mattmaroon 18y agoYeah, I instinctively disagree with the rape issue too. In fact, I wrote that, thought about it, and deleted it.