4 ms·
maybe one country or another will outlaw generative ai or ai art or media synthesis or whatever it ends up being called, but presumably they'll be left behind b
by kragen 4y ago
maybe one country or another will outlaw generative ai or ai art or media synthesis or whatever it ends up being called, but presumably they'll be left behind by rapid cultural and technical development in whatever countries don't
the cat is out of the bag, the worms are out of the can, the feathers have blown away in the wind
these developments seem very likely to be central to programming, all other kinds of engineering, conceptual art, scenography, costuming, technical illustration, and pornography, within a couple of years, even if (against all odds) development on the neural nets themselves makes no further progress; they enable you to do things in minutes that previously would have taken days, things which are core parts of the feedback loop driving these disciplines
if every country in the world except thailand bans it then within ten years all your kids will be secretly watching prohibited thai movies with software secretly written in thailand on surreptitiously thai-designed computers, riding thai bicycles
even if deepfakes mean that the most significant effect of ai art is enabling massive fraud, spam, and mitm attacks, banning it locally won't stop you from falling victim to it (fraud is already illegal) but just from developing effective defenses against it
- echelon 4y ago100%. Furthermore, if we adopt current copyright laws to AI rather than understand the entire world is changing, only the largest AI companies will be able to leverage the technology to train their models. If it requires every film in existence to train a model, only Disney or Disney licensors will be able to operate. That's not good for competition. It might make it even harder to grow up as an independent creative or startup as it presents an impenetrable moat. As I currently see it, weakening copyright is the only way to assure democratic access to this technology.
- lelanthran 4y agoIf it really turns out to be a problem then copyright holders are simply going to add in a not-licensed-for-training clause in all their licenses[1]. Sure, existing works already licensed can still be used, but at least both parties (copyright holders and AI trainers) won't have anything to argue about. [1] Anyone from CC reading this? Make it the default.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- CrimsonRain 4y agoIt is like adding a clause in the license that you are not allowed to read the license. The moment you share your creation/work to someone/the world, you are training their nn. You can not share something publicly and then demand "xyz" can not view it. Viewing is training. You are free to keep your creation under lock & key and only share with nn (of people and/or AI) of your choice.
- lelanthran 4y ago> You can not share something publicly and then demand "xyz" can not view it. That's nonsense. Licenses have clauses on how the content may be used. Clauses along the lines of "The content may not be used for ..." are common. I dunno where you heard that once you release something the license clauses no longer apply, but it's wrong.
- kragen 4y agomany of these clauses are legally unenforceable because you can violate them without infringing on any of the rights that copyright law grants exclusively to the copyright holder (who can license them)
- lelanthran 4y ago> many of these clauses are legally unenforceable because you can violate them without infringing on any of the rights that copyright law grants exclusively to the copyright holder (who can license them) That's news to Microsoft[1], who's shared source and various NDA licenses for the source code already has clauses restricting what you can do with it. [1] I think the problem is that the pro-AI arguments are coming from people who are not aware that clauses in licenses restricting how the content is used is quite common. For example, you were obviously not aware that they were so common that almost every big tech and/or software company of the past and the present already have those clauses in, and those clauses have already been found to be enforceable!
- jimbo9991 4y agoI'm still troubled by some of the implications of the technology and think it would be a good idea to have some countries take a hard Luddite stance against AI, but that doesn't mean I think you are wrong. I have trouble with the assumption that what is good for efficiency and reducing human labor is necessarily good for us, but it does imply those that don't go along with the efficiency increases will be destroyed by those that do. With generative AI I'm mostly concerned with what it will do to the next generation of artists. I don't think I would have ever had the motivation to pursue music if it had been possible to replicate perfectly with AI. I'm immensely thankful I got that opportunity and so I want the next generation to get it as well.
- kragen 4y agoi strongly agree with your first paragraph i think the second paragraph is a bit myopic, like hunter-gatherers observing agriculture and worrying whether the next generation will be able to track prey through plowed fields, or will allow their hunting skills to decay because it's easier to get meat by trading with the agriculturalists but that understates the case; ai (if this is really ai this time) is certainly a more significant innovation than agriculture, probably more significant than fire, on par with tools and language still, that says nothing about its moral valence
- gene-h 4y agoJapan has explicitly amended their copyright code to enable machine learning on copyrighted data.[0] [0]https://storialaw.jp/en/service/bigdata/bigdata-12 https://storialaw.jp/en/service/bigdata/bigdata-12
- zone411 4y agoVery interesting! This would give Japan a real competitive productivity advantage if ML tools are banned or severely hampered elsewhere. It would also mean that other countries would need to ban not just scraping but also the resulting code or AI-generated media.
- bombolo 4y agoI'm sure chatgpt would be of much less interest worldwide if it only spoke japanese.
- rogers18445 4y agoIt's surprising that so many people on this site side with the Luddites. The back pressure ML is generating is at this point too strong for anything to make any difference. Anyone who attempts to stop it will just be practicing self-sabotage.
- wruza 4y agoIt's surprising that so many people on this site side with the Luddites This is too reductive. The back pressure ML is generating is at this point too strong for anything to make any difference. This is wrong, regulation can make a difference. Anyone who attempts to stop it will just be practicing self-sabotage. This is a prospect worth evaluating organically. Learning the potential is much different from accepting self-fulfilling prophecies.
- rogers18445 4y ago> This is wrong, regulation can make a difference. Regulation is per country or bloc. With ML the value of defecting is so high that any regulation you impose on it which restricts its utility will amount to self-sabotage.
- kragen 4y agogenerally luddites are found among those with the deepest understanding of a new invention but i agree that in this case it's probably futile