4 ms·
> Without having more information, I'm guessing, probably you would not do it. Wrong. Pretty much every time I'd do it. Just coz. ;) What do you mean I'm "C
by justinclift 4y ago
> Without having more information, I'm guessing, probably you would not do it.
Wrong. Pretty much every time I'd do it. Just coz. ;)
What do you mean I'm "Chaotic Neutral"? :p
- adastra22 4y agoActually I completely honestly would, and I'm confused that people wouldn't. That frog would hop off to lead a bleak, short, meaningless existence if I don't turn it into a person. Even if I wave the wand and make it human then fully abandon it, it'd still be a better outcome overall for a sentient being.
- solstice 4y agoDepending on what you mean by "fully abandoning it" that doesn't seem to track with humans being loss-averse as has been shown in (I believe) many psychological studies. Meaning most people vastly prefer remaining at a low level than to even lose a tiny bit. The fate of a frog becoming human and then being discarded shortly afterwards would be judged to be much more terrible by most people than the frog never becoming human in the first place.
- adastra22 4y agoWell that sounds like a moral philosophy that is alien, unappealing, and downright evil in its consequences. I mean, by that exact logic—if you truly believe it—you should be out euthanizing homeless people as a net win. Every human life has value. There is no instance where I would value the life of a frog over the life of a human being. By logical consequence, I should always prefer one more human over one more frog. QED.
- rom-antics 4y ago> Every human life has value. You say that because you're a human. If you were a frog, I bet you'd value frogs' lives more than humans. Why do you think it's your place to change others' lives into whatever form you personally prefer?
- amanaplanacanal 4y agoBy your logic, everybody should make as many babies as possible. I know there are people that claim to believe that.
- solstice 4y agoWe may be talking past each other and I don't follow the part about euthanasia you lay out at all. My point is that it would be vastly more cruel to turn a frog into a human, let them live a little and then abandon them to fend for themselves after they've outlived their usefulness to me (which is how I understood your point above) than to leave the frog alone entirely. By turning them into a human you have acquired a degree of responsibility for their well being which I would argue you can't shirk under normal circumstances. (C.f. making babies.) This logic hinges on the assumptions that 1) humans have a higher state of consciousness than animals (which might be debatable in certain cases, ok) and 2) that a frog is indifferent towards its current state of existence because it doesn't know any better. Lastly, you write "every human life has value" but in that thought experiment in the OP, they are not humans so far so that logic doesn't hold. Just because you have the ability to elevate/create life of a higher consciousness, absolutely does not mean that you have to do so IMO and that it can be downright inhumane to do so. (Again, babies, contraception, abortions etc.)
- realo 4y agoInteresting. Now suppose some advanced alien had the power to advance _you_ to his level of sentience , thus cutting you off from everything you have known and loved, including your family. Would you let the alien do that?
- adastra22 4y agoMaybe. With a human being there’s an issue of consent. I don’t believe frogs are intelligent enough to be able to give informed consent, but for people that would be an issue. But setting aside the issue of consent, then yes. (Caveat: I don’t believe this hypothetical is possible anyway. I am of the opinion that there is a dividing line in sentience beyond which improvements are possible but are more like upgrades than something more radical. There’s a phase change between sentience and non-sentience, but no further ohase changes to be had (I think))
- throwanem 4y agoIt's a bold move to decry one moral philosophy as evil in its consequences, and advance as preferable another that's evil in its precepts.
- justinclift 4y agoHell yes. 100% every time.
- rom-antics 4y agoWhy is a frog's life more bleak and meaningless than a human's life? We can't understand animals' thoughts, but that doesn't mean they don't have them. A frog spends its time chilling in a pond and swimming all day. People pay good money for vacations where they can do exactly that. Sounds like a good life to me. If I was a frog and you turned me into a homeless guy who has to go get a job at an Amazon warehouse to afford food, I'd use my newfound intellectual capacity to plot revenge on you and everyone you love.
- adastra22 4y agoAnd getting eaten by birds. All life in nature (except of top predators like us) is harsh, brutal, and short.
- Dudeman112 4y agoAh, but in that case would they mind it being harsh, brutal, and short? Given the configuration of their mind's hardware On a side note, I get the impression most people just don't have a gut instinct for just how awful natural life is like for the most part
- andrewflnr 4y agoThey mind it about as much as we do, judging by how hard they try to avoid it. It's silly to assume we're so different from animals that we're the only ones who don't like pain and death.
- Dudeman112 4y agoBacteria also try really hard to avoid being harmed and killed, yet most people don't consider that sufficient for those living beings
- andrewflnr 4y agoI don't see how that's relevant to the question of whether frogs "mind" being skewered by birds, which is the question I read from your post.