20 ms·
Usually you need your weapon to move much faster than the target. A rocket, like s Javelin or an NLAW, apparently moves fast enough to hit s tank or an APC. Yo
by nine_k 4y ago
Usually you need your weapon to move much faster than the target. A rocket, like s Javelin or an NLAW, apparently moves fast enough to hit s tank or an APC. You don't necessarily need much-much faster, but it's important to pack a punch.
But against a rocket you need a weapon that's much faster than a rocket. A laser (or a maser) reaches a rocket in negligible time, and may be very fast to retarget.
A rocket can't have ablative armor on the side, it will be blown away instantly. Landing space capsules have an ablative cover on the bottom. Also, landing capsules only decelerate, so they can afford to carry much more mass for evaporation than a rocket that needs to accelerate and maneuver.
The best a rocket can do us to become highly shiny. It's not as easy though to be shiny in a wider spectrum, from optical to deep IR or even sub-millimeter. I can imagine a multi-color ray gun :)
So I think ray guns are going to be more widespread as anti-missile defense systems, to intercept incoming rockets, warheads, and even shells. At least one actually exists (in Israel), and works.
- consumer451 4y ago> So I think ray guns are going to be more widespread as anti-missile defense systems The issue as highlighted by the situation in UA is that the highest-tech weapons cannot be deployed to the front lines where they are needed, as they might fall into the enemy's hands and be reverse engineered. I am much more interested in hacked low-tech solutions. For example, walls of anti-air racing drone style quadcopters which can seek out an Iranian drone and just ram it. I am a little surprised that we have not seen these yet.
- dsq 4y agoLaser defense is fundametally short range, so it's best use case is probably behind the front lines, to defend your air force bases and keep the air power active. Also to defend ships. Critical infrastructure such as fuel depots, power stations. Anything up to a few kilometers. This also means your lasers are connected to power lines. The best idea is to keep your rear echelons free from missile and drone harrassment, so you can focus your attention on the offensive. Drone swarms are an interesting idea as well.
- consumer451 4y ago> Drone swarms are an interesting idea as well. I am curious if the US defense industry is up to the task of delivering such systems at a cost level which can be implemented in places like UA. Otherwise the most significant systems may be developed by other sources. This honestly scares me a bit, as given the alternatives, I am a fan of the predictability of Pax Americana.
- pksebben 4y agommmm. ah dunno bout that. I'll take pax Europa a lot quicker.
- consumer451 4y agoI'm OK with that as well! Should be even better. The only problem is that this project is about 40 years behind in budget and political will in most European countries. It's a travesty which is being paid for in Ukrainian blood as we speak.
- ethbr0 4y agoA Switchblade-300 is $6k. Phoenix Ghost is a few hundred dollars. Both easily within range of Ukraine.
- WastingMyTime89 4y ago> For example, walls of anti-air racing drone style quadcopters which can seek out an Iranian drone and just ram it. I am a little surprised that we have not seen these yet. Quadcopters can’t carry much, are slow and can easily be stopped by a marksman with a rifle or a fixed SCG. They are a lot more useful for recon than as offensive weapons. Plus drones are a lot more nimble and can fly at height where a quadcopter becomes useless.
- consumer451 4y agoI'm sorry, but this is wrong on nearly every count. A moving quad is really hard to hit by gun, see the yearly DARPA challenges. A racing style quad is way more nimble than any winged aircraft I have ever flown or seen. A quad tasked with knocking out an Iranian winged style drone just needs to foul the propulsion, no need to carry anything aside from some trailing weed trimmer cord or durable plastic sheet. The only practical limit on quad max altitude is the FAA/DJI control limitation which is easily bypassed on my quad. Also, all the cruise missiles style winged drones fly relatively low. The only real challenge is getting in the flight path of said Iranian drone. I really hope someone is working on this as we have been told that we can take out freaking airliners with cheap drones, on accident, for a long time now.
- WastingMyTime89 4y ago> A moving quad is really hard to hit by gun A properly trained human with a military rifle can hit a quad easily. A FCS controlling a military gun does mince meat of them. > A racing style quad is way more nimble than any winged aircraft I have every flown or seen. That has zero carrying capacity. Even then, you clearly haven’t flown or seen much if you are impressed by the manoeuvrability of a quad. A fixed wing drone will just toy with it. Quads, even racing quads, are unbelievably slow. That’s inherent to their design. > The only practical limit on quad max altitude is the FAA/DJI control limitation which are easily bypassed on my quad. You are confused about what kind of altitude we are talking about here. > The only real challenge is getting in the flight path of said Iranian drone. The only real challenge to going to the Moon is jumping high enough. There is a reason quads are not used offensively and it’s not because no one thought about it.
- cm2187 4y ago> A rocket, like s Javelin or an NLAW, apparently moves fast enough to hit s tank or an APC. You don't necessarily need much-much faster, but it's important to pack a punch. that's also what I thought but it doesn't seem to work that way. For the NLAW at least, all the missile does it to position the explosive charge above the tank. The missile doesn't hit the tank from the side, so the kinetic energy isn't contributing to the destruction. So from a logical point of view, I assume you could position the same warhead with a slow moving consumer drone and get the same result. https://www.economist.com/media-assets/image/20220122_WOC909.png https://www.economist.com/media-assets/image/20220122_WOC909...
- meepmorp 4y agoTop attack is primarily a way to exploit the fact that most tanks are weakly armored on top. The speed (not KE, per se) trade off make sense because it makes a kill more likely by positioning the warhead for better penetration. That doesn't make sense for aircraft - even slow drones which are still a lot faster than tanks and move in 3 dimensions. Faster weapons means less time for the target to escape, which is always better even when guided missiles.
- nine_k 4y agoA slow-moving helicopter drone may be not fast enough because a tank can make 50 km/h, much like the drone. Even a standing tank is usually attacked froma distance of 500-700m, not much closer (except in an urban environment). While the drone is flying towards a tank, the tank may have enough time to detect it and shoot it down. You ideally need something an order of magnitude faster. Unlike a rocket, a drone can loiter, stay high enough above to be less detectable. The most successful anti-armor drone so far, the Bayraktar, is a large winged drone that shoots fast rockets downwards.
- WastingMyTime89 4y ago> Usually you need your weapon to move much faster than the target. That’s an extremely wrong take. The corner stone of missile defence is that the missile already has enough kinetic energy to destroy itself. The way anti-missile system works is by creating a cloud of obstacles close enough to the approaching missile that it can’t avoid some. That can be done with another missile exploding close by, a very large burst of bullets for a CIWS system or even a shell if you are trying to stop something slower. That’s why efficient laser systems are so hard to actually make. They can’t use the kinetic energy of their target.
- nine_k 4y agoYou need an anti-rocket munition to move faster than the rocket so that the rocket does not hit its target while the anti-rocket munition is on the way. It's not about the speed of impact. Also, for an offensive weapon, the munition should move fast enough to reach a moving target. It should reach the target quickly enough to make evasive maneuvering harder, and to not be destroyed by protective fire en route.
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoThat's apparently dead wrong. Patriot anti-missile system would just position the ordnance in the way of an incoming rocket. They would collide and explode in the air.