3 ms·
What kind of certainty? All else equal, (1) when the punishment for the crime is severe, you'd want to be more certain that the convicted criminal is actually g
by thaumasiotes 4y ago
What kind of certainty? All else equal, (1) when the punishment for the crime is severe, you'd want to be more certain that the convicted criminal is actually guilty ("It's bad when innocent men are punished."); (2) when the crime is not very serious, you don't really care whether the convict is guilty or not (because we assume the punishment is not very severe). So we want more certainty-of-guilt in case 1 and less certainty-of-guilt in case 2.
We can also ask for certainty that people who are guilty in fact get convicted. ("It's bad when guilty men go free.") This is the opposite of the other kind of certainty. Here, we'd want a lot of that type of certainty for crimes with severe punishments (we assume that such crimes are very serious), and we don't really care about this for crimes with no particular impact on victims. So we want more certainty-of-conviction in case 1 and less certainty-of-conviction in case 2.
Certainty-of-conviction and certainty-of-guilt are, in the general case, directly in conflict with each other. We don't want either (in a relative sense) for trivial crimes, so it doesn't really matter what happens. We want lots of both for serious crimes, so what happens matters, but we can't actually achieve both goals.
In conclusion, when setting your policy, you need to look at other aspects of the crime than the one(s) you mention here, which are not informative as to this question. (Though they are informative as to the question you literally asked; we want more certainty of every type on serious crimes.) Perhaps the punishment for a particular crime is out of proportion to how serious that crime is. If the punishment is too heavy, we'd want more certainty-of-guilt; if it's too light, we'd want more certainty-of-conviction. Perhaps it's much easier than usual to reliably determine guilt-in-fact for a particular crime. Then we'd want more certainty-of-conviction.
- watwut 4y ago> whether the convict is guilty or not (because we assume the punishment is not very severe) There is nonsuch thing. Even short conviction destroys people's ability to hold jobs, find housing and to find partners. People inyour life stop trusting you and that is super big one too. And it may cause divorce with law abiding lartner and factor into custody dispute. Any Criminal conviction has huge ramifications.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoIn the face of all this complexity, I think it is not "obvious that you'd want to set this differently for different crimes." It is clear the perfect certainty would be ideal, if possible. It is not clear to me that variable standards are desirable from a practical standpoint. The relevance of a Blackstone number is it basically sets all this aside and looks at an ideal circumstance, and you can adjust from there, if you want to take peculiarites into account.