3 ms·
> But at the end of the day, it basically just comes down to how many calories you put in your body. What about this study[1], which fed twin pairs a carefully
by gruez 4y ago
> But at the end of the day, it basically just comes down to how many calories you put in your body.
What about this study[1], which fed twin pairs a carefully controlled diet, but nonetheless resulted in huge variances in weight gain ("The mean weight gain was 8.1 kg, but the range was 4.3 to 13.3 kg") between twin pairs? Surely if your body weight was determined by CICO, we'd expect everyone to gain the same amount of weight given the same calories/diet?
[1] https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/nejm199005243222101 https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/nejm199005243222101
- 0x5345414e 4y agoI don’t see how this challenges the CICO argument at all. Weight gain is just a function of calories absorbed and calories burned. You can dig into the details of what those two numbers might be for different people but it doesn’t change what the function is. That being said, CICO is bordering on being a truism and not really adding much to a discussion on weight gain.
- layer8 4y ago> Surely if your body weight was determined by CICO, we'd expect everyone to gain the same amount of weight given the same calories/diet? Only if you also control for calories out, which is difficult to do.
- tekla 4y agoCICO is a determination about the fact that humans obey the laws of the thermodynamics and cannot create mass from nothing. The fact that different people metabolize differently doesn't refute that. If you stop eating/eat very small amounts of food, you WILL lose weight. It is literally impossible for you not to do so. It doesn't matter if you drink pure corn syrup, eat twinkies, or Big Macs. If you limit to some arbitrary number of lets say 500 calories a day you WILL lose weight. The military has done extensive research on this because of logistical concerns, and have very well documented studies on calories required to keep soldiers active on the field. Any argument to the contrary is literally arguing that humans break physics and can get fat from nothing.
- hombre_fatal 4y agoI think the real point is that CICO ends up just boiling away into a trivial statement yet people fling it around as some actionable mantra. For example you can’t actually calculate CI and especially not CO. You can just try to approximate them which is just “eat less to lose weight” yet people throw around CICO as if it illuminates anything interesting, especially when it seems to be brought up as a counter to eating healthier. Turns out can’t actually eat all that much of something like broccoli, so “eat healthy” remains good advice.
- tekla 4y agoIt doesnt illuminate anything interesting because weight loss is inherently uninteresting. There are TV shows that show people who claim they have trouble losing weight even though they diet and eat healthy, and when you see what you eat, its some ungodly amount of calorie dense food. There are athletes who plan their diets and workouts based around trying to make weight for competitions which involve planned amounts of weight drop for a target date. People who dont lose weight simply are LYING to themselves. They claim they track calories, but usually its eyed and not measured calories, they simply "forget" about the snack they had, or they "treat themselves" frequently for "good diet behavior" As a former extremely obese person, seeing people continually lie to themselves about a literal physical law about matter creation pisses me off. Losing 150 pounds was EASY the moment I realized I had to stop LYING to myself.
- DougN7 4y agoCICO is true, and it’s the same as saying being an excellent driver is merely controlling friction and inertia. Factually true, but almost meaningless in and of itself.
- bitL 4y agoI've read that there is a huge difference between not eating anything at all and eating just a little. The former leading to rapid loss of weight while functioning somewhat normally, the latter to body shutting down and entering starvation mode. In other words, the stored body fat is not utilized unless there are no other options and if there are, body prefers to shut down instead of taping into reserves. The exception would be HIIT and similar training regimes that seem to lead to weight loss based on fat but those are typically out of reach of a regular obese person (but would work for athletes that bulked up).