3 ms·
Sounds like a great way to remember your gesture. But it also sounds like a great way to pick an extremely obvious gesture (e.g. outline of the house) that some
by eridius 15y ago
Sounds like a great way to remember your gesture. But it also sounds like a great way to pick an extremely obvious gesture (e.g. outline of the house) that someone else can guess. If your gesture is based on prominent features in the picture, that greatly limits the search space for an attacker.
- JoshTriplett 15y agoExactly. This seems even less secure than the Android "lock pattern" mechanism, which at least provides a grid of nine features and no obvious reason to choose any particular set. (Despite that, I suspect many people use the same patterns.) The examples given in the article provide little to no security, while giving a novice user the illusion of security. Ideally, this ought to have gone through extensive practical security testing: what pictures and patterns do users pick, and how easily can others guess those patterns? I could understand the aversion to passwords if people had to remember a pile of them, but they don't. You only need to memorize one: the password to unlock your personal system. Can people really not remember one secure password?
- Karunamon 15y ago>Can people really not remember one secure password? Answer: No - and then you're asking to get fully compromised when the (good and secure!) password gets revealed from some service somewhere not following best practices.
- JoshTriplett 15y agoNo service should ever have your secure password. It should unlock your personal system, which can then remember all the (different, random, and secure) passwords or keys for any other service you use.
- Retric 15y agoYour assuming the average users machine is secure. I don't think that's necessarily true. For most people, a list of common passwords stored under their keyboard is probably more secure than an encrypted file on their HDD.
- JoshTriplett 15y agoIf you don't have a secure machine to enter passwords in, it doesn't matter where you store them.