6 ms·
New York got it wrong on cybersecurity and the right to repair
- Cypher 4y ago[flagged]
- jplona 4y agoWhat does this comment contribute to the discussion?
- LegitShady 4y ago>It was a victory because the Digital Fair Repair Act is the first law in the nation to enshrine the right of consumers to have access to the information and parts needed to repair their electronics. >It was a defeat because of a host of last-minute amendments, at Hochul’s request, that weakened the law. It was pure defeat. the purpose of passing it toothless is to be able to say "look we passed it" and the purpose of making it toothless was to to make the passing of it meaningless. It became a 100% waste of time and effort, circumvented by politicians in corporations pockets who don't care about anything but ingratiating themselves into the wallets of the rich for future funding.
- donmcronald 4y agoPlus, the longer they can keep 3rd parties locked out of repairs, the longer they have to retrain the entire industry with propaganda that dictates what should be fixed vs replaced. What happens after a generation or two of the workforce is trained by industry groups that are approved by the companies that don't want us to be able to repair or control our devices? IMO, the lie about non-repair-ability becomes accepted as fact, the expertise from people that know it's a lie isn't passed on, and suddenly the lie becomes the truth because there's no one left that knows how to perform the repairs that were deemed unprofitable.
- mindslight 4y agoI feel like that ship sailed long ago (unfortunately), with the trend of replacing entire subassemblies rather than building devices/subassemblies to be field diagnosed and repaired. Semi-related rant: I recently bought a Haynes manual for a '15 Civic. I figured it would, at the very least, have thorough wiring diagrams and describe the physical layouts of the wiring harnesses. Nope - over half is just generic information about tools and general car repair. The "wiring diagram" is woefully incomplete - it shows one single reference to a "CAN Bus" off the ECU, rather than the 7 or so devices on one bus, and 10+ on the second bus. Luckily I managed to stumble upon a 15k-page OEMish service manual that details a lot of this stuff (via procedures, rather than easier-to-read diagrams, but at least its authoritative). I know car repair information has been obfuscated and proprietarized by manufacturers, but it looks like Haynes isn't even trying. Either at least document what's physically there, or just stop pretending to sell a repair manual. (I'm not opposed to going to the dealer if I can't figure it out. I've just heard too many stories of people having electrical/control issues, and the stealership goes on a wild goose chase replacing part after part. So I figured I'd take a crack at it first)
- bluGill 4y agoHaynes was always that way. Okay for basics like spark plugs, but not much else.. there are others, which are somewhat better. The OEM manuals are generally available and great.
- mindslight 4y agoThat's disappointing. I had thought I heard good things about them over the years, and finally had occasion to buy one (previous cars I'd managed to find service manuals online straight away). So much for the "complete teardown and rebuild."
- andrei_says_ 4y agoLet’s not confuse misunderstanding of technological requirements and limitations with intentional lies and corruption.
- Entinel 4y agoSaying they got it wrong implies they tried to get it right. The NY Right to Repair bill was sabotage plain and simple.
- sambull 4y agoSabotaged at the end with a precision cut
- chasil 4y agoProfoundly bad leadership, that was bought. Sincere thanks to our legislators for your deep commitment to monied corporate interests. The founders would be proud of you.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> NY Right to Repair bill was sabotage plain and simple I've been out of New York politics for over a year. Who sabotaged it? And who is the constituency with pull in New York opposing right to repair?
- Entinel 4y agoJust to add some background, the Right to Repair bill passed in NY legislature and went to the governor. Kathy Hochul then amended the bill heavily before signing it into law. As far as who is opposed to right to repair in NY, take your pick, everyone from Apple to John Deere have to fighting against this for years.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> take your pick Someone exerted influence. It would be useful to know whom. I’m failing to think of an obvious in-state employer with the motivation and pull to demand this.
- walterbell 4y agoTechNet was one of the trade groups lobbying on right-to-repair, https://www.technet.org/our-story/members/ https://www.technet.org/our-story/members/
- mrjin 4y agoThe question is that have they ever tried to get it right?
- walterbell 4y agoWhen a negotiating party acts in bad faith, this can motivate creative reciprocal responses. If "right to repair" is being blocked, expand the Overton Window to "right to modify". Create a yearly Transformed Electronics contest for creative mods to consumer devices. Add new features, remove unwanted features. If everything is declared impossible, then anything is possible. Repair shops can compete in electronics surgery, expanding the art of the possible. Create a super-premium market for modified devices, where incremental revenue goes to repair shops and not the original vendor. Since modified devices cannot use a vendor warranty, that redirects consumer budget to warranties provided by repair shops. Grow the market for quality 3rd-party components. Promote OSS firmware and vendors of modular, repair-friendly products like the Framework laptop. HN ranking graph for this story: https://hnrankings.info/34460821/ https://hnrankings.info/34460821/
- nebula8804 4y agoThese things are being made illegal using the DMCA. So if you go public with this you are risking imprisonment. Thats always the end state of the bureaucracy.
- walterbell 4y ago> These things are being made illegal Please provide examples of "these things" that you consider within the scope of the U.S. DMCA, which is limited to copyright protection. It's not illegal to purchase a device and modify it, nor to pay a repair shop to modify your device. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First-sale_doctrine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First-sale_doctrine https://apnews.com/article/305f5bcbef3e4ec688df3a5dd3ceba12 https://apnews.com/article/305f5bcbef3e4ec688df3a5dd3ceba12 > For many car owners, their vehicle is an extension of their personality — and as such they customize it to reflect their individuality and uniqueness. That’s particularly true for young car enthusiasts ages 16 to 24, who spend $7.2 billion each year customizing their vehicles, according to a recent study by the Specialty Equipment Market Association (SEMA). “More than 7.9 million young people customize, modify or upgrade their vehicles each year,” says SEMA Director-Market Research Gavin Knapp. “Their vehicles not only help them get from A to B, they are also an integral part of their social lives.
- Cypher 4y ago[flagged]
- musicale 4y ago> Disabling software locks that prevent repair has no bearing on the cybersecurity of covered devices. This is presented without adequate proof. It is plainly not true for hardware locks and physical security. For example, a car with a sealed, inaccessible engine would be hard to repair and maintain, but also harder to tamper with or sabotage, and it would be harder for thieves to steal the catalytic converter. But what if the engine compartment door is controlled by software that only permits access by authorized repair providers? The same argument applies. Similarly, a device or OS that refuses to run unsigned or unauthorized device drivers might interfere with repairs such as replacing component devices with new ones that required new drivers, but would likely interfere with the operation of unauthorized, driver-based malware. There are clear counterexamples disproving the claim that disabling software locks that prevent repair has no bearing on security ("cyber" or otherwise.) On the contrary, software locks that make benevolent repair harder can also make malicious tampering (to hardware and/or software) more difficult as well.
- kris_wayton 4y agoAssuming the catalytic converter is underneath the car, making that particular area inaccessible would be a lot less headache than the engine bay.
- musicale 4y agoIndeed. There may be an interesting analogy there about primary and secondary purposes and effects. ;-) However, the same basic argument applies: harder to repair/replace, but also harder to steal or tamper with.
- 6510 4y agoBluntly put: Making it harder is not security. Security is not a pile of obfuscation and hoping it will make things difficult enough. Lets forget your analogy with stealing car parts. We can just do that :) Lets have the realistic or real world settings where we are all purchasing incredibly cheap IoT devices that bring us all kinds of wonderful functionality. Businesses, factories or brands making incredibly cheap stuff are not very stable. They make a popular widget for a while then dissolve and everyone moves on. They can also move on to the next version of their product abolishing support for previous version. If build reasonably well and used rarely or carefully such devices can last for many decades. It thus is guaranteed for a large percentage of the devices to not have a single authorized repair provider for the longest period of their usage. Real security holes will be found, bugs will be exploited, they will be easy to find online and come with a life time guarantee to work. The analogy would be a catalytic converter that might explode. You shouldn't drive this car in your drive way. You should buy a brand new one from the same brand! But doesn't that have the same catalytic converter? Maybe! But as long as you don't know about it you are safe! Their 15.4 has just been released and non of them exploded! Stop being poor!
- toomanyrichies 4y agohttps://archive.ph/NUoQ8 https://archive.ph/NUoQ8