4 ms·
That’s a remarkable assertion, given that there’s plenty of countries where strong taboos on having multiple sexual partners has effectively controlled diseases
by rayiner 4y ago
That’s a remarkable assertion, given that there’s plenty of countries where strong taboos on having multiple sexual partners has effectively controlled diseases such as AIDs. For example, AIDS prevalence in Egypt and Pakistan (which have relatively well developed healthcare systems with accurate statistics, and are also the target of extensive western healthcare aid and associated scrutiny) is just 0.1%. In the United States it’s 0.36% and in many countries it’s well over 1%.
Many poor countries have largely been spared the ravages of the AIDS epidemic because it is in fact possible for societies to reduce risky sexual behavior if they choose to do so.
- JamesBarney 4y agoWhile it's possible in theory to undo the sexual revolution in the US, it's also would be practically impossible.
- rayiner 4y agoThat’s probably true. I’m just pointing out that “we can’t” is a different argument than “we like it this way and are willing to put up with the consequences.”
- crystaln 4y agoIt would also be a huge regression for humanity IMO.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoIt’s happening slowly already due to which world views are repopulating and which are doing the opposite…
- tptacek 4y agoThe countries with the highest prevalence of AIDS overwhelmingly do not share the taboos (or lack thereof) of the United States.
- rayiner 4y agoThey don’t share the culture of the US, but they lack the stringent taboos on risky sexual activity that exist in Asia and the Middle East. The unmarried birth rate in China, India, North Africa, and South Asia is just around 1% https://archive-yaleglobal.yale.edu/content/out-wedlock-births-rise-worldwide https://archive-yaleglobal.yale.edu/content/out-wedlock-birt.... In countries like Kenya which have high AIDS prevalence rates, unmarried births are around 30%. Similarly, the only Asian country with high levels of unmarried births, the Philippines (what is it with former Spanish colonies) is contending with an AIDS epidemic: https://pulitzercenter.org/stories/philippines-hiv-cases-could-reach-133000-2022 https://pulitzercenter.org/stories/philippines-hiv-cases-cou...
- tptacek 4y agoYou see how this can be knocked down as a just-so story, right? You started out with a statistical narrative that, to say the least, doesn't hold up.
- rayiner 4y ago“Countries that stigmatize and punish sex outside of marriage inexplicably have low levels of sexually transmitted diseases. Social scientists at a loss for any explanation.” You’ll struggle to find air tight explanations for any sociological phenomenon. But as far as such correlations go this is a pretty compelling one. Certainly if I’m in Asia I wouldn’t be inclined to mess with a system that seems to be working.
- tptacek 4y agoYou tried to make that argument, 2 comments ago, with a trivial statistical argument that fell apart the moment anyone breathed on it. Given the motte has fallen, it seems futile to make a stand at the bailey, right? I don't even know how much we disagree about this fuzzy, subjective values discussion here; I'm just interested in the argument I responded to originally.