4 ms·
Meh, old reactor tech with new "engineered" safety features. I would have liked to see stuff more like FAST or slow wave reactors with inherent physics based sa
by giantg2 4y ago
Meh, old reactor tech with new "engineered" safety features. I would have liked to see stuff more like FAST or slow wave reactors with inherent physics based safety features.
- PaulHoule 4y agoA big part of the problem with today's reactors is that they are full of water which requires huge heat exchangers (often bigger than the reaction vessel but still safety critical) and have a huge steam turbine. Even if heat were free you'd have a hard time making the steam turbine powerset competitive in 2023. Nuclear might be able to compete if we can get rid of the water. In Japan they are talking about producing hydrogen directly with thermochemistry, no powerset at all. There is also talk about coupling fast reactors or molten salt reactors to this kind of powerset https://www.powermag.com/what-are-supercritical-co2-power-cycles/ https://www.powermag.com/what-are-supercritical-co2-power-cy... The claimed price of a NuScale reactor isn't going to beat a large LWR but it might possibly be able to build at the quote that NuScale quotes, whereas the large LWR struggles. If you want "the power to save the Earth" you have to get costs down and reactors that can do that are still a decade + out.
- giantg2 4y agoI'll have to look up the hydrogen one. I know the only DOE work I've heard of in the US is still hydrolysis. I thought they have small scale modupar FAST reactors. I would hope they would be similar on price, or at least quote accuracy.
- scythe 4y agoThermochemical hydrogen — solar or nuclear — has been studied for a while. The simulation thermodynamic efficiency numbers are excellent (beating electricity generation by 1.5-2x), but the reaction cycles in practice tend to leak process chemicals or corrode equipment too quickly to be sustainable (even losing, e.g., 0.1% of your iodine per cycle is unacceptable). I believe Japan is considering a reactor made of tantalum. Canada started such a project in 2010 that was supposed to be online by 2016ish but has continued hitting roadblocks.
- pfdietz 4y agoSulfuric acid vapor at 850 C is nasty stuff.
- Retric 4y agoThe steam loop is a tiny fraction of current nuclear reactors costs. If you didn’t need to worry about nuclear safety etc then a pure steam loop would be wildly profitable.
- PaulHoule 4y agoHave you seen how big the steam turbine is? There is a table here that estimates that only 28% of the cost is the "nuclear island" https://world-nuclear.org/information-library/economic-aspects/economics-of-nuclear-power.aspx https://world-nuclear.org/information-library/economic-aspec... the steam turbine and other systems that are bloated by low temperature overhead comprise much of the rest. Also some of the "nuclear island" such as the steam generators is also bloated by low temperature overhead. It is no accident that we stopped building coal-burning power plants at the same time we stopped building LWRs and that is because gas turbine power plants with much lower capital cost became available.
- Retric 4y ago28% of construction costs not total costs. If we are assuming magic such that you don’t need fuel then you also don’t need armed security, nuclear decommissioning etc etc.
- arcticbull 4y agoConstruction costs are the big cost in nuclear power. Uranium comprises between $0.0015/kWh and $0.000015/kWh. You don't really need armed security, but a couple guys with guns in America are a dime a dozen. Decomissioning is $300-400M after a 30-50Y lifecycle and operators are generally allowed to collect that money over the plant life. [1] That's compared to the $17B in construction costs for Vogtle. [1] https://www.nrc.gov/reading-rm/doc-collections/fact-sheets/decommissioning.html https://www.nrc.gov/reading-rm/doc-collections/fact-sheets/d...
- Retric 4y agoUranium costs are the kind of meaningless fact that’s true and wildly misleading. Fuel rods are not simply long sticks of unprocessed uranium. Refueling is expensive because of many separate costs. Even simply being forced to take a power plant offline for a long period is inherently expensive. Similarly building a cooling pond and equipment to move extremely high level nuclear waste is costly. Add up all those individual costs and fuel represents a significant faction of the total lifetime costs for a nuclear reactor.
- aclatuts 4y agoMaking it smaller does add physics based safety features that couldn't be achieved otherwise.
- Retric 4y agoUS’s biggest nuclear accident in terms of lives lost was on a tiny reactor. At best the worst case downside is limited, but so to is the amount of power generated.
- gpm 4y agoPersonally I'm not worried about the biggest nuclear accident so far. I'm worried about the potential future very unlikely but very severe nuclear accident that kills a non-negligible fraction of the population. An accident that makes Chernobyl look small.
- nomel 4y agoThis needs to be balanced with any loss of life from global warming. Some would want to consider non-human life in that calculation, as well. (I don't know enough about this to know if nuclear will have a large impact, in the grand scheme).
- gpm 4y agoSure, it's a risk vs reward thing and my comment was just focusing on the risk - a risk that I think is continually downplayed because we are bad at appreciating the costs of extremely unlikely but extremely bad events that have never occurred before. If the reward is high enough the risk might be justified. Personally I doubt it (mostly because economically solar + wind + power storage seems like a better bet), but that's a whole other discussion.
- fr0sty 4y agoThis accident? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SL-1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SL-1 "Stationary Low-Power Reactor Number One, also known as SL-1 or the Argonne Low Power Reactor (ALPR), was a United States Army experimental nuclear reactor in the western United States at the National Reactor Testing Station (NRTS), later the Idaho National Laboratory, west of Idaho Falls, Idaho. It experienced a steam explosion on the night of January 3, 1961, killing all three of its young military operators, and pinning one of them to the ceiling of the facility with a reactor vessel plug. The event is the only reactor accident in U.S. history that resulted in immediate fatalities.
- nickpinkston 4y agoI guess this would be the logical place for them to start, but hopefully it's just a start.
- Buttons840 4y agoReminds me of what we humorously learn from The System Bible[0]: "When a fail-safe system fails, it fails by failing to fail safely." The book mentions 3-miles island, where a problem in a secondary system (an added safety system) spread and caused the system as a whole to fail. This is a tongue-in-cheek way of illustrating a serious issue when designing systems, though I wonder if the interpretation of what happened at 3-miles island is a bit of a stretch? (And I may misremember the book.) "The accident to unit 2 happened at 4 am on 28 March 1979 when the reactor was operating at 97% power. It involved a relatively minor malfunction in the secondary cooling circuit which caused the temperature in the primary coolant to rise..."[1] [0]: https://www.amazon.com/Systems-Bible-Beginners-Guide-Large/dp/0961825170 https://www.amazon.com/Systems-Bible-Beginners-Guide-Large/d... [1]: https://world-nuclear.org/information-library/safety-and-security/safety-of-plants/three-mile-island-accident.aspx https://world-nuclear.org/information-library/safety-and-sec...
- retzkek 4y ago> a problem in a secondary system (an added safety system) "Secondary" in nuclear parlance for a PWR refers to the loop of water that cycles through the steam generators and turbines, while the "primary" loop cycles through the reactor and steam generators. Not to detract from your point, which is a good one, and the pressurizer relief valve that stuck open and through which the cooling water escaped was indeed an added safety system.
- credit_guy 4y agoPlenty of such stuff is going on. [1] is the list of reactors designs the Department of Energy is working on. [2] is the legwork the Nuclear Regulatory Commission is doing to prepare for the approval process on non light water reactor designs. As for the slow wave reactors, it looks like that idea was put on a back burner. Fast reactors are much more exciting anyway. [1] https://www.energy.gov/sites/default/files/2020/05/f74/Advanced-Reactor-Types_Fact-Sheet_Draft_Hi-Res_R1.pdf https://www.energy.gov/sites/default/files/2020/05/f74/Advan... [2] https://www.nrc.gov/reactors/new-reactors/advanced.html https://www.nrc.gov/reactors/new-reactors/advanced.html
- p1mrx 4y agoNuScale's main safety feature is an enormous pool of water, so the reactors can cool down without human intervention. That's more physics than engineering.
- giantg2 4y agoNot really. You have to engineer that water containment, delivery, and steam venting. Sure, it's making use of physics for some of those aspects, but there are still others that rely on how it was designed and manufactured.
- p1mrx 4y agoI don't disagree that there are more-elegant proposed reactors with more-inherent safety, but NuScale has an incremental/conservative design with 20 years of effort behind it. We need to fight climate change immediately, and prioritize "good enough and politically feasible" over "technically optimal" solutions.