4 ms·
This comment from a NYT opinion piece by former Slack CPO added some clarity as to one reason why tech companies are doing this: pressure from investors to keep
by insane_dreamer 4y ago
This comment from a NYT opinion piece by former Slack CPO added some clarity as to one reason why tech companies are doing this: pressure from investors to keep the share price up. Public companies lose that freedom to do whatever they want even if they have tons of money in the bank.
> Meta and Salesforce combined lost more than $700 billion in market cap last year. Both companies are now dealing with activist investors who have taken prominent positions in their stocks. The activists have called for the companies to slash costs, reduce nonstrategic investments and, notably in Meta’s case, aggressively reduce its work force.
edit: link to article: https://www.nytimes.com/2023/01/19/opinion/tech-layoffs-meta-amazon-silicon-valley.html https://www.nytimes.com/2023/01/19/opinion/tech-layoffs-meta...
- insane_dreamer 4y agoAnother comment on this: don't forget that no matter what these CEOs say about their workforce, we're family blah blah blah, they are first and foremost beholden to their shareholders. The very purpose of a capitalist corporation is to serve the interests of its shareholders, aka make more money; everything else is secondary.
- skybrian 4y agoThis is called "shareholder primacy" and it's more of an ideology than an actual legal requirement. It's going to be true to the extent that the company leadership believes it's true, and a lot of different strategies could be justified as serving the shareholders in the long run. Matt Levine has written a few columns about how this works out in practice, or doesn't.
- ROTMetro 4y agoCostco seems to do a pretty good job at saying no and they have not had repercussions.
- lazide 4y agoUnless the bylaws and structure are explicitly setup to be different, the shareholders elect the board, and the board appoints the corporate officers. So any board that doesn’t get the shareholders what they want doesn’t last long. And any corporate officers that don’t get the board what they want don’t last long either. Of course, many opportunities for ‘capture’, owner/agent issues, market perception and ‘fog of war’, etc. It’s an ideology for a reason, it’s the naive truth.
- insane_dreamer 4y agoBut the company leadership either has to be able to convince shareholders to stay the course (as Amazon famously did for years without generating profits as it grew), or has to have enough power to ward off the investors (bearing in mind that most investors are institutional not retail) because of the way the company is structured that he's not in danger of being ousted if the board (which represents the shareholders, not the company) doesn't like the company's performance.
- skybrian 4y agoYes, shareholders can sometimes exercise power over a company via its board, but it doesn’t follow that shareholders necessarily want to maximize the value of that company’s shares, or at least not right away. Shareholders often have other interests. For example, they usually own shares in other companies. Also, ESG is big these days. This can make deciding what a company should do a messy political process when there’s disagreement about what shareholders want or should want. Like, some shareholders may decide to buy a coal plant to shut it down, others to keep it running as long as possible.
- chippiewill 4y agoGoogle don't have to worry about such activist shareholders in the same way that other companies do. Larry Page and Sergey Brin have the controlling share in Alphabet thanks to their Class B shares. They only have a fiduciary responsibility to the other shareholders.
- spacebanana7 4y agoIn fairness, neither did Meta. Zuckerberg has a similar dual class structure through which he can control the company.
- insane_dreamer 4y agoSo does Zuckerberg. But while he and Page/Brin may have a controlling interest in _voting_ stock, they own a much smaller amount of overall shares. Sure, activists can't control the board, and Zuck/Page/Brin are not in danger of being ousted, their fiduciary duty is to the shareholders not just those with voting rights.
- bananapub 4y agook? there's no fiduciary duty to do a dumb thing just because Amazon did the same dumb thing, and saying "we've got loads of cash, we're going to expand and hire the great people Amazon and Meta just stupidly let go and enhance shareholder value in the long term" is a perfectly cromulant thing to say.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoFacebook, nor Google, is firing people because of activist investors. They're firing them because they just way over hired people recently, and they have way too many people for what they can adequately put to good use given their size now. Feels like everyone wants to put a semi "conspiratorial" twist on these announcements when it's pretty obvious what the underlying driver is.
- darth_avocado 4y agoThe underlying driver is also wage suppression. Why retain overpaid employees when you can collectively fire people and suppress the market wages? The added benefit would be that the rest would work twice as hard.
- tootie 4y agoMeh. Saying this is a new "era" and the old ways are over is nonsense. We're entering what is likely a mild recessionary period with less flowing capital. It's a market correction. The "era" will last maybe 2 years. Then the upward trajectory will hit again and tech workers will get drone shuttles to work or something by 2030.
- lazide 4y agoDidn’t work that way for the chip companies. Those highly paid jobs pretty much just ceased to exist.
- andromeduck 4y agoSeems like it just changed companies - Google/Apple/Nvidia saw an opportunity and poached a lot of them to death.
- lazide 4y agoNope, completely different people and skills. Original silicon valley was actual making chips, silicon type. And there were a ton of folks here who were expert at it. When it moved to Taiwan, those jobs disappeared from here. The types of jobs you're talking about (high level design layer) didn't exist then.
- andromeduck 4y agoWhen was this?
- woeirua 4y agoRemind me, what happened after the DotCom bubble imploded?
- tootie 4y agoTech sector recovered to astronomical new heights?
- LordDragonfang 4y agoThis is definitely the case. I was just talking with a Googler after the Microsoft layoffs about how Google is (now was) one of the last big tech companies avoiding layoffs, and Pichai was fighting investors like hell to keep it that way. He supposedly literally told them "these are real people" out of frustration at some point. It's hard to look at that incredibly generous layoff package an not see it as a "fuck you" to investors telling him to slim down, after forcing his hand.
- abdabab 4y agoWho are these investors that he’s fighting?
- avrionov 4y agohttps://www.reuters.com/technology/hedge-fund-tci-says-alphabet-cost-base-too-high-2022-11-15/ https://www.reuters.com/technology/hedge-fund-tci-says-alpha...
- phendrenad2 4y agoSays that they have a $6 billion stake. Google's market cap is 211x that. If I owned 0.47% of a startup company, would they even take my phone call to listen to my "opinion" on any matter? Something doesn't add up here. Or perhaps this theory is correct, a company that owns 0.47% of Google gets to call the shots. Really makes you think twice about taking investment money.
- asda_ 4y ago[dead]