10 ms·
Alec Baldwin Will Be Charged with Involuntary Manslaughter in ‘Rust’ Killing
- europeanguy 4y agoI thought Rust was supposed to be safe?
- ilovecurl 4y agoI hate that I laughed at this. Never ascribe to malice that which is adequately explained by incompetence. See also: https://doc.rust-lang.org/book/ch19-01-unsafe-rust.html https://doc.rust-lang.org/book/ch19-01-unsafe-rust.html
- bryanrasmussen 4y agointernet archive: https://web.archive.org/web/20230120004918/https://www.nytimes.com/2023/01/19/arts/rust-shooting-charges-alec-baldwin.html https://web.archive.org/web/20230120004918/https://www.nytim...
- ChoGGi 4y agoIf an actor is handed a gun and told it has fake ammo, how would they know the difference to not be charged with involuntary manslaughter?
- perrygeo 4y agoThe actor wouldn't. The producer who let live ammo anywhere near a set would. He's being charged as the head of production, not as the actor who was unfortunate enough to pull the trigger. The fact that he's both is just a cruel twist of fate.
- ianceicys 4y ago"cruel twist of fate." no Alec Baldwin was not responsible as both a producer and actor, now he is being held accountable as he was in every sense of the word responsible for manslaughter...even involuntarily. Cruelty is reserved for the grief of the individual who had their life abruptly ended, and the grief of family of the deceased.
- matthewdgreen 4y agoAccording to CNN [1] this is not true. Baldwin is facing charges for his direct actions as an actor (who pulled the trigger) and as the producer. I imagine this will be very confusing for a jury to unpack, and I think it’s unfortunate. To quote the DA: Other actors — including "A-list" celebrities — consulted by prosecutors said they "always check their guns or have someone check it in front of them," Carmack-Altwies told CNN shortly after announcing her intention to file involuntary manslaughter charges. Every person that handles a gun has a duty to make sure that if they're going to handle that gun, point it at someone and pull the trigger, that it is not going to fire a projectile and kill someone," she said. She added, "An actor does not get a free pass just because they are an actor. That is what is so important. We are saying here in New Mexico, that everyone is equal under the law." The piece goes on to note that the “criminal liability as a producer” case would have different requirements than the “criminal liability as an actor” case, presumably because one case would need to argue that on-set safety was actually Baldwin’s responsibility and he was specifically negligent in that duty. But based on the DA’s quotes it looks like she is going for a very broad theory of liability that mixes the two roles up (ie as the producer he should have known to take special care when handed a cold gun as an actor.) It says that CNN’s legal expert found the case to be very unusual, FWIW. I’ll be honest that this case has a whiff of “small town DA wanting to get a bigger political profile” to it, but I guess we’ll see. [1] https://www.kcra.com/amp/article/alec-baldwin-rust-charges-why/42581449 https://www.kcra.com/amp/article/alec-baldwin-rust-charges-w...
- perrygeo 4y agoInteresting! Thanks for the clarification. Gun safety etiquette dictates that the handler is always responsible for their own ammo. Alec the actor should definitely not get a free pass. I didn't realize there were criminal ramifications too. Alec the producer is guilty of a far worse crime IMO. It could have easily been someone else who pulled the trigger.
- matthewdgreen 4y agoStandard gun safety procedures are excellent, but don’t really have any bearing here. Just as a professional chemical laboratory has different safety procedures (and responsibilities/expectations for workers) than, say, your house: a film set also has different expectations and safety procedures when it comes to weapons. I’m no expert, but my understanding is that film sets need to allow actors to use guns in specific ways that would never be acceptable in normal gun ownership, such as to point (“cold”) props at people and pull the trigger. To enable this specialized usage the industry has developed a very specific set of safety standards tailored to this use-case. It involves hiring specially-trained professional armorers to manage all of the prop weapons on the set, and it also puts in place a new set of communication procedures to ensure that armorers can communicate with actors to let them know when they’re dealing with an unsafe weapon. From what I can tell, Baldwin the actor followed these safety procedures exactly as expected. There is a separate question of whether Baldwin the executive producer has liability. To answer that you can’t just say “but he has a producer credit!” You’d need to actually show that (1) he had responsibility over hiring or on-set safety, and separately that (2) in that role he was negligent. It’s not really clear that an executive producer has that responsibility, usually it’s just a meaningless vanity credit. What’s confusing about this case (from what I can tell) is that the DA realizes that both of these individual cases is kind of weak. And so instead she’s going for a hybrid case where Baldwin the actor followed the normal safety standards, but this isn’t sufficient because he somehow has to follow a non-standard (higher) set of safety standards because “as the producer he should have been aware that the professional armorer wasn’t trustworthy.” I’m not saying this argument is wrong, exactly. But I think it’s vague enough that it might allow a jury to disregard the legal safety requirements and invent new ones out of whole cloth. PS I find this case fascinating and I don’t apologize for it! But I do apologize for the long post.
- bogantech 4y agoThey are supposed to follow strict safety rules to prevent things like this happening, like guns being handed over only by the armorer (who wasn't even there in this instance). I'm pretty sure that being the film's producer he is liable.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- torstenvl 4y agoIf you're going to pick up a weapon, point it at someone, and pull the trigger, what happens next is your responsibility, regardless of any other context. If you aren't willing to learn the difference between dummy rounds, blanks, and live rounds, then you shouldn't be pointing firearms at people and pulling the trigger.
- seanw444 4y agoAgreed. If he wanted to have real firearms there, he needs to know how to operate real firearms. If he hired the armorer (or another person dedicated to firearms safety) to teach him how to do that, and they failed at that job, then the they should get their fair share of blame / repercussions. Which it sounds like they did, with a "negligent handling of a deadly weapon" or something. Ultimately, though, as someone that is very familiar with guns, I have a hard time sympathizing with Baldwin. You brought real guns onto the set, and you pointed them at people. Primarily people that had no business having the guns pointed at them. It wasn't even another actor during filming, which I would have at least understood to some degree. It seems like the perfect storm of things had happened for him to "accidentally" kill this person he didn't like. At the end of the day, any actors / set workers handling real firearms should have thorough training before using them. Trigger discipline, how to check the chamber, identifying cartridge types, emptying the chamber before setting it down, not aiming at people who aren't even actors...
- RansomStark 4y ago> you pointed them at people. Primarily people that had no business having the guns pointed at them. It wasn't even another actor during filming, which I would have at least understood to some degree. the scene involved pointing the gun towards the camera, which means the gun is pointing towards the crew. > Trigger discipline How do you maintain trigger discipline when the scene requires you to point a gun at someone, or in someones general direction, with your finger on the trigger? > check the chamber, identifying cartridge types, emptying the chamber before setting it down If an actor tries to check the chamber, messes with the cartridges, the gun immediately goes back to the armorer to be made safe before being handed back to the actor, if the actor check again, guess what happens? It's very important to understand that on a film set the standard rules do not apply, or more precisely the rules apply in different ways.
- DiabloD3 4y agoThat kind of sucks, and I'm surprised a prosecutor is willing to risk their career. However, this article has very strange wording in it, "Mr. Baldwin, [played] former President Donald J. Trump on "Saturday Night Live"", but later, "Ms. Reeb, the special prosecutor, who is also a Republican"; is NYT trying to accuse the prosecutor of making this political?
- boeingUH60 4y agoInserting Trump in an article generates outrage...outrage is good for publications. I've noticed a lot of publications doing this, as in inserting politics into articles where it doesn't matter. I don't know who to blame; Trump the attention-seeking clown or the media orgs that give him the constant attention, whether positive or negative.
- Mountain_Skies 4y agoThat's increasingly happening with YouTube videos for pop science and listicles. The creators just have to find some way to twist in some politics, usually with a snide or smug delivery, even if they don't have even a tangential relationship to the video's advertised subject matter. Usually, it's not about Trump but about various political and ideological causes currently popular with twentysomethings. Often it feels like the video was finished and someone went "Oh crap, we forgot to stick in some politics" and went back to add it in.
- plusminusplus 4y agoWe hear this platitude a lot. Specific to this article they're saying "the Republican special prosecutor has good reasons to do this (that aren't political)" to cut that argument off.
- tolleydbg 4y agoI think they actually might be trying to show that both Democrats and Republicans in New Mexico are in agreement on the issue, in an attempt to show that it is -not- political. I could be mistaken, but that's been my impression from other media in New Mexico. There has been an increase of self-defense related shootings in New Mexico, and although the state has usually acknowledged some form of castle doctrine in your own home that isn't typically tempered by any duty to retreat. Gun violence, and crime in general, is fairly high in New Mexico, and is likely responsible for the increase of self-defense cases, but nevertheless, that state has been filing charges, or at least mulling them over in traditional self-defense instances. Here's one from earlier this year: https://www.kob.com/new-mexico/suspect-killed-in-double-home-invasion-in-ne-albuquerque/ https://www.kob.com/new-mexico/suspect-killed-in-double-home... I can't find the specific article I read back when this happened, but they all said something about the DA was debating on whether to file charges or not. It may seem like Alec Baldwin may be a victim of this crackdown, and perhaps he is being used politically as a show of force in their effort to curb gun crime, but I think as the producer of this film, he would've been charged before the crackdown, and likely would faces charges in most states.
- gboone 4y agoAfter reading the article I wanted to know what is gained by shaking a bullet in front of the actor (this was not done but someone is quoted as saying it's standard practice)? I found this which shows comparisons of bullets and blanks. There is a mention in one of the posts of BBs being installed to give a rattle. It says blanks are not to be used at close range and not to be pointed at anyone. A cold gun is supposed to be an unloaded gun and not a gun with a blank? https://www.quora.com/When-talking-about-bullets-or-rounds-what-is-the-difference-between-blanks-dummies-What-does-it-mean-if-someone-says-the-firearm-is-cold?share=1 https://www.quora.com/When-talking-about-bullets-or-rounds-w... But what stands out is how blanks and shotshell look the same. If the accident on the set used a bullet, that should have been visibly noticeable. The call was that it was a cold gun, but the article doesn't give an example of what was used. Anyone have info on that?
- scott00 4y agoIt was supposed to have been loaded with dummies, not blanks.
- say_it_as_it_is 4y agoYou people will upvote anything with "Rust" in it, won't you?
- Mountain_Skies 4y agoGuess Rust isn't quite as safe as advertised.