4 ms·
Revisiting Apple’s ill-fated Lisa computer, 40 years on
- jdorfman 4y agoWhat a great article. I’m a proud Ars Technica subscriber so if you enjoyed this article consider subscribing.
- wsc981 4y agoI loved Ars Technica in the past, but the site and forums seems to have become such a one-sided echo-chamber of left-wingers that nowadays I visit the site much more rarely then I used to. This is mainly related to let's say healthcare and political topics. It seems to me that HackerNews has more balanced audience, which suits me better.
- D13Fd 4y agoI have never seen evidence of this at all. Maybe reconsider your own biases. I do think the quality has fallen overall at Ars Technica though. Particularly on their car articles, which for a long time now have been just regurgitated press releases filled with lame industry speak and no critical analysis. I also don't like that they are recycling Wired articles so often rather than posting original content. Great articles like this one are becoming less and less common.
- GeekyBear 4y agoI have definitely seen it. The site went from ridiculous levels of Elon Musk worship (How dare you say it's misleading for Tesla to use the name Autopilot) to constant hit pieces following his recent fall from grace on the left.
- D13Fd 4y ago> The site went from ridiculous levels of Elon Musk worship (How dare you say it's misleading for Tesla to use the name Autopilot) to constant hit pieces following his recent fall from grace on the left. I guess this is one way to view it. Or you could see it as them giving him the benefit of the doubt when he was a gifted tech businessman, and then not doing so when his purchase of Twitter led to an emperor-has-no-clothes moment.
- GeekyBear 4y ago> Or you could see it as them giving him the benefit of the doubt when he was a gifted tech businessman Musk hasn't changed at all. Calling a lane keeping feature "Autopilot" has always been exceptionally misleading and dangerous. What has changed is that he's now on the left's version of a Nixonian enemies list.
- Terretta 4y agoSeems more likely Ars opinion of Musk has little to do with wings or wingnuts. Seems more likely it's tech's so-called meritocracy bias: he's been re-weighed on the merits and this time found wanting. That said, both wings have tried to politicize #elongate, so I can see how people imagine any opinion on Musk is politically polarized.
- wsc981 4y agoCheck any topic including forum discussions on the COVID vaccines or COVID related policies and read the discussions. It should be very clear by then that the forum is a complete echo chamber. Everybody not agreeing with government or WHO/CDC policies is regarded a retard and downvoted into oblivion.
- D13Fd 4y agoI think you are mistaking a pro-science bias for a left-wrong bias.
- wsc981 4y agoI don’t agree it’s a pro-science bias, but YMMV. As stated before, I see there’s a much more balanced discussion on this topic on HN and as such, I prefer HN over Ars Technica, as it’s less of an echo chamber.
- coldcode 4y agoI had a Lisa on my desk back in early 1984 (along with an IBM PC/XT, an Apple III and an Apple II of some kind). It was an amazing device that clearly showed the direction of computing in the future. It was also way overpriced and underpowered (a 5 MhZ 68000 is not exactly fast), but while I didn't get a chance to write anything for it as it was just an eval unit, reading the documentation was mind bogglingly different than anything I had ever seen. Of course it was the Mac that actually lead to the future (and then Windows 3 that took over years later), but the Lisa pointed the direction.
- gumby 4y ago> Jef Raskin, an early Apple employee who wrote the manual for the Apple ][, had visited PARC in 1973. He believed that GUIs were the future. Raskin managed to persuade the Lisa project leader to change the computer into a GUI machine. However, he couldn’t convince Jobs, who thought Raskin and Xerox were incompetent. I knew Jef a little and I think "incompetent" was unfair (OK it's allegedly Steve jobs who said it so all his statement/opinions were dialed up to 11). Jef was thoughtful, but I would say some of his ideas were utopian and he was somewhat ineffective, probably because of that. Which leads to: > After being kicked off the Lisa team, Jobs strong-armed his way into Raskin’s Macintosh project. Raskin loved GUIs, but he had different ideas for his computer... The project was indeed Jef's, but his vision was very text-oriented. I consider the actual Mac to be a complete reboot of what he was working on (but I was not there and perhaps others who were would disagree -- hopefully someone who knows will comment).
- GeekyBear 4y agoThe Cannon Cat was Jef's vision, and it didn't even have a GUI. > Canon Cat is primarily the creation of Jef Raskin, the originator of the Macintosh project at Apple. After leaving the company in 1982 and founding Information Appliance, Inc., he began designing a new computer closer to his original vision of an inexpensive, utilitarian "people's computer". It features a text user interface, not making use of any pointer (mouse), icons, or graphics. All data are seen as a long "stream" of text broken into several pages. Instead of using a traditional command line interface or menu system, the Cat makes use of its special keyboard, with commands being activated by holding down a "Use Front" key and pressing another key. The Cat also uses special "Leap keys", which, when held down, allows the user to incrementally search for strings of characters. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canon_Cat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canon_Cat
- gumby 4y agoThat wikipedia page links to a great note by Jef on his vision, which is what I remember him describing on a couple of occasions. He was working on it pretty much to the end of his life as far as I know. https://www.apple-history.com/gui_raskin2 https://www.apple-history.com/gui_raskin2
- brudgers 4y agoOh how I lusted after Lisa. Alas, she was way out of my league.
- vannevar 4y agoOne thing the emulator probably doesn't adequately convey is just how painfully slow the Lisa was. We had a lab full of them in college, and I was very excited to use the new GUI. But it was almost unusably slow, and I suspect that had more to do with its failure than the price. DOS applications, while ugly, were lightning fast by comparison.
- getpost 4y ago1983 TV ad for Lisa with Kevin Costner, "I'll be home for breakfast." https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kJRx79sl1yk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kJRx79sl1yk
- vannevar 4y agoRight. I'll be home for breakfast, and hopefully by the time I get back to work this LisaDraw file will finish opening.
- transfire 4y agoThis is a great article. Funny how Apple became so successful because of Jobs and yet sometimes despite Jobs. Interesting to know how much better the Mac could have been if they stuck to their Lisa guns more.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoMy professor often said that the Lisa was the best machine that Apple ever made because it allowed the user unlimited control. He said it was very fun and easy to hack on, write drivers, etc.
- lproven 4y agoI find it especially interesting to compare this article to their other one announcing the story: https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2023/01/pioneering-apple-lisa-goes-open-source-thanks-to-computer-history-museum/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2023/01/pione...
- toddh 4y agoIt was a magical machine. I remember programming a chess game in Pascal, and all the API calls were like a hundred characters long.