8 ms·
Genesis Filed for Bankruptcy
- easytiger 4y agoA tweet they posted (NB the twitter account hasn't tweeted since April 2021: > 10% APY on all of your $USDC 6.5% APY on all of your #Bitcoin No min. No max. No tiers. The fantasy world these guys must weave to justify this multi party ponzi. Here is a tweet, in fact the last one Gensis retweeted from someone explaining how Genesis can justify such yields as a sustainable https://twitter.com/web3breakdowns/status/1509880728707911689 https://twitter.com/web3breakdowns/status/150988072870791168... In short it's "because its new and cool and different". If it were true the yield would be constantly variable, not fixed for a start. Lending rates would surely be more volatile than extant money markets given the risk. A component in a ponzi is rationalisation to the client regarding the magical money making sources. They might have had a lot of loans out there, but the fact is they were lending to con men who were giving their clients similar yields in a game of musical chairs that left a lot of people with no place to sit when the music stopped. At some point there are 3 options 1. these people do not understand the (not very complex) flow of financial markets 2. They do understand the flow and know they are in a limited lifespan scam and hope to personally skim off the top before it crashes (as was the case with luna/terra). The operators have limited risk compared with clients 3. they have become so enamored of the unfounded pseudo-economics of the industry that they believe it will all work out fine somehow (delusion). Mechanism TBD
- cdiddy2 4y agoya I don't think they were a ponzi themselves but they lost money to both 3 arrows capital and in the ftx collapse. https://decrypt.co/114778/genesis-suspending-client-withdrawals-lending-arm-citing-ftx-impact https://decrypt.co/114778/genesis-suspending-client-withdraw... https://www.coindesk.com/business/2022/06/29/genesis-faces-hundreds-of-millions-in-losses-as-3ac-exposure-swamps-crypto-lenders-sources/ https://www.coindesk.com/business/2022/06/29/genesis-faces-h...
- rippercushions 4y agoYou cannot offer 10% APY on a stablecoin like USDC that by definition does not increase in value or pay dividends without getting that 10% from somewhere else, namely other customers' funds.
- superjan 4y agoCouldn’t you make the same argument about fiat currency? Both in regular finance and in defi there exist funds that do high stakes gambles with other people’s money.
- smcl 4y agoRight but in “regular finance” you generally have a regulator who will slap you around if you advertise a product which promises 10% per year guaranteed. There are unregulated (or less regulated) things like hedge funds, but at that point you’re clearly in a fairly small market that most people cannot or do not participate in. So what is niche, risky behaviour in traditional finance, seems to be the norm in the Wild West that is crypto.
- cdiddy2 4y agoTo be clear none of this is defi, its all just traditional borrowing and lending. Aave pays 3% on USDT right now and lenders there are doing fine in defi
- BLKNSLVR 4y agoIt's from interest on loans as far as my understanding goes. As safe as ... the companies taking out the under-collateralised loans...
- easytiger 4y agoThat's why i called it a "multi party ponzi". They had to know their largest borrowers were not above board. FTX promised large no risk returns for deposits in turn. Except FTX didn't even have the plausible excuse of lending money. One of the stablecoins promised an infinite money making circle of lending->profit. 3AC's trading model was to borrow at these high IRs and gamble it (i don't for a second believe they had a risk based trading strat) and hope it paid off and skim off the top. See my 3 possibilities above. The company founders even had a flight plan to non extradition treaty countries. Where they now reside
- kamma4434 4y agoWhat is Genesis ? I thought it was the telephone company
- superjan 4y agoA cryptocurrency company (not an exchange). For the recent headlines about their struggle: https://web3isgoinggreat.com/?collection=genesis https://web3isgoinggreat.com/?collection=genesis
- rerdavies 4y agoI thought it was Hyundai's luxury automobile division.
- pezezin 4y agoNo, it was the American name for the Megadrive.
- autoexec 4y agoThe text of the first tweet reads: "This evening, Genesis Global Capital, LLC (Genesis) filed for bankruptcy under Chapter 11. This is a crucial step towards us being able to recover your assets." Hopefully that helps clear up which "Genesis" this concerns since the title was ambiguous or maybe save somebody a click to twitter
- zip1234 4y agoThe whole thread reads as CYA and trying to pass blame somewhere else. Looked it up and yes, guess who also has legal action headed their way?
- roenxi 4y agoThe issue with linking to Twitter, is I have no idea: 1. What does Genesis do (a crypto exchange?)? 2. Is it in any way important? 3. Is this an unusual level level of bankruptcies happening in Crypto? As far as I can tell this is just a crypto company going bankrupt. The US (the world!) is in an unprecedented post-COVID-shutdown amount of turmoil. The economy is roiling. NASDAQ is down 23% over 12 months. There is even war on the border of the world's largest nuclear power and everyone is still escalating it even after 12 months. Unless we're drawing a pattern that bankruptcies in crypto are unusually high (which this twitter thread does not seem to be), it doesn't make sense to focus on Genesis. There are bigger issues out there.
- pjc50 4y agoMostly schadenfreude; people are enjoying the widespread fraud in crypto and its promise of absurd returns from simply emitting vast quantities of CO2 gradually collapsing.
- roenxi 4y agoThis article isn't even evidence of that. I've been waiting patiently for Bitcoin to collapse after watching what I assumed was the all time high in 2018. We've nearly dropped back to that now, still persistently above that price. I think I've made a profit in Monero. In a jaw dropping set of peg defences, Tether still exists. You can buy and sell it for about $1 USD. The ecosystem has proven much more resilient against major players going bankrupt than the traditional financial system. Nobody has been bailed out by a government as far as I know. I suspect the crypto market is less volatile than has historically been the case. It might happen, but so far there are no signs that the crypto market is going to collapse. If anything, it looks quite healthy to me. I wish traditional stock markets were allowed to fall like this without the authorities stepping in to prop things up. Genesis going bankrupt is a non event until a good reason is found to believe otherwise.
- pavlov 4y ago> "The ecosystem has proven much more resilient against major players going bankrupt than the traditional financial system. Nobody has been bailed out by a government as far as I know." That's because crypto, unlike the traditional financial system, doesn't interact at all with the real world of companies, cash flows, employees, their mortgages, etc. There's no need for the government to step in to save a bunch of crypto traders who got into trouble for inventing tokens that leverage tokens that represent tokens, and so on. This also explains why the crypto system looks resilient at this point. Retail crypto investors have mostly taken their losses and gone home. The remaining players can manipulate the market to make it look like what they want; it's a shadow play with very little real money left. Even Peter Thiel sold all his Bitcoin in March 2022 while at the same time making conference appearances where he claimed its price is going to increase by 100x: https://www.ft.com/content/0a1d5597-7145-4035-987b-ff033bba3d75 https://www.ft.com/content/0a1d5597-7145-4035-987b-ff033bba3...
- nailer 4y agoThis isn't the Genesys people know from Shadow Drive and RPC providers. https://docs.genesysgo.com/shadow/ https://docs.genesysgo.com/shadow/ It appears to be some kind of OTC derivatives platform.
- glutamate 4y agoFor crypto skeptics, this is another day in paradise
- rollcat 4y agoAs a "crypto skeptic", no it's not a paradise. People buying this were still fooled and lost money, people who built this are having their work erased. You can disapprove of a technological/social trend and still feel empathy for the people who are negatively affected.
- martin_a 4y agoAt this point neither the "investors" nor the people builing those systems can claim plausible deniability. Nothing good has ever come out of crypto/blockchain, it's all just scams left an right.
- rollcat 4y agoI have no doubt they "knew" it was coming. It takes a combination of committed greed, delusion, gullibility, and short-sightedness to still keep going despite that. That these traits are common enough for this phenomenon to achieve such scale is what's worrying me. So no, not a paradise.
- chaxor 4y agoGit seems to be quite a good tool, and it's a blockchain.
- rollcat 4y agoGit is a blockchain in the same manner that a smoke detector (which utilises radioactive isotopes) is the bomb that dropped on Hiroshima. Except git (2005) -and Perforce (1995), which it was designed to replace - also happen to predate Bitcoin (2009) and Hashcash (2002).
- esalman 4y ago
- mpreda 4y agoCall toll free: 1-555-GEN-ESIS Jesus He Knows Me: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=35K6vQRt67g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=35K6vQRt67g
- mpreda 4y agoThat's a joke BTW. It's the song "Jesus He Knows Me" by Genesis, about amassing large amounts of money by misleading honest people. At 2:59 in the official video is the quote "You can call my toll free number, 1-555-GEN-ESIS" which I find, as the overall lyrics, great. Well, what has Hacker News become that one has to explain even the jokes..
- psychstudio 4y agoHN doesn't take too kindly to jokes.
- gpderetta 4y agoMy experience is that 0 effort reddit style memeing is downvoted, while sarcasm and jokes are rewarded as long at least a minimum effort is shown. I think that most people (me included) just didn't get the joke.
- smcl 4y agoHN is a fickle beast - sometimes jokes are well-received and upvoted, sometimes they’re misunderstood and downvoted, and sometimes they’re understood and downvoted out of spite. It’s hard to read the room sometimes, especially in a text-only medium where despite commenting and interacting a lot, many of us don’t actually really know each other
- Hamuko 4y agoHow long before Gemini does the same? As far as I'm aware, they funneled all of their customers' funds directly to Genesis.
- cdiddy2 4y agoonly their earn product customers
- BLKNSLVR 4y agoAs far as I'm aware, the service offered by Gemini that used Genesis was a difficult separate service to their exchange. Gemini customers put their own money into the 'earn' program, and if it was anything like Celsius, there's a different set of Customer Agreements for different services. Ie. Gemini didn't 'funnel' any funds, customers' choose whether their funds were put. I doubt Gemini has anything at risk beyond reputational damage, but they have to make a fight on behalf of their customers to mitigate the reputational damage.
- mellosouls 4y agoFor anybody else who has no idea what this is about, a news article with context (that followed from the tweet here): https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-64343377 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-64343377 And wrt the tweeter: "Genesis is also embroiled in a high-profile dispute with Gemini, owned by the former Olympic rowers Cameron and Tyler Winklevoss, over the fate of $900m in assets that Gemini customers deposited with the lender."
- Geee 4y agoScammers going bankrupt is the absolute right thing to happen. As a whole, the crypto market emerges stronger, when the trash is taken out. It's also a learning experience for everyone to be skeptical about yield products. If you don't know where the yield comes from, you are the yield.
- manholio 4y agoThe crypto market is the trash, a decade old speculative bubble with zero real world applications.
- faeyanpiraat 4y agoIt actually has a nice use case as a breach canary. Have an unprotected wallet stored on your machine with some btc on it (like 200-500 USD worth), and if you notice a transfer out from there, you can be sure your machine is compromised. This method was recently posted by a fellow HN member, unfortunately I forgot where.
- danaris 4y agoAh, yes, $200-500 USD, an amount of money that surely no one will ever miss, and everyone would feel perfectly fine throwing away as a "breach canary". Never mind that that's, what, about a week's wages for many people?
- moonchrome 4y agoThen you have bigger worries than a PC breach.
- danaris 4y agoRight, because The Poors don't have lives to live that also care about things like privacy. They just exist in a horrifying life-or-death, dog-eat-dog scramble every day in their slums. (/s) Seriously, can you be any more out of touch and dismissive of the concerns of people who haven't been making six figures ever since they left college?
- swiper_lux 4y ago"...This evening, Genesis Global Capital, LLC (Genesis) filed for bankruptcy under Chapter 11. This is a crucial step towards us being able to recover your assets." So Gemini is helping depositors of Genesis, or depositors of Gemini? If depositors of Gemini, did the depositors know that their monies were going to Genesis when they deposited them into Gemini?
- hnbear 4y agoNot all Gemini deposits were sent to Genesis. If a Gemini user opted into Gemini's Earn product they were notified that any Earn deposits were going to Genesis. You can argue those warnings weren't big enough or obvious enough, but it was spelled out in various places that Earn deposits were not held by Gemini, but sent to third parties (in this case Genesis being the only third party in the program).
- doctor_eval 4y agoI find it interesting that all the Twitter messages presented to me below this tweet are from accounts with names like “Pepe”, “End Wokeness” and Andrew Tate (how is he even posting?) Anyway - I suppose they just group all the scumlords together to save disk or bandwidth or something idk.
- lancesells 4y agoSame. I don't have a twitter account and don't browse it. Is it because it's crypto related? So much weird anger out of all those accounts.
- acdha 4y agoYes - cryptocurrency ideology has always been heavily skewed by right-wing ideology but that was also reinforced over the years as many of the people who were extreme enough to get kicked off of platforms like Patreon found alternative funding mechanisms. That of course doesn’t mean the average cryptocurrency person is embittered but the ones who are tend to be extremely vocal.
- europeanguy 4y agoI'm not in Twitter, but I clicked that link just to see what you're talking about. I must've scrolled 50 messages and saw a total of 2 pepes. That's it. Maybe Twitter is showing you that based on your historical account behavior? :-)
- doctor_eval 4y agoI only use Twitter when I see links from HN, and have never seen anything like this before. I actually found it very confronting and upsetting. I looked again after a while and it was back to what I would consider normal. Maybe just some glitch in the matrix. Honestly, I see all these people screaming with unkindness and I just think, WTF happened to the world where this is OK?
- _a9 4y agoI only see some crypto and space/nature stuff. It usually has something to do with stuff you've previously viewed on twitter or whatever their algo thinks you do.
- NickC25 4y agoThis whole thing reeks of a Ponzi Scheme to me. 10% APY and your deposit is safe? Yeah, no. Same think SBF did but he promised 8% a month, which is even more blatantly a Ponzi. Now, did Cameron and Tyler explicitly know that this was a Ponzi Scheme? Honestly (and as much as I like to knock them) I don't think so....they have been on-board with crypto for a decade if not longer, so they were probably buying into their own hype a bit too much.
- girafffe_i 4y agoBut I'm still going to get my GUSD earn from Gemini right?