Dial up was an on-demand pricing model, not a subscription. By your own rules that doesnt work. Now, if you had dial up and paid a subscription for access to a

Dial up was an on-demand pricing model, not a subscription. By your own rules that doesnt work. Now, if you had dial up and paid a subscription for access to a free phone number and they cut you off before your subscription ended, then yes you absolutely would expect a refund.