The old records may have belonged to the car thief. Given their low value, it's unlikely to be loot. What if you found a jar of peanut butter in the car? Would

The old records may have belonged to the car thief. Given their low value, it's unlikely to be loot. What if you found a jar of peanut butter in the car? Would you try to find out if it was stolen and hunt down the rightful owner?