4 ms·
Quite dystopian if you ask me. Is it not enough that there are police officers and speed traps on the ground, now you have to fear to be watched from the skies
by mschuster91 4y ago
Quite dystopian if you ask me. Is it not enough that there are police officers and speed traps on the ground, now you have to fear to be watched from the skies all day as well?
- DJBunnies 4y agoThey can already get probable cause from a helicopter pass.
- jrockway 4y agoDystopian is the day that Apple sells your location information to the local police force and you just get a speeding ticket in the mail every time you drive 1mph over the speed limit. (Is there a statute of limitations on speeding tickets? They can get you for your entire driving career with a mere SQL query!) Speaking of dystopias, I'm surprised that they don't issue speeding tickets based on the time that EZ-PASS sees your transponder in various locations. They must imagine too much backlash, or tacitly endorse some speeding already. (I've never seen someone get a ticket for going 60 in a 55, though I'm sure it must happen.)
- uni_rule 4y agoConsidering the defacto speed of 80 on a road that is limited to 65 dominates the whole of New Jersey I think there would be so many people caught in that net they wouldn't be able to properly prosecute it.
- NoImmatureAdHom 4y agoBacklash indeed. Americans would flip their shit. No more EZ-PASS!
- midoridensha 4y agoAs usual, it's all about money. If they used Ez-Pass data (remember, Ez-Pass is a private company) to issue speeding tickets, then no one would get an Ez-Pass and they'd have to go back to toll booths. The system only works because drivers believe that Ez-Pass data is only used for toll collection and nothing more. If they used it to hand out 3mph-over tickets, everyone would stop using it.
- ajdude 4y ago> Dystopian is the day that Apple sells your location information to the local police force and you just get a speeding ticket in the mail every time you drive 1mph over the speed limit Something like this happened with TomTom several years ago: https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2011/04/28/135809709/dutch-police-used-tomtoms-gps-data-to-target-speeders https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2011/04/28/135809709...
- aceazzameen 4y agoI've always wondered about why that hasn't been implemented with EZ-PASS too. My assumption is politicians don't want it because they all like to speed, and it's easier to tell a cop who they are instead of fighting a digital ticket.
- tristor 4y ago> I'm surprised that they don't issue speeding tickets based on the time that EZ-PASS sees your transponder in various locations. They don't want to do this. Toll systems are set up as private corporations (often with government money) so that they can operate for-profit, and are a tacit "Speeding Pass". E.g. usually there is no enforcement in toll lanes / toll roads for speed limits compared to standard roads. They do this very specifically as an enticement for people to pay in order to get to their destination faster, that is the entire USP (unique selling proposition) to a toll road. If they started using toll data to automatically enforce speed limits, it would immediately making tolling impossible/unsustainable, and nobody would use transponder systems. There's already issues with people cheating tolls using various methods to obscure their license plate for systems which support license plate tolling.
- atahanacar 4y agoQuite dystopian to protect people outside the car from the outcomes of the car's driver negligence.
- WirelessGigabit 4y agoCould be worse. Western Europe is full of average speed cameras, speed cameras and cops hiding behind all sorts of constructions where all they do is take a photo and send the registrar of the car the ticket with no way of facing your accuser. All you can do is pay the ticket. It's you vs the machine. Didn't drive the car and don't know who did? Tough luck.
- srmarm 4y agoI'm sure in most countries you can choose to take the fine or fight it in court. How often do you not know whose driving your car?
- WirelessGigabit 4y agoYou can take it to court and then what? The judge just slams you with the photo (for which you need to pay if you want it as part of your defense). Speeding tickets in Belgium are part of the government budget. That on its own should make you think about why they make it so hard to defend yourself. And a picture of a license plate proves just that. The plate was there. I shouldn't have to keep record who drove my car. Especially not 4 weeks ago when the letter gets to my mailbox. Nor should I be required to rat out others.
- ben_w 4y agoIn the UK, knowing who was driving is the responsibility of the owner: https://www.westyorkshire.police.uk/ask-the-police/question/Q618 https://www.westyorkshire.police.uk/ask-the-police/question/...
- _Wintermute 4y agoI fear being killed by a dangerous driver. Whose fear is more rational?
- tristor 4y agoSpeeding != dangerous driver. I speed, effectively every day, just as do most other people, because many roads still have a speed limit of 55mph from the 1960s and the expected (and safe, partly because of this) speed on these roads is 70-80mph. Dangerous drivers are the MANY people I see every day who are on their phones, not looking at the road, with bad lane-keeping practices, who change lanes without using blinkers, or make erratic and sudden movements. Dangerous drivers are the MANY people I see every day who tailgate and then pass aggressively via weaving between lanes, passing on the right. Dangerous drivers are the MANY people I see every day who camp in the left lane while going significantly below the expected average speed for the lane, causing some people to feel it necessary to pass them on the right and obstructing the flow of traffic. Speeding probably isn't good, but it's not even in the top 5 things I would be most concerned about on public roadways in the US from a safety perspective. As a passenger or another driver on the roadway, I'd much rather be surrounded by attentive drivers with both hands on the wheel who are speeding than inattentive drivers with one hand on the wheel and the other on their phone watching a Tik Tok video and texting their friends while cruise control is set.
- _Wintermute 4y agoI'd rather be sharing public spaces with drivers not speeding and not on their phones. It's not one or the other. From a quick googling speed is listed as a factor in 29% of fatal accidents. Plus if you're already breaking one driving law, chances are you're breaking several more.
- mlindner 4y agoThe US is rather free of speed cameras in comparison. I know they have them in some states, but I've traveled around quite a bit and not seen any place that's monitored by speed cameras. In Europe they're quite common from my understanding, at least in the UK I've heard that's the case.
- brenns10 4y agoIn this case you are operating your licensed, registered, several thousand lb machinery on roads subsidized and maintained by public money, at great risk to other road users (and yourself). Is it so dystopian that there's the chance you'd be monitored for the purpose of enforcing safety regulations?
- bluefirebrand 4y agoPretty much any effort to constantly monitor everyone's behavior at all times is dystopian, yeah. Safety regulations are just the justification for why it's necessary. The income from fines is the real reason it's done.
- brenns10 4y ago> Pretty much any effort to constantly monitor everyone's behavior at all times is dystopian, yeah. You say "at all times" but like I said, this surveillance is limited to the times when you are operating your privately owned heavy machinery on public roads (which have posted signs regarding aircraft). > The income from fines is the real reason it's done. The article even explicitly says that the economics of aircraft doesn't work out for tickets. It's not about revenue, nor evil gov't surveillance. It's about public safety.
- dazc 4y agoYou can stay within the given limit and fear nothing though.
- bluefirebrand 4y agoThe limits that municipalities deliberately set lower than the road can handle so people are more tempted to speed because they feel safe doing so. This isn't some conspiracy theory. Governments all over use speed fines as part of their budget, it is absolutely within reason to think that they also set up the rules in such a way as to get the outcome they want.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoGoing the limit when prevailing traffic speed is 15-25 over the limit is not exactly safe. If it were we wouldn't have minimum speed statutes.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoThe dystopian part is that they only do it enough to make a buck, not often enough to affect safety and definitely not often enough for their to be political will to make the speed limits reflect reality. It's like the state equivalent of a corporation screwing some fraction of the people it does business with out of a few bucks knowing that suing doesn't make sense and they're under the threshold for a lucrative class action.