4 ms·
One thing not mentioned is that the TrustCor VP (Rachel McPherson) spent the entire discussion trying to distance TrustCor from MsgSafe, the product that was co
by lolinder 4y ago
One thing not mentioned is that the TrustCor VP (Rachel McPherson) spent the entire discussion trying to distance TrustCor from MsgSafe, the product that was coming under scrutiny for bundling the malware and engaging in false advertising about its encryption. She repeatedly categorized MsgSafe as a distinct business unit "operated separately and independently from TrustCor CA" to try to insulate the CA from getting damaged by MsgSafe's obvious problems.
One of the key factors in Mozilla's decision was that this supposed operational independence was a lie, because Rachel herself was the Director/VP of Operations for both business units [0]:
> The same individual was responsible for the day to day operation of both TrustCor’s CA business and MsgSafe. They are listed on TrustCor’s website as the VP of TrustCor’s CA operations and the Director of Operations for MsgSafe. [2]
> ...
> [2] Rachel McPherson is listed as the Vice President of Operations, having “access-to and control-over the CA and CA Business Operations” in a company document submitted privately by Rachel to Mozilla. Press releases on TrustCor’s website list Rachel McPherson as MsgSafe.io’s Director of Operations, e.g. https://web.archive.org/web/20221108224150/https://trustcor https://web.archive.org/web/20221108224150/https://trustcor.....
[0] https://groups.google.com/a/mozilla.org/g/dev-security-policy/c/oxX69KFvsm4/m/yLohoVqtCgAJ https://groups.google.com/a/mozilla.org/g/dev-security-polic...
- ethbr0 4y agoThe bad taste this left in my mouth was the glee with which it was conducted. Delisting a CA is a thing you can do. It is a serious thing you can do. But the internet drama surrounding this, and some posts on the mailing list itself, were overly emotional. "Ha! We caught you! You damned executive, you!" is not exactly the tone with which I'd want to conduct weighty matters. It was like looking back into the early-90s, when pitchforks-and-torches-because-we-technically-can were the norm. I don't miss those days, and I'd thought the internet had grown up more. Apologies in advance for being the no-fun police, but we're talking about destroying a business. Even if it's a shitty business, run by shitty people, trying to do shitty things... just don't fucking dance. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=0k5aVLi_yhM https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=0k5aVLi_yhM
- akerl_ 4y agoCan you help clarify where you're seeing glee, either now or in the early 90s?
- lolinder 4y agoIf you look at the emails by Kathleen, she was very deliberate and professional in her phrasing. She only called Rachel out by name in a footnote, and never drew attention to the lie directly. I elided a whole lot of body text to put those two lines together, and even when combined Kathleen doesn't explicitly call her out for lying. That shows a lot of decorum and restraint on Kathleen's part, given the nonsense she was confronted with. There were definitely some people on the mailing list who were less than professional (and of course on Reddit and HN), but the main decision makers were very careful and professional throughout. Rachel is the only one out of the core people involved who lapsed into immaturity.
- ethbr0 4y agoAgreed. Kathleen and the browser reps, as far as I could tell, were nothing but professional and cordial. But by Rachel's fourth reply(?), the response tone seems to shift. Suddenly it's okay for the peanut gallery to snark. And I get it -- I probably couldn't have resisted a choice remark after being shoveled a load of what read like horsecrap. But when "I’m not sure how exactly you’re involved in the CA community, do you represent a CA? A browser perhaps? Or any of the governing bodies? [...] Or are you concerned citizen consumers?" is responded to with "I think all of us are easily found via Google", that's less than the gravitas I'd expect. And I find it fascinating HN cheered this one, when HN's 2nd favorite topic du jour is complaining about how large companies steamroll smaller entities whenever it suits them, without any standard process.
- lolinder 4y agoYes, I fully agree about Kurt's replies—they were unprofessional and added no value. The others that chimed in at the same time were more thoughtful (though equally scathing), but were probably colored a bit by proximity to Kurt's. > And I find it fascinating HN cheered this one, when HN's 2nd favorite topic du jour is complaining about how large companies steamroll smaller entities whenever it suits them, without any standard process. I think the main reason it drew so much attention is because the TrustCor rep made such a scene out of it. Evasion and deflection escalated into ad hominems and conspiracy theories. By the time it hit the HN front page, it was pretty obvious that TrustCor couldn't be trusted, so there wasn't room for any sympathy.