3 ms·
I'm AMAZED at the comments here. I see two common ones: 1) this is news? and 2) no experts used. Both are just insane. For 1) not everyone is tech literate. Yo
by godelski 4y ago
I'm AMAZED at the comments here. I see two common ones: 1) this is news? and 2) no experts used. Both are just insane.
For 1) not everyone is tech literate. You're telling me that everyone you know also knows that companies like Google, Apple, Amazon, Netflix, etc are capturing your data across the web? That they can (almost) uniquely identify you? You've probably been living in SV your entire life and never traveled around the bay -- or further -- if that is an honest statement. This statement comes off as self serving, saying that _you_ know better. Maybe the article isn't for you, and that's okay. You don't have to comment. The comment section may not be for you either. Post if you can _contribute_ to the discussion, otherwise don't.
For 2) I understand the concern, but ProPublica has long worked with topics like these and legal issues. I guarantee you that their staff has enough expertise to understand what browser fingerprints are. That's really not a high bar so your screams for experts are falling short. They list the tool they used and the websites in question. Your calls for expertise will raise if you give reason to them by pointing out how a tool might be flawed and/or that websites are actually capturing fingerprints like the article claims (but that can change after the article's release). So if you want to disprove the article disprove it instead of making a call to authority. Otherwise you're just noise.
Ironically these two types of posts are in direct contradiction to one another. But can we please stop and actually discuss the article instead of you? This is a stupid flame war and most of us just want to discuss the actual contents of the article. Please don't even respond to this, just participate in the conversation to the actual contents of the article.
- Teever 4y agoYou don't have to be tech literate to know that the man spies on you. Hell you don't even need to be literate. I worked in construction about a decade ago when the Snowden thing was big and I asked a construction worker with a grade 10 education from a rural part of Canada what he thought of it and he chortled before saying 'of course they're spying on us. They've always been spying on us.' Meanwhile I have a friend who is a lawyer for the federal govt and this guy just can't seem to grasp anything regarding privacy law and why people care about itm. Meanwhile he's flabbergasted that Madison Square Gardens has the technical means and gall to kick out any lawyers tenuously related to legal action against them. At some point people are responsible for their level of ignorance. I dont know where that point is but I'm sure that it exists.
- godelski 4y ago> You don't have to be tech literate to know that the man spies on you. The article is about __HOW__ the man spies on you. > At some point people are responsible for their level of ignorance Sure, but my point is that we shouldn't enable that ignorance by making people feel stupid for not already knowing. That's not helpful to anyone involved. I'd explicitly consider this a worse position, which is why I'm complaining.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoI also know someone who believes that Bill Gates put GPS chips in the COVID vaccine to track you. To somebody not tech literate, how big a difference is there between COVID tracking chips and the Google tracking cookies in online pharmacies?
- aaron695 4y ago[dead]