3 ms·
Guns are physical products and the comparison isn't apples to apples, unless you're talking about distribution on a massive scale. Building and distributing on
by bad_user 15y ago
Guns are physical products and the comparison isn't apples to apples, unless you're talking about distribution on a massive scale.
Building and distributing on a massive scale, means that the whole operation will be illegal. Otherwise the state will make sure that you can only sell to licensed individuals and will also make sure that those guns won't be cheap.
To manufacture guns you need the materials required, like steel, wood, ceramic, ABS plastic and so on and you need to get them cheaply. To produce them cheaply you also need a heavily automatized factory that accommodates lots of processes like forging, stamping, milling, welding, riveting, casting and drilling. You can also outsource work, but to produce cheap guns you're better off controlling the whole stack. Of course, you could steal or buy those guns from the black market, like from the former Soviet Union arsenal, but doing so implies that you have connections and money to bribe people. Supply is also limited. And the risks are higher, since there are always people looking for those missing guns. So you're better off building your own factory, which of course has to be shielded from the local authorities (more bribes).
To distribute guns, you need a distribution network. And because illegal distribution is illegal and leaves traces, such a line of work is very high-risk. Like, you can always hire junkies to do the street-level distribution for a small price, but junkies are often getting caught by the police and then become valuable witnesses. Lots of mobsters got caught because of junkies. Also, if you want to cross the borders of a country with your merchandise, then things get really complicated. So if you want distribution on a massive scale, then it isn't going to be without a high price.
Compare to the Internet: communications can be encrypted with no way to eavesdrop without the key, it has very few single points of failure (e.g. DNS) and eavesdropping on peer to peer communications is a bitch, all this while copying and distributing has an absolute zero cost and can be done on a freakishly big scale.
4 days ago I wrote an article on my personal blog ~ 10,000 people viewed it in a single day, even though I'm a nobody. When you, as an individual, will be able to showcase your guns to 10,000 people in a single day, then it will be an apples to apples comparison (and you could use the Internet for that, but distribution and availability is location-dependent, you can't just click "download gun").
- sklipo 15y agoI think his point was that just because a crime is easy to commit, it doesn't mean that it's okay to do it. Just because pirating things is easy, doesn't mean that it should be okay, in the same way that if getting guns and killing people was easy, it wouldn't mean that doing so is okay.
- bad_user 15y agoI was trying to say that guns will never be cheap enough or as easy to distribute. From the point of view highlighted by you, the comparison is even more flawed. Downloading a file doesn't threaten anybody's life. Killing for the sake of killing is also not about money. Before refrigerators happened, I'm sure there were companies selling ice to rich folk for a nice price. And if you lived then, I'm sure you could come up with all sorts of reasons for why refrigerators should be outlawed.
- sklipo 15y agoWhat I'm trying to say (and what I think jayzee was trying to convey) is that rbanffy's logic is flawed, and that just because pirating things is easy doesn't make it right. What we call pirating might be okay, but the idea that because something is easy to do it shouldn't be illegal is flawed. Attempting murder is arguably just as easy as downloading a pirated version of a game, but it's not okay. The only difference between the two is that it feels obvious that murder is harmful, but downloading that song instead of paying for it doesn't feel quite as bad. That being said, I agree that copying things should be legal, but not because doing so is easy. I think that it should be legal to copy things because I don't think people should be allowed to restrict what I do just because they want more money.
- nitrogen 15y agoI don't believe rbanffy ever said "easy." The actual word used was "unavoidable." The inevitable result of giving people the practically limitless ability to copy information without cost is that people will copy information. In response to your earlier comment ("...just because a crime is easy to commit..."), the right question to be asking is why something that's inevitable should be considered a crime at all. You might as well outlaw the water cycle. In that light, the question is not "How do we stop the inevitable," but "What do we do to keep making big money in harmony and cooperation with the inevitable?"