7 ms·
What happens if you plug two USB-C laptops into each other using a USB-C cable
- hbossy 4y agoPlugging Dell Vostro 15 5510 into Thinkpad L580 starts charging on Thinkpad and shows a bunch of `[104408.050983] usb usb2-port1: Cannot enable. Maybe the USB cable is bad?` messages in dmesg on both machines.
- Traubenfuchs 4y agoI will do this now with my new macbook pro and an old thinkpad. I will update you with what happened. Lenovo at 50% charges Macbook at 100% if and only if the right macbook port is used. If another macbook port is used, nothing happens. When using this one macbook port (the one right next to the charging port) lenovo also tried to set up a new "macbook pro device", I didn't let it finish. The Lenovo has just one USB-C port. I now wonder what two macbook pros or two lenovos would do to each other.
- atemerev 4y agofamous last words!
- johnwalkr 4y agoI have a work (intel) and personal MacBook Pro (m1) and sometimes I plug the 2 together using a thunderbolt 3 cable (only one connected to a charging cable). Both charge and internet sharing/networking also works.
- fps_doug 4y agoDoes it matter which one is connected to the charger? If not, that would mean they adjust that "power level" value they send over the other port which is used to determine who charges who. While it would perfectly make sense to implement it that way, I'd also be surprised that manufacturers actually do.
- johnwalkr 4y agoI don't know, I didn't think about or try to see what happens when both are on battery power. I don't see how they could negotiate with each other based on battery level from my knowledge of how usb PD works. I do know that macbooks only accept one (the highest rated) power input, so when one is plugged in, it will also charge from the plugged in macbook to the other one. When trying to google for the answer, I noticed a lot of misinformation about this topic, and it doesn't seem well-known that thunderbolt can be used for networking data transfer instead of "target disk mode", which is not even support on Mx macs. Anyway, finally I found a convincing answer: It depends on the order of plugging in the cable and the first mac will plug in the second![1] This is great, the user gets to decide, and I am glad you asked this question! [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hV-zqi_ztw0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hV-zqi_ztw0
- antipaul 4y agoWhich MBP model? I think it may matter
- musicale 4y ago> two macbook pros IIRC the second one you plug in charges the first. You can also charge from a single MacBook Pro that is plugged into a power adapter, in a daisy-chain or star topology.
- actionfromafar 4y agoTwitter won't load the video for me. Edit: whatever is in the post (poll?) won't load for me.
- xg15 4y agoIt's just a meme of earth exploding. You didn't miss anything interesting.
- Traubenfuchs 4y agoThere is a video? I just see a poll.
- cf100clunk 4y agoHere's a Nitter link that might work: https://nitter.priv.pw/d_feldman/status/1615871748708388864 https://nitter.priv.pw/d_feldman/status/1615871748708388864
- vlan0 4y agoReminds me of the IEEE 1394 days. https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc2734 https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc2734
- ilyt 4y agoThink Linux even had kernel driver for it. It was even technically useful as even slowest firewire was faster than then-typical 100Mbit ethernet
- dfox 4y agoThat depends on what you mean by "faster". Firewire has this weird half-duplex "logical bus on physical star" topology which combined with the IP traffic having pretty low QoS priority (best effort bulk data) means that the latency is horrible compared to switched ethernet.
- bradrn 4y agoLater in the conversation someone links to a Twitter exchange which I found quite interesting: > (@m_ou_se) I just tried to charge my phone by connecting it to my laptop (with USB-C), but instead of my phone, my laptop started getting charged, quickly draining my phone's battery. Uh, what. > (@Gankra_) in case you aren't familiar: there was a semantic function of asymmetric usb cables that symmetric usb-C has broken. to "fix" this, each device picks a number for how subby it is, and the less subby one is the dom and charges the sub. these numbers can be surprising. > (@m_ou_se) After some experimenting, I concluded that Dell laptops are the most powerful USB-C PD doms followed by ThinkPads, while phones and MacBooks are (equally) subby. Connecting phones and MacBooks with each other results in a switch fight. (https://twitter.com/m_ou_se/status/1502664680602492933 https://twitter.com/m_ou_se/status/1502664680602492933)
- detrites 4y agoI can't fathom how we all went ten years without knowing this stuff.
- doubled112 4y agoDidn't have a laptop with USB-C ports until 2021. I've got a couple now. One does PD, one does not. One does video out, one does not. One charges fast, and you guessed it, one does not. Is it supposed to be easy because the cables fit? Honestly, it's only made it harder and I know what I'm doing. "It fits but doesn't do what I was told it would" is probably more confusing to the average Joe.
- philliphaydon 4y agoBut but everything used usb-c so iPhones must be usb-c now toooooo!!! I like the physical connection of usb-c but that’s it. The whole thing is an absolute mess. I’m going to miss lightening port.
- mycall 4y ago> everything used usb-c so iPhones must be usb-c now toooooo EU agrees with this.
- have_faith 4y agoWhat happens if you daisy chain a load of devices together into a circle?
- Faaak 4y agoSupposing they each charge each other, the overall battery will drain due to the inefficiency of the DC/DC converters
- number6 4y agoThe circle becomes a particle accelerator. Source: I have a theoretical degree in physics.
- polyterative 4y agomade me laugh so much
- candiodari 4y agoAll I can say is that, in theory, theory and practice are the same. In practice however ...
- MontagFTB 4y ago“Check out these bitcoin mining hacks! Number four will surprise you.”
- HPsquared 4y agoDepends on their relative position in the hierarchy
- senttoschool 4y agoPlugged a 16" AS MBP into a Lenovo. Nothing happened.
- ThinkBeat 4y agoA link ot a poll? That was disappointing I was expecting a write up and pictures. Should I know who this person is? The headline should be modified to lower expectations. "Guy polls Twitter about the result of connecting usb c laptops with usb c cable." "Twitter poll on the outcome of connecting two usb c laptops with a usb c cable" I am no good at headlines obviously. Further it depends on the USB C cable being used, and the properties / capabilities of the ports being used. Given all the different things a USB C port can do these days and the fun smallish fire that happens if you use a cheap usb c cable and abuse it to do something it was not intended for I think there could be multiple distinct outcomes.
- remram 4y agoEspecially useless since it depends on the laptops (models & config)
- sylware 4y agoPersonally, I use such cable in order to use xHCI DBC capabilities. Aka, debug tracing.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rebolek 4y agoWhat happens if you plug USB-A late 2008 aluminum Macbook into USB-microA Panasonic DC-FZ82? It will show your photos. What happens if you plug USB-C Thinkpad T480 into USB-microA Panasonic DC-FZ82? It will show your photos. What happens if you plug USB-C 2022 Macbook Air into USB-microA Panasonic DC-FZ82? Nothing. It won't even show in `/dev/` and you need to use an annoying and shitty app over stupid Wi-Fi.
- skunkworker 4y agoI ran into a similar issue with thunderbolt and two laptops. Laptop A was being charged by a usb-c dock, I plugged laptop B into laptop A via thunderbolt (for thunderbolt bridge networking). And laptop very slowly drained power in the battery but was running off of the power from Laptop A. Then I plugged laptop B into it’s own USB-C brick (on the same surge protector), and nothing happened other than it took me a quick second to think if it was okay to do.
- prettyStandard 4y agoI plugged my TitanRidge ThunderBolt PCIe add in card to my Framework Laptop and my 2019 MBP. It didn't charge either. I did plug my power supply in to the TitanRidge. Very Disappointed. I was under the impression when you plug two thunderbolt devices into each other you got charging and a network connection.
- xenadu02 4y agoYou'd think the USB-PD spec would have devices exchange their battery capacity, charge level, and AC power state. There is no scenario where anyone wants a 80-100Ah device like a laptop to charge from a 3-4Ah device like a phone if both are on battery. Only if the device with a small battery is on AC power should it offer anything to the larger device. So the spec should prohibit this. Secondly you'd think for devices of comparable battery capacity they'd prioritize having the one with AC power feed the one without it. If neither have AC power then have the one with a higher charge level feed the one with a lower charge level only when the one with the lower level reaches 20% and only as much as necessary to maintain 20%. Once the system providing power hits some threshold (40%?) stop feeding power altogether. This would do what most people want when you connect two laptops or two phones: share enough power to keep the other device running but don't completely drain them. If a "battery bank" flag is set then it should always be a supplier unless the other end is a power supply. You can have minor quibbles about the exact numbers here but this strategy is simple and does the right thing the vast majority of the time.
- jefftk 4y ago> If a "battery bank" flag is set then it should always be a supplier unless the other end is a power supply. If I plug my laptop into the wall and my battery bank into my laptop I want the laptop to charge the battery bank.
- pydry 4y ago>You'd think the USB-PD spec would have devices exchange their battery capacity, charge level, and AC power state. Screw that. They just need a signal for one device to tell the other that it wants to charge or be charged. The rest can be left up to the UI. It's better if it isn't smart. I'm mystified that we have this many USB C cable types, chargers and data transfer speeds and there isn't some protocol for explaining what is available when a cable is plugged in or dictating behavior based upon that.
- rektide 4y agoUSB HID defines a good number of power/battery telemetry/control items. It's bothered me a lot that no battery pack or chargers expose themselves as such in actual USB. This whole series of resistors in usb legacy and aux channel chat in usb-pd makes me more than a bit sad. I would have liked to have used longstanding usb hid specs to implememt usb-pd, rather than having assorted side-band negotiations. It still leaves the question of how two laptops would work. The naive "wait to see if there's a device and if not become the device" strategy more or less mirrors what usb-pd already does, with all the weird uncontrollable quirks. Im not sure how usb4 figures out there is a host-to-host link & negotiates networking, that's another wrinkle that might give us a good extension point to build from to enable bidirectional control. Maybe we run usb-ip over the network link - expose our usb hid battery/charger devices over that! ;p
- mensetmanusman 4y agoDevs need to solve this ambiguity with standardized pop-ups that ask the user what the goal of the connection is.
- TobiWestside 4y agoTried this a few weeks ago with two MBPs: one of them started charging, depending on which end of the cable I plugged in first.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- elwebmaster 4y agoTotal nonsense of technology. I can assemble a whole PC without knowing anything about its components just by virtue of there being only one way to connect components to each other. Yet, one can’t even consistently charge a phone these days by just plugging it to a laptop.
- musicale 4y agoA USB to Lightning cable has worked consistently for me for charging my iPhone (and iPad, Apple keyboard and trackpad, etc.) for the past decade or so.
- musicale 4y agoApple laptops can charge each other; I believe the second one you plug in charges the first. I haven't tried a feedback loop however. A possibly more useful scenario that I've seen when power outlets are scarce is daisy-chaining multiple laptops to the one that is plugged in.