3 ms·
Sadly, the moral of the story seems to be that the 1943 FBI had loads of zealous (performative?) plods on staff, but ~zero law enforcement professionals. In '4
by bell-cot 4y ago
Sadly, the moral of the story seems to be that the 1943 FBI had loads of zealous (performative?) plods on staff, but ~zero law enforcement professionals. In '43, the US had plenty of highly competent professional cryptographers, who were quite experienced with current Japanese, German, Italian, British, etc. codes. Before an entire local FBI office spent even a day on this case (let alone 6 weeks), maybe they should have asked some of those professionals to look at the supposed "Japanese code key" page? If it turned out to be a known code that (say) Canada used for low-security consular messages, that'd quickly narrow down or close the case.
EDIT: If they believed the "Japanese code key" page might be genuine, why didn't they pass it up to the professional code-breakers ASAP? Sitting on it, while the Japanese used the code to plan an attack on the US, could make that local FBI office look like a bunch of idiots and traitors. So perhaps they did pass it up, were told that it was a waste of time...but didn't want to accept that answer.
- rvba 4y agoWell maybe the local office didnt have anything else to do. So they followed this lead as a top priority since they had no other leads. Money would be spend on the wages of those agents anyway, even if they had nothing to do.
- greggsy 4y agoIt’s important not to fall into the trap of hindsight. At the time, they very well thought it was important, but it of course seems silly once you hear the full story.
- bell-cot 4y agoNote my edit, above. If they suspected it really was important, then they should have passed it up to the code-breakers ASAP.
- halJordan 4y agoThis is an important lesson I think. Much of the assumed professionalism we have now is built on the lessons these people learned from serious introspection of their own actions.
- mauriciolange 4y agoThis was a code key, not a codified message, so there was nothing to break, but only the indication that messages could have been exchanged using this key.
- adastra22 4y agoWhich is gold material for the code breakers. The people trying to decrypt messages having to do with the ongoing war at the time.
- quietbritishjim 4y agoYes but if the codebreakers also came across a (real!) coded message, wouldn't they want to have the key already to hand so that it can be decrypted?
- pjc50 4y agoThat was Hoover's FBI, the peak of hunting for anyone suspected of being a communist, gay, dissident, or anti-segregationist.
- bell-cot 4y agoTrue-ish. But in 1943, it sounds like they'd gotten badly distracted by some less-important "Japanese" stuff...
- bell-cot 4y agoAlso - "Working for the Evil Overlord" is no excuse for gross incompetence. By late 1943, there seem to have been at least 4 independent communist spies inside the uber-secret Manhattan Project. Most of them with communist connections which competent zealous plods, perhaps eager to be heroes, could have uncovered.
- dwighttk 4y ago>If it turned out to be a known code that (say) Canada used for low-security consular messages, that'd quickly narrow down or close the case. It was made up by the two kids, so maybe they did that but it didn’t narrow down their case…
- flavius29663 4y agoI don't understand your point here. He lost the cypher itself, not an encrypted message. So the code breakers would have said: yep, that's a cypher alright, it can be used for anything by anyone. Being at war, you want to make sure it's not an enemy using the code.
- petesergeant 4y ago> Before an entire local FBI office spent even a day on this case (let alone 6 weeks), maybe they should have asked some of those professionals to look at the supposed "Japanese code key" page? That sounds far less exciting than scrambling to find a fifth columnist and potentially being hailed as a hero.
- bell-cot 4y agoTrue. But most people, after they've been grown-ups for a while, figure out that "find the winning lotto ticket on the sidewalk and get rich" is not how life actually works. And with a war on...the FBI's kids, simpletons, day dreamers, and glory hounds should have been closely supervised by real grown-ups. Or transferred to lines of work better suited to their talents.
- koliber 4y ago> most people, after they've been grown-ups for a while, figure out that "find the winning lotto ticket on the sidewalk and get rich" True, but it's not completely bleak either. I once wanted to take out $40 from an ATM, and it gave me $60! I never told anyone and this is the first time I am sharing this. If a time comes to fill out a security clearance application, should this go in there? Moral of the story: it takes money to make money. :)
- felipemnoa 4y agoYour secret is safe with us ;)
- skissane 4y ago> True, but it's not completely bleak either. I once wanted to take out $40 from an ATM, and it gave me $60! One time, I wanted to take $40 out of an ATM, it gave me $80 instead. I checked my Internet banking - they had the ATM withdrawal at the expected location, but only for $40, which is all I’d asked for. Then, a few days later, I got another $40 debit transaction, but of a strange type I’d never seen before - it was labelled something like “MANUAL ADJUSTMENT”. I assume someone at the bank had worked out that the ATM screwed up and manually corrected it.