3 ms·
Sending money to a scammer tends to be an authorized transfer; you made it yourself, intentionally. The Zelle page you said itself states "Because you authorize
by ceejayoz 4y ago
Sending money to a scammer tends to be an authorized transfer; you made it yourself, intentionally. The Zelle page you said itself states "Because you authorized the payment, you may not be able to get your money back."
I would not hang my hat on a Regulation E complaint in this scenario.
- Karunamon 4y agoI think you are both sort of correct. The pertinent bit of regulation E[1] appears to hinge on how the fraudulent transfer was done. It looks like if you as the authorized person transfer money to somebody because you were scammed into doing so, then the regulation does not apply. However, if you were scammed into giving up your, say, debit card number or password, and this was used to to initiate transfers, the regulation does apply. The magic words here are "access device" and "unauthorized". That being said once you start throwing around laws that the average consumer doesn't know about, on certified letters directed at important people, the bank very well might make you whole rather than fight it even if you have no case. [1]: https://www.consumerfinance.gov/rules-policy/regulations/1005/2/#m https://www.consumerfinance.gov/rules-policy/regulations/100...
- snotrockets 4y agoThe intent (which is how law and regulation are interpreted), as expressed in the regulator comments on the regulation (e.g. 2(m)-4 at the link above), was to make sure the cost, to consumer, of using electronic services, is the same as having a human do the task. Just imagine calling, or going to the bank to make a similar transfer to a scammy zelle one. I assure you the person you'd be speaking to would have to ask you some very pointed questions about that transfer, and not out of the goodness of their hearts. banks try to replace humans with software to reduce their costs; reg E basically is "you're only allowed to harm your own workforce doing so, not your customers"
- snotrockets 4y agoZelle can write that water are dry, it will not make it so. The customer intended to authorize a non-scammy transfer, but was scammed into authorizing himself into a fraud. As such, regulation E holds. And if there's something bank fears is someone reminding their regulator the bank may not be following regulation to the letter. It has been made very clear that regulation E is meant to held banks responsible for misuse of electronic services. For example, if you are coerced to draw money out of an ATM, regulation E holds, even as you authorized the withdrawal with your card and PIN code (it also makes perfect sense: there's assumption the same wouldn't be as easy had you had to use a teller for that withdrawal).
- ceejayoz 4y ago> As such, regulation E holds. I've cited the exact wording of Regulation E to you elsewhere; it's pretty clear this scenario is not an unauthorized transfer.
- snotrockets 4y agoIt isn't. Law and regulation are interpreted by intent, not by a google search (also see official interpretation 2(m)-4 there)
- ceejayoz 4y ago> Law and regulation are interpreted by intent Nothing in Regulation E indicates an intent to cover intentional transfers by the account holder to scammers. Quote something specific if you disagree. > also see official interpretation 2(m)-4 there None of those scenarios match "I willingly sent money to something that turned out to be a scam". At all. Each example in that interpretation is that of an unintentional transfer - bank employees doing it, stolen devices, being under duress.