7 ms·
Current and future role of Haber–Bosch ammonia in a carbon-free energy env(2020)
- Isamu 4y agoTo the point: >Despite the technical feasibility of the electrically-driven Haber–Bosch ammonia, the question still remains whether such revolution will take place. We reveal that its success relies on two factors: increased energy efficiency and the development of small-scale, distributed and agile processes that can align to the geographically isolated and intermittent renewable energy sources.
- chicob 4y agoThe point. I have to say this article was published in December 2019, and since then some projects for new green ammonia plants have been planned (although I must update this information). Synthetic fertilizers are not just about ammonia: urea is needed too, and the existing infrastructure accounts for both, produced in close proximity. And using natural gas, the big problem. Also, another thing: urea production needs carbon, currently provided by methane. If the source is the atmosphere, then producing green fertilizer would not only be carbon neutral, it could become negative. But again, if, if, if... Where renewable energy is cheap and not easily exportable (e.g. Greenland, that recycles energy-intensive aluminum), this could be a way of exporting it indirectly and of diversifying the economy. Either that or hydrogen exports. There is also the geopolitical perspective, since the world trade of fertilizers depend too much on states that tend to regard international law as optional: Russia, Belarus and Morocco (for urea and potassium, potassium, and phosphorus, respectively).
- chicob 4y agoHere's the project I mentioned: https://www.bondalti.com/en/multimedia/news/bondalti-fosters-hydrogen-strategy/ https://www.bondalti.com/en/multimedia/news/bondalti-fosters...
- logifail 4y ago> states that tend to regard international law as optional I know HN isn't supposed to be about politics, and not wishing to get into specifics and thus provoke an detailed argument, but many of us know of plenty of other "friendly" states that are happy to ignore international law whenever and wherever it suits them. For those who haven't heard it, the BBC's "One Day In August" is really worthwhile: https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b04nrqsk https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b04nrqsk
- chicob 4y agoBtw I meant Iceland, not Greenland.
- RosanaAnaDana 4y agoHa! As an avid gardener who who got solar panels recently, I've seriously considered looking deeper into this. When I spec'd out my system, I did some back of the napkin math on mining bitcoin with surplus pixies during the day, and it came something on the order of 10x more profitable than what my utility is willing to give me for those same pixies. However, I don't really use bitcoin. I do however, have an ongoing need for nitrogen fertilizers. I've been digging about into what it would take to drive the Haber Bosch process at a home scale. A couple of 10's of kg of fixed nitrogen a month would be more valuable to me than what my utility is willing to pay, and I could put it right to work in the garden beds.
- ciconia 4y agoThere are so many alternatives to chemical fertilizer: manure (cow, horse, chicken, human), compost, planting nitrogen fixers, sowing ground cover plants... Depending on where you live each may be easier or harder to produce or procure. In addition there are generative techniques that concentrate on soil fertility: permaculture, cover crops, syntropic agroforestry to name a few. I have never used a chemical fertilizer in my garden, and am striving towards a completely autonomous fertilization cycle, where my garden's fertility grows each year without any external input.
- jvanderbot 4y agoImagine throwing 50kg of manure into the back of your tesla every spring.
- RosanaAnaDana 4y ago50kg? Try more like 500kg. I usually get a 5 yard load dropped off once a year, and that isn't nearly enough.
- 082349872349872 4y agoHN readers may be amused to learn that "New Idea" is a brand name of manure spreaders.
- berjin 4y agoIn my limited knowledge of fertilizers the larger problem seems to be P and K which are sourced from mined minerals rather than air. It's possible to fix soil N with legumes but I don't know of a sustainable solution for PK leaving the farm with crop outputs.
- schiffern 4y agoP and K are abundant in the world's agricultural soils. They just need to be 'eaten' (dissolved) by soil microorganisms.[1] The problem is that farmers have been taught to ignore the health of soil organisms and just apply a short-term bandaid chemical (vs biological) spray product, which causes more harm in the long-term. Take a wild guess who taught them that? [1] https://youtu.be/x2H60ritjag https://youtu.be/x2H60ritjag
- berjin 4y agoProbably companies like Bayer and Yara. I'm aware that chemicals like glyphosate are detrimental to fungi and soil bacteria. But I don't think regenerative farming with no mineral inputs is sustainable either. As this story shows there isn't always enough PK to pull out of the soil https://www.newsroom.co.nz/green-dream-pushes-farmers-into-red https://www.newsroom.co.nz/green-dream-pushes-farmers-into-r...
- schiffern 4y ago"Abundant" != "ubiquitous," but I see your point. There are always exceptions, but in aggregate (no pun intended...) the world's agricultural soils have no shortage of minerals. Ultimately, this might be a simple story of "better soil outcompetes lower quality soil." Stop the presses! :) But I don't see how one exceptional case invalidates the use of soil biology to break down in-situ minerals. I haven't evaluated their property, but they may benefit from relatively inexpensive glacial rock dust amendment. Sounds like their system could be rate-limited in the rock weathering step, not the biological activity.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- effnorwood 4y ago[dead]