4 ms·
The problem isn't meritocracy. The problem is that what we are calling a meritocracy isn't one as it is based on luck and connections. All this "networking" tal
by giantg2 4y ago
The problem isn't meritocracy. The problem is that what we are calling a meritocracy isn't one as it is based on luck and connections. All this "networking" talk that I see on here and any career development site - it's the opposite of a meritocracy and disadvantages anyone not in the "in" group.
- acjohnson55 4y agoI thought that too, once. But now I think that the concept of meritocracy is fundamentally flawed. First, it has no ability to differentiate merit manufactured by previous iterations of the meritocracy game from other forms of potential or reasons to invest in a person or reward them. Second, it implicitly devalues people who seem to be lacking in merit, amplifying the effects of any sort of disadvantage. I don't know that a society based on merit can ever truly be humanitarian. This plays out in very visible ways, in America, the most meritocratic of cultures. We tolerate an astounding amount of completely avoidable misery. As an American, steeped in meritocratic thinking from birth, it's frankly scary and disorienting to imagine what things would be like if you took meritocracy off its pedestal. I think you'd see a happier society, but also a loss of the economic competitive edge that is the source of our power in the world. Meritocracy might truly be our state religion and the main thing that binds this country together.
- Loughla 4y agoBingo. If getting the job requires you to know the hiring manager to even know about the opening, it is not a meritocracy. It's a birthright. If you don't know the secret codes or secret power holders, you're just stuck on the outside looking in. And these secret codes have little to nothing to do with actual ability.
- chrisweekly 4y agoSort of. Being effective in nearly any role requires interpersonal skills, and it's not unreasonable for the strength of one's professional network to play a role in landing interviews. Of course at one extreme, pure nepotism does exist as the "opposite of meritocracy" you bemoan -- but that hardly represents the majority case, where human connection and evidence that someone, somewhere, was glad to have worked with you, improves your perceived strength as a candidate. TLDR even if you write code for a living, your career is still all about people.
- giantg2 4y agoThe part you're missing is that candidate A might be just as better than and just as sociable as candidate B. But if the manager knows candidate B, candidate B will get the job. The result is that the best person did not get the job. It's observation bias.
- chrisweekly 4y agoI'm not really "missing" that part, rather I have a different PoV. In my experience on both sides of the tech hiring equation over the past 24 years, it's not a given that "B will get the job" (based solely on familiarity). I agree it's more likely, but mostly to a reasonable degree in that it helps de-risk the hire. I've also seen the opposite case, where a candidate's perceived ceiling or limited potential upside (based on outdated "familiarity" w/ their abilities) counted against them, failing to account for their growth. My point remains: do good work and don't neglect connecting w people and making good impressions; relationships w colleagues are essential to a strong career.
- giantg2 4y ago"are essential to a strong career." It seems we're discussing two separate things.
- chrisweekly 4y agoOur discussion stemmed from your complaints about career development advice, and the OP is all about what steps to take to have a strong career. No big deal, your point about observation bias is relevant, we simply apparently disagree about how important it is.
- giantg2 4y agoI was discussing how it is not a meritocracy. Whether the career advice is good or not is not the point. The point is that we are not in meritocracy.
- altruios 4y agoThe meritocracy measures along the vector of manipulation.
- dgb23 4y agoWe are social animals. Sociability, communication skills and demonstrating that you "show up" have a lot of merit. I'm not very good at either of those things, but I appreciate them and try to improve on them, because they are important. In my eyes the real problem is not whether there is an "in group" as you say, but whether there is gatekeeping and what it is based on. Do people just happen to have the right surname, gender or skin color? Or is it really about engaging, kind, fun personalities who are competent and hard working. If it is the former, then it is not a good group to be part of at all. But the latter describes a group that is based on merit.
- giantg2 4y ago"Sociability, communication skills and demonstrating that you "show up" have a lot of merit." It depends on how that's done. You can have someone who "demonstrates" that stuff via manipulation. Those people are generally not great for achieving whatever your company goal is. While they might be an asset today, they can turn. Gatekeeping is an issue too. But even if you eliminate those, a random candidate will almost always lose to a personally known candidate due to observation bias. The gatekeepers aspects are a part of this too - you are more likely to be in the "known" category if you share the same attributes as the manager.