6 ms·
It's kind of insulting to tell someone that you know better than they do what's good for them. A Kenyan has told you that this job pays substantially better th
by lolinder 4y ago
It's kind of insulting to tell someone that you know better than they do what's good for them.
A Kenyan has told you that this job pays substantially better than average and that they wish more companies would make such jobs available, and your response is "no, you're wrong, this job pays too little". On what basis do you make that claim? What makes you better qualified than OP to comment on conditions in Kenya?
- AlexandrB 4y agoFair point. But this is also the exact problem with allowing a small number of individuals to accrue massive wealth by arbitraging labor costs like this. It doesn't matter how much philanthropy Bill Gates engages in, he doesn't understand the needs of the poor better than they do. Instead of having this elaborate, inefficient system of funnelling money to first world billionaires and then having them (maybe) send some of it back to the developing world, wouldn't it be better if these workers were just paid better in the first place?
- lolinder 4y agoIn theory, yes, but at some wage level it wouldn't make sense to choose Kenya over India. At another threshold it wouldn't make sense to choose India over the US. There is overhead to sending jobs to poor, unstable countries in timezones far from headquarters. If we insist that everyone, worldwide should be paid the same wages we are in the US, what incentive do companies have for not just hiring locally and avoiding those costs? If we step it back and say "okay, you should at least pay what you would in India", then why not just hire in India, which is a far more predictable environment than Kenya?
- supriyo-biswas 4y agoThe job pays too little based on the fact that it can leave the "employees" traumatized and scarred for life. But it does not take away from the fact that it can negatively affect the employees in an adverse way long term, and takes advantage of poor people to give them an objectively bad deal based on an information asymmetry where the person in question might not know that they have to read graphic descriptions of bestiality and pedophilia.
- quonn 4y ago> traumatized and scarred for life. Scarred for life by reading/labeling text? There is obviously a big difference between labelling pictures or video and text. I would be open to seeing an actually study, but my prior would be that text must be harmless. I would certainly be open to reading any text, especially if the context is that the text is for training purposes.
- key_stroker 4y agoSome had images, also they did other work for the hiring company.
- replwoacause 4y agoSounds like you haven't read the article.
- quonn 4y agoCorrect. But then the headline is confusing.
- realAzazello 4y agoOther content filtering work is primarily videos & pictures. Check out this article: https://www.wired.com/story/social-enterprise-technology-africa/ https://www.wired.com/story/social-enterprise-technology-afr... Sama/source in trouble yet again!
- lolinder 4y agoThis is an argument that the job shouldn't exist at all. That's an okay argument to make (I personally lean that way), but has no relevance to whether $2/hour would be worth it to a Kenyan.
- daveguy 4y agoYou don't see any logic in the difficulty of a job influencing the wage of that job?
- replwoacause 4y agoJust because a group of people is accustomed to poor working conditions doesn't make it any more right or ethical. You could apply your logic to sweatshop scenarios where the people in those countries are just happy to have work, even if the work pays unfair wages, requires unreasonable hours, uses child labor, and provides no benefits to the workers. But hey... the disenfranchised are just happy to have a paycheck right?
- lolinder 4y agoWhat would constitute a fair wage? The same as what we would have been paid in the US? Maybe India? If we insist upon that, then why hire in Kenya, which is an unstable and unpredictable environment that has a lot of inherent risks for the company? Or are you arguing these jobs shouldn't exist at all?
- replwoacause 4y agoI'm not a labor wage specialist so your guess is as good as mine. Do you think $1.32/hr. is fair? Are you of the impression after reading the article that the worker's wellbeing was taken seriously and the pay was set at a fair amount considering the kind of work they were doing? I wasn't.
- lolinder 4y agoIf you're not a wage specialist and my guess is as good as yours, why were you so quick to dismiss someone who actually lives in the country you're opining on?
- replwoacause 4y agoIt's clear you're one who enjoys a circular argument so I'll just leave it at this for you. I don't need to know the exact right amount of money these people should be paid to know that $1.32 per hour for looking at child porn and violent imagery is too little, especially without the requisite mental health resources available. If you are so sure this is a fair situation, maybe for your next job you'll accept minimum wage pay doing similar work.
- yawboakye 4y agowhat's insulting is that you assume one kenyan speaks for all of them. even worse, that the random kenyan not being paid $2/hr by openai is qualified to speak on their behalf. on what basis do you accept the first statement. if another kenyan claims the opposite would be then become some vacillating organism between two (or more) positions?
- lolinder 4y agoI only assume that one Kenyan is more representative than one westerner. I'd happily invite other Kenyans to comment their own perspective!
- Graffur 4y agoDo you think that person speaks for all Kenyans? Clearly $2 an hour is too little but people are exploitable when they need money.
- lolinder 4y agoI already replied to this question: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34427780 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34427780 > I only assume that one Kenyan is more representative than one westerner. I'd happily invite other Kenyans to comment their own perspective!
- blagie 4y agoYou're confusing being poor with being financially stressed. The two are not the same.