11 ms·
ReactOS
- IYasha 4y agoI truly wish these guys to succeed! Watching ReactOS for a decade or more.
- andrewclunn 4y agoWhen the newest "latest news" story is for Google Summer of Code 2022... why is this being submitted?
- xen2xen1 4y agoWondered the same.. Because they could? I get changelogs, updates, but..
- hnbad 4y agoProbably because someone bumped into it, found it interesting and decided to post it to HN (again). Not all submissions are driven by marketing sockpuppets.
- SquareWheel 4y agoI don't think anybody is accusing the submitter of being a sockpuppet. It's just a rather well-known project already, and there's not any news to discuss related to it right now (as far as I know). I get that there's always one of today's lucky 10,000, but I think a certain threshold of obscureness is reasonable. It wouldn't make sense to submit the Linux Kernel project, or Mozilla Firefox without any news. Maybe I'm overestimating how well-known ReactOS is, though.
- smcl 4y agoI was wondering if they'd reached some new milestone, but yeah it seems it's just one of the "check this cool project out" submissions. It's fair enough, as you said there will be the xkcd lucky 10k who are encountering it for the first time. Though now that you mention it, it would at least be a little bit funny to submit kernel.org and be like "Found this cool indy OS kernel, looks like it's just a hobby and won't be big and professional like GNU but it's still neat" in the comments :)
- fsflover 4y ago> rather well-known project already Do you believe that most of the HN audience know ReactOS very well? I upvoted the submission, because I don't think so.
- _joel 4y agoDepends how often they use the site. It's been posted about many times before. https://hn.algolia.com/?q=ReactOS https://hn.algolia.com/?q=ReactOS
- SquareWheel 4y agoDo I believe they know the project "very well"? No, probably not, but that's an extremely high bar to meet.
- giancarlostoro 4y agoI've followed the project for years, and I assume not literally everyone on HN is aware of it, maybe the power users, but the casual HN reader might find it interesting.
- worble 4y agoWhy not?
- skrowl 4y agoThis is why HN post subject of just the project name are confusing. Is there something new here we should be excited about in the project?
- theodric 4y agoI, for one, just thought of ReactOS again 2 days ago after a large gap. Perhaps the Zeitgeist is presently weighted toward ReactOS. Can't possibly just be my own confirmation bias, because I'm a rational thinker, you see.
- giancarlostoro 4y agoI posted it mainly because not everyone on HN is always aware that ReactOS exists, the thread shows up every year or so, and you always find someone learned something new. I also love the engagement around the subject, sometimes you learn something new about the project.
- _joel 4y agoI wondered too, had a dig through the news/releases since the last post, not real update. Good to let others know of the project though, I guess
- asveikau 4y agoForget 2022, reactos has been around for multiple decades. But I think varying amounts of the HN audience are unfamiliar with any given topic that might seem like old news.
- Synaesthesia 4y agoI've seen this many times before, now I'm curious to know a lot more about it. How does it run, does all windows software run well, even advanced apps and games (doubt it)! What is the basis? Is it based on Linux? edit: naturally the Wikipedia answered all my questions. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ReactOS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ReactOS
- Dwedit 4y agoIt's basically a rewrite of the Windows 2000/XP Kernel space and user space. Then they decided to bring in code from Wine to speed up development.
- giancarlostoro 4y agoI said this in another comment, but I feel like they're missing an opportunity not reaching out to Valve / Steam to work on Proton and integrating that instead. Steam will pay people to work on Proton fixes, so it seems like a no brainer to me.
- iillexial 4y agoI'm curious now, is this project has a purpose to get some share of users from Windows? Or is it just a fun/hobby project? I'm asking it because the OS itself is 25 years old, however it is not really ready for everyday usage. Funny thing, I have seen it once on the screen of a cashbox in a supermarket in Kyiv. However, it is not clear if they really used ReactOS, or just their logo/graphics to avoid buying license for Windows. UPD: Found the photo https://i.imgur.com/5biLbTj.jpg https://i.imgur.com/5biLbTj.jpg (2016)
- noobermin 4y agoI feel like 10 years ago or so, everyone would have seen this and thought it was understandable that a project like ReactOS would still be in alpha after all these years and still somewhat unstable. However, since then lots of open source OSes have started and have had some stability, although no widespread usage yet, primarily because these OSes are being developed on the side by people like google or facebook. And so may be that is why people look at reactOS after all this time and are surprised it's still a small shop. It's similar to GIMP. GIMP was "impressive for open source" in 2013 but now it's behind the times when things like Photopea exist. May be ReactOS hasn't kept up with the progress people now expect from open source projects.
- giancarlostoro 4y agoI feel like ReactOS should try to see if they can get with Steam / Valve to work something out where they both work on Proton together, and Valve lets them use their efforts for ReactOS, and gives them well needed funding. My understanding is they are reaching for similarish goals. One benefit of ReactOS is it tries to support Windows drivers, I'm not sure if Wine does this or not? But for something like SteamOS if it doesn't have driver support, it would make way too much sense to support it via Proton / ReactOS.
- _joel 4y agoDirectX (not sure which version) has been show to run, the patches are in master now (that was 7 months ago). No idea about Vulkan etc. edit: I've just seen Space Cadet Pinball running, what more do you want? :)
- guerrilla 4y agoSo, what's it still bad at?
- actionfromafar 4y agoI think ReactOS has an unfulfilled promise it can't deliver on yet, but is so tantalizingly close. You know how people complain about how Windows adds weird shit and is no longer just an OS, staying out of your way and which you can run applications on? You know how there are so many false starts of a Linux distribution which will be simple to use, no-nonse, and just be user friendly? (Looking at you, ElementaryOS.) Well, ReactOS could be all that. Just an OS. Free license. Most old-school programs just work, and for newly developed Win32 programs, very few tweaks are usually needed to them running on ReactOS. What's missing, in priority order? - STABILITY - "Marketing" to show you can develop modern apps for ReactOS - Hardware support - Make sure .NET works (not everything, but the basics) Stability is key. It's unstable even on VirtualBox. Hardware support is nice to have, but you could deploy ReactOS on modern hardware by booting Linux as essentially a hypervisor and run nothing but ReactOS in thin VM at boot. All projects need marketing, even Open Source ones. Everything needs a story to tell what it's about. Having .NET work, even in a limited capacity, would open up ReactOS as a target to many more developers, useful for pros (embedded) and enthusiasts alike. Parting thoughts: ReactOS is very alluring to me because it doesn't churn and chase the latest, which is tiring in Windows and Mac, but also in Linux land. What if XP or 7 was just updated to support new graphics, 64-bit, new processors (ARM)? I wouldn't mind switching to an open source OS which was all that. I don't mind the Windows "clunkyness" as much as I dislike the ads, the telemetry and the churn. ReactOS reminds me of when my computer was My Computer and not some corporate cloud tentacle.
- prmoustache 4y ago> You know how there are so many false starts of a Linux distribution which will be simple to use, no-nonse, and just be user friendly? (Looking at you, ElementaryOS.) A 3 decades old looking OS with a terrible desktop experience is quite the opposite of what we call user friendly today.
- jbverschoor 4y agoFor people who like to mess around with live cds, https://ventoy.net/ https://ventoy.net/ let's you create a bootable USB stick where you can simply copy .iso files to, and it will let you boot from that iso. That way you don't have to keep reformatting / preparing the usb drive.
- vageli 4y agoThere's also pixiecore [0] with a similar idea but with pxe instead of usb. [0]: https://github.com/danderson/netboot/tree/master/pixiecore https://github.com/danderson/netboot/tree/master/pixiecore
- dns_snek 4y agoVentoy never "worked" for me for some reason. It usually gets me to the ISO selection stage of the boot process, but the image refuses to boot, quickly followed by a reboot. Am I missing a trick? Rufus continues to be easy to use and reliable on the other hand.
- chungy 4y agoVentoy is a fairly common source of trouble from people trying to boot ReactOS. It's a nice, well, toy, but its compatibility with various OSes is spotty at best. You're much better off just writing a real CD-R or USB stick with the plain image than trying to manage it via Ventoy.
- tw1984 4y agoI first heard it back in the days when I was still on 56kbps modem and Clinton was facing his impeachment trial. After so many years especially after the success of linux + wine, I don't think anyone needs a Windows NT clone. I know they share code/knowledge, there is just no practical reason to have a full clone of the NT kernel. I'd further argue that Microsoft should stop developing its windows OS kernel altogether, running wsl2 on top of a boring windows kernel is never the solution. They should build Windows on top of the Linux kernel, I mean let Windows be a good Linux Window Manager.
- yellowapple 4y ago> let Windows be a good Linux Window Manager. Which would be coming full circle back to the days when Windows was a good (for the time) DOS window manager.
- marcodiego 4y agoYes. Windows could be a better wine than wine.
- tech234a 4y agoWorth noting that already did this to support SQL Server on Linux [1]. [1]: https://threedots.ovh/slides/Drawbridge.pdf https://threedots.ovh/slides/Drawbridge.pdf
- nix23 4y agoWine is the better Windows as Microsoft's Windows.
- sedatk 4y agoWhat's that mean? Is it 150% compatible with Windows apps?
- gattilorenz 4y agoIf you consider 16 bit apps, yes.
- collyw 4y agoI had forgotten about this. Looked at it more than a decade ago. What's it like these days? Has anyone got any real world experience?
- qwertox 4y agoHow does Google Chrome run on this? On Windows 7 it started popping up a banner that new Chrome releases won't land on that version of Windows anymore. Does ReactOS pretend to be a certain Windows version?
- actionfromafar 4y agoI can't answer about version, but I don't think Chrome works. I use K-Meleon[0] when surfing on ReactOS. 0: http://kmeleonbrowser.org/forum/read.php?1,125632,156845,page=15 http://kmeleonbrowser.org/forum/read.php?1,125632,156845,pag...
- xet7 4y agoNo, Chrome only runs on newest amd64 Linux/Windows/Mac. For modern browser, there is compatible Firefox fork Mypal where older version works also on ReactOS. It can be installed on ReactOS 32bit from GUI package manager included in ReactOS, and I have also copied it to here: https://releases.wekan.team/mypal/ https://releases.wekan.team/mypal/ When I tried, newer versions of Mypal did not work on ReactOS 32bit. ReactOS 64bit is still more unstable, not much works on it. For older Windows versions like WinXP etc, that Microsoft does not support anymore, there are some replacements for Windows Update, like http://legacyupdate.net http://legacyupdate.net , some others are also listed at https://github.com/wekan/wekan/wiki/Windows https://github.com/wekan/wekan/wiki/Windows . When I tried it, it installed most updates, but not Windows Live Essentials and some other update.
- smm11 4y agoI'm just waiting for ChromeOS to be the thing we adore once Fuchsia roles out.
- getoffmyyawn 4y agoReactOS helped me in a pinch recently when I needed to run a Windows only app to configure an IoT device. As I don't own any Windows system, it's very nice to have an option other than buying or borrowing a copy of Windows.
- actionfromafar 4y agoThat's a very bloggable story. :-)
- owaislone 4y agoNice! Would be great to learn more about your experience. Was Wine not enough? Due to drivers or other features that ReactOS has?
- getoffmyyawn 4y agoTo be honest I didn't think about wine. I haven't used it in a long time. I strongly suspect it would have also worked.
- qayxc 4y agoI'm a bit puzzled by this. You can install Windows without having to buy it. You can even run it forever if you want to - other than a watermark and some personalisation options being locked, nothing is different from an activated copy. For stuff like simply configuring a device, any old ISO or even VM image available directly from MS should do.
- getoffmyyawn 4y agoI think those are good options if you don't mind sending data to Microsoft. edit: typo
- qayxc 4y agoBut how would that even work in a VM not connected to any network? I hear this allegation a lot without anyone being able to explain how an offline installation would even be able to do this...
- josephcsible 4y agoAre there any programs that work in ReactOS but not in Wine?
- flatiron 4y agoProbably ones that need specific windows drivers.
- pelasaco 4y agoI remember when I played with that, was mostly to try to run some old worms/exploits and write win32 offensive code for windows XP.. stuff worked pretty well actually.
- berry_sortoro 4y ago[dead]
- lacoolj 4y agodidnt this have a different name a long time ago?
- sedatk 4y agoIt was the successor of FreeWin95 project, but they were unrelated projects as I understand. This one was named ReactOS since the beginning.
- feldrim 4y agoThe issue with ReactOS is that it's not a greenfield OS project. The devs do not make the biggest architectural decisions. They have to follow MSs steps. Unfortunately, most of those steps are not documented and they must be followed. Because the one and only target of the project is to be fully "Windows compatible".
- xet7 4y agoReactOS has install option to use Btrfs filesystem. Windows does not have that.
- feldrim 4y agoWhich has been almost abandoned since the developer left ReactOS contribution. There's no maintainer if one wants to contribute to Btrfs. IIRC, it was done to find a viable alternative for NTFS as it is almost as hard to develop ReactOS itself. Still, lack of an open source NTFS driver is the most important lack of ReactOS. Because many of the reliability issues are tied to filesystem reliability and FAT is not as reliable as NTFS. When you do a hard reset, registry might get corrupt because it could not flush to disk properly and without a Journaling file system, it's not easy to prevent, rollback, recover from this situation.
- torstenvl 4y agoI'd love to try this out, but any attempts at booting in a VM fail with an error that it's unable to open txtsetup.sif. I've tried pre-formatting the drive as FAT32, FAT16, with and without FreeDOS installed, nothing. I tried the 0.4.14 release as well as recent 0.4.15-dev ISOs, to no avail. This has apparently been an issue for a while, and is a regression. https://jira.reactos.org/browse/CORE-9057 https://jira.reactos.org/browse/CORE-9057 https://jira.reactos.org/browse/CORE-16043 https://jira.reactos.org/browse/CORE-16043 https://jira.reactos.org/browse/CORE-18227 https://jira.reactos.org/browse/CORE-18227 https://jira.reactos.org/browse/CORE-17818 https://jira.reactos.org/browse/CORE-17818 The latest version I can get to boot is reactos-bootcd-0.4.13-dev-1080-g4843c1a-x86-gcc-lin-dbg.7z available at https://iso.reactos.org/bootcd/reactos-bootcd-0.4.13-dev-1080-g4843c1a-x86-gcc-lin-dbg.7z https://iso.reactos.org/bootcd/reactos-bootcd-0.4.13-dev-108... The fact that this regression has been dismissed with "Works on my machine!" is deeply troubling. I can't foresee trusting anything to ReactOS.
- jeditobe 4y agoAs well, you do not describe the exact sequence of actions that leads you to the error. Without it, you cannot be helped. You also provide a list of bug reports that are just similar, but probably not related to your particular issue.
- torstenvl 4y ago> not related to your particular issue That's extremely unlikely and it's concerning that you think the exact same error at the exact same point starting after the exact same last-known good build is "not related." If that's a possible failure mode of your code base then your code base is pure shit.
- jeditobe 4y agoThis problem is very rare. It is very hard to encounter it, unless you have some very specific conditions. You said nothing about the version and name of VM you are using. As well, you do not describe the exact sequence of actions that leads you to the error. Without it, you cannot be helped.
- wereallterrrist 4y agoI'm very curious, from a high-level, but technical level, how differently ReactOS and Wine are. And/or how much they share. As someone who keeps playing Halo Infinite at 120FPS via Proton on a Zephyrus G14 running NixOS, I'm kind of amazed on a daily basis that this is where "Desktop Linux" is. I know that there's a bunch of HNers who used Ubuntu 6 years ago to tell me otherwise, but this is insane. As soon as the HDR kernel patches are rebased on 6.1, I'll have HDR too. (edit: lul, to be fair, NixOS ships upstream latest kernels, so even latest Ubuntu on this laptop might be a serious step back, but that's what you get for listening to Ubuntu users's take on "Desktop Linux".) Just bonkers. I'm getting nearly as good of perf for a DirectX 12 modern game on Linux as I am on Windows. Meanwhile, this is all on ZFS, all incrementally backed up, I can restore this entire state of this laptop in about two minutes. Wow, desktop linux haters can hate, but this is still blowing my mind.
- jeditobe 4y agoPlease join r/reactos/ to have more discussions about ReactOS