4 ms·
Understanding the development of Western Europe is one of the most important things historians could be doing right now. Because those lessons can be applied to
by rayiner 4y ago
Understanding the development of Western Europe is one of the most important things historians could be doing right now. Because those lessons can be applied to help developing nations follow the same trajectory to development.
Unfortunately too much of academia is fixated on faulting the west for past injustices, which leads to an unproductive Eurocentric mindset. (Britain will never, and cannot, pay back India what it took, so no point concerning ourselves about that.)
- maxerickson 4y agoLots of developing countries currently have per capita GDP comparable to western European countries in 1980 (Like as an example, Netherlands vs Vietnam). Why not look at somewhat more modern lessons?
- refurb 4y agoNetherlands had a GDP per capita of $13,000 USD in 1980, equivalent to $49,000 USD today. Vietnam had a GDP per capita of $13,000 USD today. They aren’t even close.
- maxerickson 4y ago~13000 in "Current US$". You don't adjust for inflation and then adjust for inflation again. Vietnam is considerably lower today on that measure (3750), but if you use PPP the comparison isn't quite as stark (but ends in 1990). https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.CD?locations=NL-VN https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.CD?location... https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.PP.CD?locations=NL-VN https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.PP.CD?locat...
- refurb 4y ago$13,000 USD in 1980 isn’t adjusted for inflation. And if you’ve ever lived in Vietnam you’d realize the comparison doesn’t make sense. Vietnam is still very poor today. Netherlands in the 1980’s was a developed nation.
- pffft8888 4y agoNot Britain itself, but the Rothschilds or whomever (I have no idea) became obscenely wealthy as a result of it. Those can pay back India.
- pjc50 4y ago> those lessons can be applied to help developing nations follow the same trajectory to development Not necessarily: firstly, some of those factors were "have the right geology" (coal/iron/later oil), which you can't replicate even if you want to, and secondly we're already in a developed world. That changes the environment and cost/benefit analysis greatly. The first person to develop a steam engine and the 1,000th person to do so are working in a very different way. To develop the third world, it might be more informative to look at the postwar trajectories of Japan, Singapore, Korea, and of course China. > faulting the west for past injustices Many of which are linked directly to present, ongoing injustices, but you'll never read that because you have no interest in engaging with the research itself, only a caricature. Besides, isn't it better history to find out what actually happened rather than just regurgitate the propaganda of the past?
- rayiner 4y ago> Many of which are linked directly to present, ongoing injustices, but you'll never read that because you have no interest in engaging with the research itself, only a caricature. Besides, isn't it better history to find out what actually happened rather than just regurgitate the propaganda of the past? Whether its true or not makes no difference. Studying history with an eye to past injustices puts people into a mindset of dependency, waiting for their former overlords to help them. But Europeans are never going to pay meaningful reparations for colonialism. Ever. The only thing worth learning from history is how Europe got to the point where it could take over Asia and Africa in the first place.
- abdullahkhalids 4y agoBritain and France even TODAY extract significant amounts of wealth from their past colonies. This is due to a variety of structures that go back hundreds of years, embedded deeply into the society of both the coloniser and the formally colonized. Ending this extraction of wealth requires understanding how and why those structures formed.
- CaptArmchair 4y agoI would argue that "applying lessons" ignores not just local geology, but - more importantly - local / regional culture, politics, socio-economics, etc. as well. It assumes that, throughout history, the rest of the world subconsciously has had - and still has - a need for Western-European frameworks of thinking about their place in the world. Which is very eurocentrist perception of the world. A hallmark of post-modern historiography is exactly discarding this history can only be perceived through a western-european lens, and acknowledging that there are as many valid ways of looking at the past as there are cultures and people around the world. > Japan, Singapore, Korea, and of course China Neither Japan, Korea nor China were "third world" countries before WWII. Or even ever. On the contrary. Japan was very much an industrialized nation in the 1930s. Before then, it has a long history as a advanced, albeit, regional power. The same is true about Korea. Chinese history itself is rife with empires and kingdoms - having trade networks, technological advances and so on - some of which being as large and influential - if not more - then the Roman Empire during its heyday. Singapore already was a bustling trade port long before WWII, and has a history of being part of powerful local sultanates before the arrival of the British. If anything, the examples you gave are quite ambivalent about the historical dynamics that led to their integration in today's modern global economic, geo-political, cultural structures and global power balances which were borne out of post-WWII victors creating a new order for peace and development.
- madaxe_again 4y agoIt isn’t just informative for “developing” nations, but also for “developed” nations. To assume we have reached some endpoint of development is absurd, particularly given historical precedent. The article posits that industrialisation was spawned out of necessity due to a shortage of unskilled labour, and an excess of underemployed capital. I find it interesting that the U.K. finds itself once again at a not dissimilar crossroads, with a shortage of unskilled and skilled labour, and with an excess of underemployed, concentrated capital. Growth is sclerotic, the political situation is fragile, and inflation runs rampant. Meanwhile, new technology developed over the preceding century has enabled new possibilities, hitherto unimagined and as yet unrealised. In history, when exposed to severe stressors, societies typically either flourish or collapse. Collapse has become less common in the industrialised, interconnected world, so it’s not an unreasonable hypothesis that perhaps the U.K. will somehow find itself at the forefront of a new productivity revolution.
- wittenbunk 4y agoYou can't understand the rapid development of western Europe without examining how it's colonialism simultaneously enriched europe and sparked conflicts that are still raging. Who would you suggest modern developing nations colonize?
- rayiner 4y agoI don’t think colonization was necessary to European development. Germany rapidly developed too without colonizing anyone. Indeed, I think you have the causation backward. European countries were able to colonize other countries because they had developed ahead of them. India was ruled by a series of foreign powers for hundreds of years before the British. It’s not like the Mughals simply chose not to develop like Britain did.