7 ms·
I've noticed a variation on this too, except I stuck with it too long. Scheme (once built out, like Racket and others have done) is easily one of the best lang
by neilv 4y ago
I've noticed a variation on this too, except I stuck with it too long. Scheme (once built out, like Racket and others have done) is easily one of the best languages, on technical merits, but I'm not using it lately, while aware of what I'm missing...
Since using Scheme/Racket heavily, I've used three major popular languages, and each has a lot of painful problems, that feel like regressions:
* Major Language X was obviously intended for much simpler needs, but kept getting extended to get closer to what was already known from other languages when it was created, the official docs often seem written as if with no awareness of a reader, and a Web search results are mostly maddening SEO by people who don't seem to understand much about the subject matter.
* Major Language Y has some merits, but a key DSL seems fundamentally wrong in execution, like a kludge that doesn't reflect what was already known decades ago, and they basically just didn't do documentation yet, and I had to do heroics to work around implementation and design flakiness in a key framework and an important library.
* Major Language Z actually shows a lot of positive signs, including cross-pollination in many small details, but at some point there was a breakdown of coherent design for a while, and some poor decisions made, which would be a lot easier to look past were it legacy from much longer ago than it was.
That said, Scheme and Racket also have their technical and community drawbacks. Also, more pragmatically, too often lately I've seen hiring situations where they really-really need some engineering magic done... but they're hung up on filtering resumes for ThisYearsPopularFramework2, and believe that's the most important qualification. So, lately, I also use the currently popular tools, even when it's incarnation #23 of something I've seen before (not done as well #4, #5, #7, and #16), and make it work despite/because I'm painfully aware of the weaknesses.
- jhoechtl 4y agoHm, that may contain Go, Rust and C#?
- neilv 4y agoI suppose it tells us something, when the same criticisms could apply to a lot of language platforms. :) (I was speaking of specific language platforms, but not calling them out by name makes it easier to be candid about the kinds of problems I saw, which was the only point here.)