3 ms·
In a Chinese invasion of Taiwan, it would be very close, and it would not go well. https://americanmilitarynews.com/2022/08/us-loses-half-its-fighter-jets-tons
by kube-system 4y ago
In a Chinese invasion of Taiwan, it would be very close, and it would not go well.
https://americanmilitarynews.com/2022/08/us-loses-half-its-fighter-jets-tons-of-warships-in-china-war-game/ https://americanmilitarynews.com/2022/08/us-loses-half-its-f...
- rainworld 4y agoThis is Americans saying they would lose. They just can’t actually say it. In the scenarios, the success of the ground battle in Taiwan depends almost entirely on Taiwan’s forces. Doesn't sound too discouraging in a world where plucky Ukraine is winning against its big bad neighbour. But, as will become clear to everyone later this year, that is not the world we live in.
- archagon 4y ago> But, as will become clear to everyone later this year, that is not the world we live in. You seem awfully confident. Not sure what analysis you are reading to give you this impression.
- rainworld 4y agoI don’t know how this will end exactly. But the reality of the magnitude of Ukrainian losses, both in terms of men and materiel, will assert itself.
- _8j50 4y agoThat's not what your link says: > Cancian explained that the Chinese missile force is devastating to the U.S. and its allies for as long as their inventory of missiles lasts. > Cancian said submarines and bombers that can launch long-range missiles are “particularly important” for the success of the U.S. side I don't contest that the US would have casualty but the fact that they know this alone tells you it is unlikely for the US to attack head on with fighter jets and carriers. The bases around china and inter-continental targeting capabilities are crucial in disabling their defenses. Both sides would lose millions but the US military industrial comples is unrivaled. It will basically replace important ammunition, missiles,etc... at a decent pace once it is mobilized. It will take 4weeks+ before a ground invasion in the mean time there is no scenario where China's navy won't get wiped out before a ground invasion. So it would be a matter of who can maintain their supply chain the longest without running out of soldiers and airmen. Keep in mind, the US military practices an invasion every generation. The PLA has less battle experience and much like the US and it's voters the CCP must maintain internal support despite their economy getting decimated. On the other hand, Americans will be more squeamish about things like civilian targets which is a major weakness in the short term but the possibility of actual economic recovery if a US friendly regime takes over leadership in China will be a huge advantage in winning the war without going nuclear.
- kube-system 4y agoMy vague one sentence summary is exactly what the article is saying. > I don't contest that the US would have casualty but the fact that they know this alone tells you it is unlikely for the US to attack head on with fighter jets and carriers. The bases around china and inter-continental targeting capabilities are crucial in disabling their defenses. The person quoted in the article claims this is not possible: > Cancian said part of the reason for the heavy U.S. losses is that the U.S. cannot take down China’s defenses without first moving in close and putting themselves at risk.
- _8j50 4y agoThere are bases in Japan and Korea as well as Taiwan. So that guys opinion needs to be backed up with an explanation of why those positions are not close enough short-medium range stealth bombers are a thing?