8 ms·
A new scan to detect and cure the commonest cause of high blood pressure
- dr_dshiv 4y agoI hope they make a lot of money. That’s a pretty fantastic system.
- lol768 4y agoThe work was funded by the NIHR (i.e. the UK taxpayer); the primary purpose is patient benefit to users of the NHS, not profit. If they're making a disproportionate "lot of money", there should be a signed revenue-sharing agreement in place given the benefit of the public funds provided.
- dr_dshiv 4y agoI figure—but what, the doctors that developed this just take home NHS salary? It is going to save the NHS billions. HBP costs over 100 billion $ in the US. https://www.cdc.gov/policy/polaris/healthtopics/highbloodpressure/index.html#:~:text=High%20blood%20pressure%20costs%20the,of%20productivity%20from%20premature%20death https://www.cdc.gov/policy/polaris/healthtopics/highbloodpre....
- vjk800 4y agoCan someone who knows more about the field to comment on whether this is as revolutionary as it sounds?
- Traubenfuchs 4y ago- this only concerns 5 - 10% of all hypertension patients - ~50% of adult Americans have hypertension - scanning all medication-non-responders (= people suffering from "resistant hypertension") and operating on all of them to remove the causative nodules sounds like quite the tall order - doctors won't just suddenly start sending all the resistant hypertension patients to CTs to diagnose this cause, instead they will continue to escalate their patients anti-hypertensive medication, i.e. adding an aldosterone antagonist to the three other maximum dosage blood pressure lowering medications the patient already takes. - this might become an option for people suffering from resistant hypertension that are receiving expensive, excellent state of the art treatment
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoisn't a single CT scan and surgery cheaper than 40 years of medication?
- Traubenfuchs 4y agoThat small question is so complex, it could probably be elucidated in a complete high quality bachelor thesis. Many of those patients will continue to have high blood pressure for other reasons (obesity, fat intake, renal impairment, god knows what else) and will need to continue their medication, maybe they will downgrade (upgrade? (-; ) from treatment resistant hypertension to normal hypertension. A significant amount of the patients receiving surgery will suffer from mild to severe bacterial infections that also need treatment. At the top of my head I would still say yes, it would be cheaper. ALSO and BUT: Please do not expect a treatment that is both cheaper and better for the quality of life of the patient to be chosen by default. Hospitals and doctors don't work that way.
- Rebelgecko 4y agoProbably not. The sticker price of my blood pressure medicine comes out to like $60/yr. The scan alone would probably cost more than 40 years of medication (and the #s are potentially much worse if you consider time value of money and all that)
- golem14 4y agoCost to you, or combined cost for you / insurer ? Honest question.
- mikeyouse 4y agoMost blood pressure medication is dirt cheap, effective pills have been generic for decades now -- you can get a 3-month supply of the largest dose of lisinopril for under $10 cash (no insurance). https://costplusdrugs.com/medications/lisinopril-2_5mg-tablet/ https://costplusdrugs.com/medications/lisinopril-2_5mg-table...
- themantalope 4y agoRadiologist. It’s cool, it’s a nice study. The article definitely over hypes the “common cause of hypertension”. These lesions are rare. Most people with high blood pressure have it because of metabolic disease/chronic stress/lifestyle, and it can be managed with changes to diet exercise and meds. It is true that doing adrenal vein sampling is hard and not always successful. Having a protocol that can non-invasively detect these lesions may save some people a procedure.
- jamesgill 4y agoThanks for this. Metabolic/stress/lifestyle problems were exactly my story. I had hypertension, anxiety, and was prediabetic. Using low carb and intermittent fasting, I lost 91 pounds, was no longer prediabetic, and went completely off bp meds. Anxiety is managed much better (no meds). My doc was amazed.
- vjk800 4y ago> Most people with high blood pressure have it because of metabolic disease/chronic stress/lifestyle, and it can be managed with changes to diet exercise and meds. Do we know this though? If, as the article claims, the lesions were previously hard to detect, I would guess that most people with them never get diagnosed. I have high blood pressure and I've never been examined for those lesions.
- themantalope 4y agoYeah there are other ways to tell if someone has aldosterone driven hypertension through blood work and urine tests. These other tests are to determine if surgery could fix the problem (tumor or unilateral vs bilateral abnormal aldosterone production). Edited for clarity
- selimthegrim 4y agoI wonder if US healthcare with its profusion of CT scanners can drive down long term patient treatment costs faster with their greater installed base.
- SoftTalker 4y agoI don't know about that. I currently need an MRI and the earliest appointment I could get was 4 weeks out, and that's not at the closest facility (they are nearly two months out). Maybe CT scans are faster.
- themantalope 4y agoRadiologist. Depending on the protocol, CT scans usually take anywhere from 5 seconds to 10 minutes (in the longer scans most of that is waiting after contrast injection). MRI studies take a long time to acquire data, usually at least 20 minutes for very short/limited studies. More involved protocols can take hours. Patient throughput is slower.
- yjftsjthsd-h 4y agoHilariously, I think the HN anti-clickbait filter made this title more clickbaity: The original title was "Ten-minute scan enables detection and cure of the commonest cause of high blood pressure", which HN helpfully removed the number from... leading to "Minute scan detects and cures of most common cause of high blood pressure". And a one minute scan would be even more impressive, but that's not what it is...
- LinuxBender 4y agoThey should still have some time to edit the description. If that time is exceeded they could email dang and ask to edit. The filter only happens on submission but not on edit.
- ipqk 4y agoI interpreted it as a minute scan (i.e. very small, of small importance). But it's a CT-scan which very much is not a minute scan.
- hinkley 4y agoI was picturing someone with an electron microscope, scanning the most minute of things... But the rest of the shortened title is straight-up hashbrowns. You are fixing a common problem with a scan? That's not how medicine works.
- dang 4y agoYes, that happens sometimes. I've changed it to clearer language from the first paragraph.
- QuercusMax 4y agoThe current title is also wrong: it's not a CT scan, but rather a PET/CT scan (with the emphasis on the PET, which requires injection with a radiotracer).
- dang 4y agoOk, maybe it's safest to just drop the CT. Thanks!
- VLM 4y ago1 in 20 is "most"? What about the other 19 in 20? I was under the impression that the most common cause was being fat.
- sp332 4y ago"Most common cause", singular.
- joshenders 4y agoWas looking for this comment, thank you.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kashunstva 4y agoThe vast majority of arterial hypertension is “essential hypertension,” meaning no identifiable cause. I assume this is (misleadingly) saying that of the secondary (non-essential) hypertension cases, the condition that this scan detects is the most common.
- CoastalCoder 4y agoInteresting. I thought "idiopathic" was the only medical term for "I don't know why."
- r00fus 4y agoFrom TFA: " The scan found that in two thirds of patients with elevated aldosterone secretion, this is coming from a benign nodule in just one of the adrenal glands, which can then be safely removed." So it seems that 2/3 of the cause of HBP is elevated aldosterone, but 1/20 of cases this can be fixed with a not-so-invasive procedure.
- primeblue 4y ago[dead]
- harveywi 4y agoFor those who may not have access to this treatment, an alternative is to add the following to /etc/hosts: 127.0.0.1 facebook.com 127.0.0.1 www.facebook.com 127.0.0.1 twitter.com 127.0.0.1 www.twitter.com
- akomtu 4y agoLooks like the cure is surgery, and with the sorry state of the US healthcare, that's hardly a solution.
- Traubenfuchs 4y agoI completely agree. Running the numbers in my head that would be up to 10 million patients this surgery would be relevant for in the US.
- jessriedel 4y agoTangent: "Commonest" is listed in the dictionary as an acceptable alternative to "most common", but I can't recall ever hearing it before. According to Ngram the latter is 20 times more common (or commoner, heh) but I would still have expected to remembering hearing it. Is this a UK vs. US thing?
- jessriedel 4y agoJournal article: Wu et al., "11C-metomidate PET CT versus Adrenal Vein Sampling for diagnosing surgically curable primary aldosteronism: prospective test validation, and impact of somatic genotype and ethnicity on outcomes" https://assets.researchsquare.com/files/rs-1179128/v1_covered.pdf?c=1640793911 https://assets.researchsquare.com/files/rs-1179128/v1_covere... Metomidate is a molecule (C_13 H_14 N_2 O_2) that naturally collects in the adrenal glands, and 11C-metomidate is a version where some of the carbon atoms are carbon-11, a radioactive version that will show up on PET-CT scans. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metomidate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metomidate For reference, a PET-CT scan costs $1k-$10k in the US. Not sure how much the radioactive tracer adds.
- pfdietz 4y agoThat tracer has to be made on site, since 11C has a halflife of 20 minutes. So there has to be a particle accelerator to make the 11C and a chemistry lab to quickly get the 11C into the drug.
- yencabulator 4y agoFun video of one such site: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eMTZvA8iFgI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eMTZvA8iFgI
- 1024core 4y agoNature article: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-022-02114-5 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-022-02114-5
- fareed79 4y agoThis is not a CT but a PET scan, it records passive radiation from a molecule injected into the body, and therefore a 10 min long scan. Then it is based on radioactive carbon (C-11), which is pretty uncommon and needs quick use after production, so not every PET(CT) can do that, it needs be in the vicinity of a production facility (i.e. close to a university/research hospital). This is the sense of the last sentence: it needs a replacement the carbon with another radioactive isotope (fluor for instance) to be doable at every PET/CT place. I don't blame the title here, because the article itself is very strangely written, it says as well "CT scan" but this is no "CT scan", this is a PET scan.
- DougMerritt 4y agoRight, but it's a weird terminology subject, because CT is just short for "Computerized Tomography", with the initial implied "X-ray" part being a convention -- but all of these 3D scan techniques are variant kinds of Tomography, with X-ray CT/CAT scans being the original kind. Your comments about C-11 are well-taken and an important caveat.
- kris_wayton 4y agoThat's interesting, thanks for sharing. I was aware of the more common "radioactive glucose" PET scan that helps pinpoint cancer...where fast reproducing cells consume glucose. Didn't know there were adjacent types of PET scans.
- aantix 4y agoI had my left adrenal gland taken out in September. TL;DR - If you know someone that takes a lot of blood pressure medications and has for many years, have them see an endocrinologist and get them screened for hyperaldosteronism ( aka Conn's syndrome ). Kind of a crazy story. I've had blood pressure (BP) issues since my senior year of high school. 1996. Started taking my first medication then. Since then, I've had one hospital stay, 3 ER visits, yearly checkups, all because my blood pressure is really hard to control. I've seen 3 cardiologists and two nephrologists over these past 25 years to help me manage my BP. I figured the high BP was because I was fat. I think my highest bp reading ever was 210/130. I’d commonly see 170/110. Not good. These past couple of years, my blood pressure had gotten and stayed really, really high. To the point where I was waking up with headaches. I even had a few headaches where I thought I was going to have a stroke. Fast forward to my most recent blood pressure related ER visit ( in March ) - the cardiologist raises the dose on yet another medication. I'm like "WTF is going here? This is craziness. I can’t keep taking all of these medications.” Really frustrated, I do my own research. I stumble upon a couple of studies citing Pheochromocytomas, a tumor on the adrenal that secretes excessive hormones which causes an elevation in blood pressure. Then I read a Washington Post article talking about a guy on “a bucketload of blood pressure medications” that actually ends up having a tumor on his adrenal gland. The general condition is called Hyperaldosteronism. This is the condition discussed in the parent article. It's pretty rare - like 1/1000. You basically have an adrenal glad that secretes too much Aldosterone which drives the bodily retention of salt and water. Which in turn, chronically elevates blood pressure while abnormally dumping potassium. At my next cardiologist appt, the Dr. basically tells me "I have nothing else for you". He wanted to increase my four blood pressure medications, again. He thought I should go back to see the nephrologist. Given my research, I asked him for a referral to the endocrinologist. For which he annoyingly shrugs, "sure, why not. But they're usually booked way out." I get a call from the endocrinologist the following Monday. I get in right away. I mention Hyperaldosteronism. Tell them my long history with resistant hypertension. They totally agree. They setup an appointment for a blood screening. Sure enough, the tests come back with really elevated levels of aldosterone, really low levels of renin, and really low potassium levels. All signatures of hyperaldosteronism. They then do an AVS, a vascular sampling of the blood coming out of each adrenal. It showed overwhelmingly my left adrenal produces high volumes of aldosterone with low levels of renin. The left adrenal’s Aldosterone/renin ratio demonstrated that it was the dominant one. Which is actually good, because then I could have my left adrenal taken out, and still live very normally with the right adrenal taking over. So that’s how my surgery came about. My overactive adrenal has probably been a huge contributor of my elevated blood pressure, for many, many years. The pathology report came back and they did find a nodule in my left adrenal gland, that was not visible from the initial CT scan. https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/2022/04/23/high-blood-pressure-medical-mystery/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/2022/04/23/high-blood-... P.S. The Facebook group for Conn's Syndrome is a wealth of a knowledge and has a few really amazing members that can guide you on how to navigate getting tested (a lot of doctor's aren't necessarily aware of the condition). https://www.facebook.com/groups/652067311558303 https://www.facebook.com/groups/652067311558303
- ManuelKiessling 4y agoI really hope that stuff like “the commonest” doesn’t become one of the most common mistakes in HN headlines…
- skyyler 4y agoI'm confused, do you have issue with the word "commonest"? The American Heritage dictionary gives the positive, comparative, and superlative forms as common, commoner, and commonest. What's the mistake?
- ManuelKiessling 4y agoI can only bring German school-level English to the table, but my instincts told me that someone played loose with what should be “the most common”.
- skyyler 4y agoYour instincts are incorrect, "commonest" is a valid word and it's being used correctly in the title of this article. I hope this mistake of correcting things that aren't mistakes doesn't become one of the most common mistakes in HN comments...
- ManuelKiessling 4y agoI don’t understand your need to be rude after learning that someone is not a native speaker.
- skyyler 4y agoIf you aren't a native speaker why did you try to correct the writer of the article? You're allowed to be rude but I am not? I don't want this to be a flame war, I want you to actually reflect on why you think you're allowed to be rude but I am not.
- chmaynard 4y agoThis headline goes beyond clickbait and into the realm of pure fantasy. Maybe the author asked ChatGPT to write it.
- 8bitsrule 4y agoReminds me of the scene in StarTrek #4 where McCoy sez something like 'Fundascopic examination is unrevealing in these cases.' A scan that cures is therefore 'the future'.