2 ms·
I always thought the "bystander effect" was a load of propaganda. Even though I'm happy that airplanes/restaurants/offices are now free of smoke. I'm old enoug
by WalterBright 4y ago
I always thought the "bystander effect" was a load of propaganda.
Even though I'm happy that airplanes/restaurants/offices are now free of smoke. I'm old enough to remember when every building stank of stale smoke.
- kleiba 4y agoInteresting. What made you think that? I was under the impression that passive smoking was pretty well studied.
- WalterBright 4y agoFor one thing, the concentration has to be a thousand times less. For another, you're just not around it that much. For a third, how can one reliably measure the exposure? Far too many variables.
- 5e92cb50239222b 4y agoPM2.5 concentrations tend to be very high around smokers. I live next to one, and even though we're separated by a door and he smokes in his own apartment, the smoking frequently pushes air in my apartment above 200 µg/m³. (I have 3 years of data to prove it.) Since the outside air is typically even more dangerous here, I can't simply open a window and have to use air filters to combat this. https://0x0.st/s/6LnsVC92Wy4es4tLN9iF5w/ohKp.png https://0x0.st/s/6LnsVC92Wy4es4tLN9iF5w/ohKp.png
- WalterBright 4y agoSo the outside air is more dangerous than second hand smoke?
- davidgay 4y ago> I always thought the "bystander effect" was a load of propaganda. I can personally confirm that standing by smokers / staying in smokers' houses is quite good for triggering asthma. So I suggest you tampen down your propaganda claims.
- LargoLasskhyfv 4y agoFunny you're mentioning that. I've got a relative who counters onset of asthma by smoking, though with very light tobacco and long, thin filters, and on demand only. I do similar things after eating, because I seem to have varying intolerances against the foods which are common now. Making my nose run, sometimes going to the eyes, giving me tears, over to coughing, and in more rare cases even constricting my throat. All that is going away instantly after a few draws of a selfmade small cigarette with long thin filter, exhaling the smoke through the nose. Furthermore I don't wan't to lose the ability to smoke light weed from time to time, without coughing and spitting fits :-)
- seanhunter 4y agohttps://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26440943/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26440943/ seems a good place to start in correcting your misconception here. Conclusions: Our overview of systematic reviews of observational epidemiological evidence suggests that passive smoking is significantly associated with an increasing risk of many diseases or health problems, especially diseases in children and cancers. edit: removed some unnecessary sarcasm
- mrguyorama 4y agoThen you have a poorly configured bullshit detector. Second hand smoke was studied in depth, and plenty of children have ended up with health problems from their parent's smoking. It is only a "controversial" fact among people who refuse to give up smoking for the benefit of their families.
- WalterBright 4y ago> only I've never smoked, and neither has anyone in my family except my mom who quit before I was born. I've never smoked marijuana, either, though I voted to legalize it. I.e. I have no personal agenda with either.