3 ms·
Interesting to see how anthropomorphic the language about the black hole is, in the first few para's - "...gatherers, not hunters. They lie in wait...sloppily
by bell-cot 4y ago
Interesting to see how anthropomorphic the language about the black hole is, in the first few para's - "...gatherers, not hunters. They lie in wait...sloppily devours...belching...gobbled...".
Vs. the reality is that the the whole process is just as deterministic and conscious-free as water flowing downhill. And after para 3, the article's tone and language change to straight & sober science.
- jxf 4y agoWe remember facts better when they are in story form. For example, suppose I ask 100 people to memorize a list of fifty words, and then I ask you which word was a food item. Many people find this challenging. If I change the experiment so that I tell a story using all fifty words, and then ask you "what did the grandmother have for breakfast?", you're much more likely to do better.
- bell-cot 4y ago> We remember facts better when they are in story form... True, but orthogonal to my point. Outside of myth, fantasy novels, and children's stories, most writing about destructive natural phenomena does not anthropomorphize Mount St. Helens as it erupted, the asteroid which hit the Moon to create Tycho Crater, the solar flare which caused the Carrington Event, etc.
- jxf 4y agoI think you may just not be looking closely enough. Using your first example, here are things Mt. St. Helens is described as doing in just one contemporaneous article: - roaring - belching - "[knocked down] millions of trees [...] like a giant playing pick-up sticks" - slumbering - menacing That all sounds very anthropomorphic to me. [0] https://content.time.com/time/subscriber/printout/0,8816,924152,00.html https://content.time.com/time/subscriber/printout/0,8816,924...
- bell-cot 4y agoPoint, though my recollection (not gonna review 1,001 old articles on the eruption, to do stats) is that the anthropomorphic descriptions tended to be in "I was too damn close, and it was very scary" accounts. I won't look down at anthropomorphism in that case - it's likely a good reflection of the author's (or his source's) very human experience and emotional reactions to danger.
- anigbrowl 4y agoTrue, but inaccurate stories create false memories. This is just bad writing.
- Wowfunhappy 4y ago> Vs. the reality is that the the whole process is just as deterministic and conscious-free as water flowing downhill. And you think you're so different? Do you have free will? Are you sure you're not just following a deterministic process?
- Ensorceled 4y agoAre you really saying that black holes ARE as deterministic as humans or even wolves?
- bell-cot 4y agoWhich sort of "free will"? If the boring sort, that wanna-be alphas argue endlessly about in Philosophy 507, then "no". If the sort that real people need to have a sense of, to cope with life in the real world, then "yes". Given ~40 bytes of data about a black hole, its behavior can be predicted, exactly enough for ~all real-world purposes, and for millions of years into the future, by a pretty simple program running on a (say) old Z80 CPU. You can drop a billion empty beer cans into it, one by one, and if you match their trajectories then the outcomes will be ~identical. Humans, or even my sister's stupid pet dog, are nothing remotely resembling that predictable and deterministic.
- dotancohen 4y agoI really like the idea of quantifying how deterministic a system is by the amount of data need to accurately (for reasonable values of accuracy) predict it's behavior. Objectional tests are terrific for bringing philosophers back into the realm of reason.
- bell-cot 4y agosed -I 's/are terrific for bringing philosophers back into/are a reasonable tactic for attempting to drag screaming, kicking, & biting philosophers back into/'
- mcronce 4y ago> the reality is that the the whole process is just as deterministic and conscious-free as water flowing downhill This isn't just an analogy, either...if the material happens to be water, it's _literally_ flowing downhill if it's falling into a black hole.