3 ms·
Question. As a non American, I wonder what brings US to a (relatively) extreme position on Health. Technicalities aside, most places consider health as part of
by netcan 18y ago
Question.
As a non American, I wonder what brings US to a (relatively) extreme position on Health. Technicalities aside, most places consider health as part of the suite of public responsibilities.
Does a significant portion of the opposition to the public assuming responsibility for health also oppose the public assuming responsibility for education? I ask because it seems a close parallel.
- yummyfajitas 18y agoThe parallel is pretty weak. Publicly funded education is for children, while publicly funded health care would be delivered to adults. We also consider preventing sex with children to be a legitimate function of the government, while preventing sex with adults is a matter of personal privacy.
- netcan 18y agoYou think the reason that it's: healthcare no & education yes, is that education concerns children? There are many aspects of children's wellbeing that the public does not concern itself with including to an extent child health. BTW, the paedophilia laws are not really analogous. Sex with children is prohibited because it is considered rape. A child is considered unable to consent so it is non consensual. Non consensual sex is prohibited with adults too.
- yummyfajitas 18y agoChildrens health is a major responsibility of government. If a parent fails to keep their child healthy, this is child neglect, and the government steps in (often removing the child from the care of his/her parents). If a parent cannot afford medical care for their children, the government will pay. There may be administrative differences between specific government programs in education and health care, but there is little public opposition to either one.
- netcan 18y agoThere is a big difference. Education is seen as a right in The States. Everyone gets to (has to) go to school.
- mattmaroon 18y agoWe believe that health care is not a right but a privilege. The Constitution does not ensure the right to "life, liberty, the pursuit of happiness, and $10 copays." Moreover, we believe that almost everything the government does, it does poorly. Schools would be a great case in point.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- njharman 18y agoHealthcare falls under "life". Oh and quit talking for all Americans.
- mattmaroon 18y agoHumans lived for at least 250,000 years without HMOs. And I'm talking for Americans who are against public health care, which was who the question was addressed to.
- netcan 18y agoThat's right, it was addressed to you.
- netcan 18y agoI actually meant that as a genuine question without meaning to discuss it but.. We believe that almost everything the government does, it does poorly There is definitely some truth in that in a general sense. But it seems to me that it is really a technical side issue in this particular case. The efficiency costs/gains are debatable. Even if you think you see an answer, it's marginal. It largely depends on what you consider the 'output' of a healthcare system. If you take traditional public health indicators such as life expectancy at birth, rates of various avoidable deaths & such, as the output of healthcare systems, private health systems are generally 'less efficient.' What I mean to suggest with the above line is that a lot of practical pieces of general world views & rules of thumb (Government should not provide services because it is inefficient) are taken to specific contexts regardless of their validity in these cases. That's why I always find it very hard to believe that anti public health arguments are truly decided on technical grounds. This is a moral not a technical issue. We believe that health care is not a right but a privilege. I'm not sure if you were being sarcastic. But it does seem closer to the point. In other words, I have no duty to ensure you have healthcare. I have a duty to ensure you are not murdered, but not that you don't die from diabetes. If you take what seems to be a current debate in US politics, it seems very fundamental & moral rather then technical: Assume the responsibility or try to enable more healthcare without assuming the responsibility. I think most would probably agree that regardless of the tax regime & regardless of price of medical care (within possible levels), some people will be left without. Many people in fact. Short of assuming responsibility for health, you are debating ways of getting the number of uninsured from 17% to 12% or 10% or some moral equivalent. Some people will be left out. But that's ok because they chose that or made a dumb mistake or had a fighting chance.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoIn general, the idea of "public responsibilities" is controversial. The country was founded so that the government would do the minimal amount necessary to insure the maximum amount of freedom. Freedoms don't mean anything unless they involve the ability to fail. As an example, any American can build their own airplane and attempt to fly it (in the right areas, such as a desert). Freedom to form a startup and make a lot of money is the same as freedom to form a startup and fail. So governmental power is used to insure freedoms. Traditionally, civic organizations are used to fulfill "public responsibilities" We have groups dedicated to local infrastructure improvement, fostering leadership skills in children, making sure people have eye care, giving healthcare to the poor -- the list goes on and on. This is changing as more and more politicians and voters want the government to do the good things that civic organizations used to do. But we still have a long way to go to the point where we view government as the tool to handle all of our moral civic duties for us. There is a strong feeling that centralized governmental planning leads to waste, corruption, inefficiencies and the politicization of service delivery. Education, I was told, was institutionalized after WWI as a way to make sure that soldiers had basic literacy and math skills. So this movement was a part of national defense, not some collective civic duty. (I understand education has a much more storied background. I abbreviate here)
- netcan 18y ago2 more questions: * Are there Americans that feel education should not be a public service? * Are you saying that healthcare is seen as a public responsibility but not one that needs to be delivered by 'Government?'
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoBy use of the phrase "public service" I think your question misses the point. Education was considered a national necessity as part of our ability to fight wars (once again, as I was told, it gets more complicated) City governments pick up the trash as a service. Services are optional, nice-to-have things. Education was deemed a requirement, and local schools were left to handle that in any way they wanted (until relatively recently) There is a large section of the population which believes that education is being done so poorly as to need re-vamping completely -- getting back to the days where the goals were set but the methods were left open to each school. I'm one of these people. I'm all for the national goal of education as being required for war-fighting and citizenship. The current system, however, looks to have quite a few flaws. I'm all for iterating and re-factoring. Healthcare, or taking care of the sick, has traditionally been seen as a church-related activity in the States. This began to change in the 1930s when FDR enacted legislation to help people in their retirement (although the initial age of benefits was also the average death age, so on average nobody saw these benefits unless they lived longer than most) You have to remember that in the States, multiple religions and cultures each took care of things like healthcare locally with hundreds of different solutions. There are hundreds of charity hospitals, for instance. In that manner, healthcare is considered a personal moral responsibility, not a public repsonsibility. Public responsibilities are those I owe the state -- voting, armed service, jury duty, etc. Moral responsibilities are those I owe a particular person based on my moral compass -- gifts to the homeless, charities (the U.S. leads the world in charities), etc. The U.S. is beginning to believe that all of these moral responsibilities must/should be delivered by government. That takes away any personal involvement or critical thinking of mine and lets the government simply "write the check" for whatever moral ills we all agree on. I'm against this and view it as a step backwards -- replacing a distributed, intelligent, self-optimizing system with a rigid centralized one. But this is clearly the direction we've been going over the last 70 years and I would expect it to continue.
- walterk 18y agoI compare public responsibility for health to public responsibility for fire control. Fires can wreak havoc upon many beyond the fire's point of origin. It's also unprofitable to run a fire department, so given the public benefit, the public foots the bill for keeping a fire department. Health care isn't the same in that it can be a very profitable business, but because profits are tied to consumption of goods (e.g., medicine) and services (e.g., operations), the industry has incentives to promote overconsumption of both. Meanwhile, the health insurance industry has incentives to deny coverage as much as possible in the name of profit. You might think this would cause the health care industry to operate efficiently, but health care is complex and not easily overseen, and even if the health care industry ran efficiently, the health insurance industry would still have incentives to deny coverage past the efficient rate. But the effects of letting people who genuinely need treatment go untreated are nevertheless much like fires. Not only does it stand an excellent chance of reducing their productivity and overall employment prospects, the consequences it can have for a family can likewise be disastrous. That doesn't do them any good and it certainly doesn't do our economy any good. So while the health industries might be quite profitable, the net benefit to society is considerably less than if the profit incentives were properly aligned to maximize health instead of consumption and lack of coverage. But, you know, some folks just have to be sacrificed on the altar of the completely free market, in the name of their own good.
- mattmaroon 18y agoSomebody else's sickness has no effect on me in most cases. And in the ones in which it does, the CDC is there to help. Nobody would suggest that the government doesn't play an important role in protecting against epidemics, which is most analogous to your fire metaphor. It's not up to the public to protect people from all of the bad things that can befall them. It's up to the public to ensure that people are not impeded when trying to help themselves. Thus even most of us who are against public health care are in favor of reforms. Tort reforms, ending the perverse incentives. Interestingly, most of our health problems in the U.S. seem to be due to political pressure caused by lobbying. Read In Defense of Food for a good review as to why our diet has shifted to where it is, and why it's almost certainly the problem. It illustrates that government cannot be counted on to ensure public health.