2 ms·
‘This song sucks’: Nick Cave responds to ChatGPT song in style of Nick Cave
- ggm 4y agoI totally agree with Cave here. This application of the technology is a bad, bad idea, it sucks the humanity out of creative writing, and it's really not helping artists to do this. Authors have been writing about the corrosive effect of fan-fic for a long time. Nothing destroys the creative goodwill of an artist like being fed ideas by adoring Fans. Neil Gaiman (I believe) has said he begs fans not to suggest things to him: he can't use them, the story potential is destroyed the minute they do. Cave is worth reading. Like David Byrne he has interesting takes on how music is made, what it is to be creative in this space, and bare your emotions to the world.
- blondin 4y agonot disagreeing with you. but way things are going, this line of argument will lose in the end. we, people, have chosen that consuming entertainment is more important than the work. we have chosen the path of quantity over quality. netflix wants to produce a movie every week. let's that sink in for a moment.
- ggm 4y agoBollywood sustained that rate of production for decades. As did national TV channels worldwide, at a soaps level. But to your underlying point, I am also not optimistic. I think the hit machine and "in the style of" is like deepfakes in the adult industry. The market will exist, and its the lowest cost barrier there is. I'd hate to be depending on IPR law for my income. Connection with the fans, the live experience, merch, has been the real income after A&R for decades, but its a hard slog. And random stupid lives in getting too close to fans. Entertainment is the industry which predates itself. If the A&R and residuals model didn't suck "profit" out of the machine so the payment to artist on 'remaining profits' wasn't zero, it would be nicer for everyone but then.. who pays for the pile of coke in the executive toilet suite?
- robga 4y agoNick Cave’s direct response is verbatim on the original generated text page [0]. It’s worth a read. Stronger: read that, not the linked guardian article. He’s a fabulous wielder of words. Placed next to the generated text, his rebuttal lays bare the beige blandness of chatgpt output. What’s truly threatened are authors of articles like the linked guardian one. That’s the irony of it. These cut, paste, and bookend articles that hacks churn out over coffee at the start of the work day. They dilute rather than focus the conversation. That’s what chatgpt can replicate with aplomb. Not that we’ll be the better for it since there are all too many of them already. I hope Nick works on a song about the “algorithmic awe”, the “replication as travesty”, the “grotesque mockery” that generative text supports. Its superficial output threatens the visible breakthrough of genuine new human creative talent above the inevitable impending noise of vanilla generated music and lyrics. [0] https://www.theredhandfiles.com/chat-gpt-what-do-you-think/ https://www.theredhandfiles.com/chat-gpt-what-do-you-think/