4 ms·
I think many of the fundamentals are completely wrong. A basic question is if you trust more in a zillion of unknown nodes were really few unknown ones run and
by wslh 4y ago
I think many of the fundamentals are completely wrong.
A basic question is if you trust more in a zillion of unknown nodes were really few unknown ones run and decide on the protocol or will you trust more a few well known actors who at the end will be accountable by a legal system, assuming it is a good one. For example, was a cryptocurrency like Libra from FB where nodes were known actors less secure than a stable coin run by just one shady actor?
If a few Bitcoin miners want to stop the show they can. Also Bitcoin is not trustless in the sense there are very few people who can modify or incorporate new features to the node. The lie is in the trustless word as if it would be run by a God.
The spirit of a P2P financial infrastructure is fine, the question is if this one is the solution.
BTW, I work in the field. I think I will never see the number of frauds and shady people I found in this space. I talked with many of the people appearing in the news now, and more will appear. If you ask me a number of things that I find interesting about the field, one is the security analysis of code. There are many interesting things to learn in this space that can be extrapolated. Another is cryptography and fault tolerance areas that are moving forward thanks all of this, a third one is that I expect DeFi could bring more new financial ideas to play that frauds.
- pfraze 4y agoI've found that question about bitcoin protocol governance rather interesting, wrote a bit about it here: https://paulfrazee.medium.com/the-rules-to-make-the-rules-be0c3b9d92b6 https://paulfrazee.medium.com/the-rules-to-make-the-rules-be... In summary, after a fair bit of research-from-home and talking to a couple of people deeply in the bitcoin space, I'm still not sure who really holds the reigns.
- saurik 4y ago> were really few unknown ones run and decide on the protocol That's not how Bitcoin works: you and the party you are giving money to decide the protocol, not the miners. If these unknown miners are doing something different than what your clients allow then those miners aren't part of the same network as you.
- bcrl 4y agoThe protocol for interacting with an exchange to trade for fiat isn't decided by the protocol. You just don't get to find out if you've been scammed by trusting your exchange to do what it said it did until it's too late. Trust is still required, but there's no governance to back it up.
- wslh 4y agoyou and your party decide on a protocol that should be the same as the protocol run for the other nodes. I am not talking here about malicious attacks over the protocol but about how the good protocol behave. That decision is in the core developers who has the power to modify the protocol but not on you. if you came up with a good idea to enhance Bitcoin that idea will not be implemented by merit.