5 ms·
> His English is very good, but the concept of inalienable rights, freedom of speech, and freedom to yell at our politicians .. he was intellectually incapable
by rayiner 4y ago
> His English is very good, but the concept of inalienable rights, freedom of speech, and freedom to yell at our politicians .. he was intellectually incapable of understanding this, his society had brainwashed him so thoroughly.
I don’t think that’s a charitable or logical framing of his point of view. Unless you’re religious—which the American framers were—“inalienable rights” are an illogical concept. In the state of nature, you are free to say whatever you want, and the people around you are free to beat you to death for it. It’s only when you have a civilized society that the concept of rights makes sense. Roughly speaking “rights” are simply rules society agrees upon for how individuals relate to each other (e.g. private property) or how society as a whole relates to the individual (e.g. free speech). There’s nothing inherent about any arbitrarily selected set of “rights.”
- thinking4real 4y agoIt’s hilarious watching all the posters tell OP he’s mistaken about a life experience he had. Hubris abound.
- pessimizer 4y ago> It’s hilarious watching all the posters tell OP he’s mistaken about a life experience he had. This is a pretty bullshit reading of the comment you replied to, which was about the nature of "rights" as a social agreement rather than something natural.
- JumpCrisscross 4y agoTo add to your comment, nobody says OP’s experience is incorrect. Instead, the comment thinking4real takes reflexive offence to seeks to explain it, not demean it.
- andrewflnr 4y agoSaid comment seized on one phrase, jumped to a conclusion about what the top-level's friend's actual misunderstanding was, and chastized them for not agreeing with their guess. We don't know if the top-level commenter's judgment is correct, but the rest of us certainly don't have enough evidence to be so confident they're wrong.
- comte7092 4y agoHow is calling someone “brainwashed” a life experience? People are allowed to have different values and opinions. Hubris is believing western morality is self evidently superior to everything else that exists.
- WeylandYutani 4y agoYou will get a lot of hate for this but I must admit: What made Western Europe diverge from places like Russia or Saudi Arabia? Individuality seems to have been invented and embraced by European and American intelligentsia.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> What made Western Europe diverge from places like Russia or Saudi Arabia? The Black Death increased labour’s bargaining power right before the Industrial Revolution. It’s a lucky set of quirks that gave Enlightenment-era ideas fertile soil to land on.
- LAC-Tech 4y agoThe end of the Black Death occurred over 400 years before the start of the Industrial Revolution.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> end of the Black Death occurred over 400 years before the start of the Industrial Revolution “Right before” was hyperbole. The population, and in particular, labor effects, were nevertheless persistent. Western labor was anomalously expensive.
- LAC-Tech 4y agoWhy would you double down at this point? Just admit you were completely wrong and move on. It's fine, I'm wrong a lot too.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> Why would you double down at this point? Because the thesis holds [1][2]. It’s far from a controversial theory in medieval and developmental economics. [1] https://books.google.com/books?hl=en&lr=&id=EUoCBAAAQBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PP6&dq=info:-XifWcNWh3UJ:scholar.google.com/&ots=panZxP_PcY&sig=oxCWxg56Xr3moAGnfHLlXnnD2x4#v=onepage&q&f=false https://books.google.com/books?hl=en&lr=&id=EUoCBAAAQBAJ&oi=... [2] https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C51&q=Black+Death+labor&btnG=#d=gs_qabs&t=1673917270805&u=%23p%3DVm-8EOtyoK0J https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C51&q=Bla...
- FreakLegion 4y ago> Unless you’re religious...“inalienable rights” are an illogical concept. That's an odd claim to make so casually. This is something people can and have argued about for thousands of years, in both directions. One direction is: How can we have values in a world without god(s)? (See: Epicureanism, Kantian ethics, or any other system of secular morality). But the other, equally fair direction is: How can we have values in a world with god(s)? (See: The Euthyphro dilemma and broader problem of evil, the Epicurean paradox, or more recent historical and anthropological analyses of how religions and their institutions are formed and operate.) I suppose you can play bad-faith semantic games with "inalienable", "right", or "inherent" as words here, but the long and short of it is that this isn't a settled issue. There are good arguments not only that religion is not needed as a foundation for rights, but that religion has not (historically) and cannot (philosophically) provide this foundation.
- rayiner 4y agoI didn’t say “God” I said “religion.” “Secular” morality invariably reduces to a system of moral assertions that must be believed but cannot be empirically observed or proven true. To me, that’s just another way of saying “religion.” For example, what’s Kantian ethics? > It states that an action can only be moral if (i) it is motivated by a sense of duty and (ii) its maxim may be rationally willed a universal, objective law. If I autopsy a dead body, am I going to find any evidence of those things in there? Can you empirically prove the categorical imperative? Moreover, “secular morality” in practice is typically just the moral philosophy of the dominant religion with the supernatural elements removed. My dad isn’t a believer, but thinks choosing not to have children is immoral. Why? Maybe it’s because his parents were devout Muslims and having children is an important obligation in Islam. Similarly, it’s amusing to observe how many professed atheists really just believe in the Christian social gospel (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_Gospel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_Gospel) without Jesus. I’m not saying that’s bad. But you have to understand how deeply intertwined even seemingly secular western thought is with Christianity, and doesn’t easily translate to other parts of the world.
- FreakLegion 4y ago