2 ms·
> people don't have the means to keep themselves healthy. Isn't that true only for US. Is employment also dysfunctionally tied to health insurance as it is in
by rdtsc 15y ago
> people don't have the means to keep themselves healthy.
Isn't that true only for US. Is employment also dysfunctionally tied to health insurance as it is in US?
> What is the end result of growth that makes societies "better"?
It depends who you ask. If you ask owners of large corporations they will look as GDP for a metric of how great a country is going. Doesn't matter if life expectancy is terrible, infant mortality, crime and corruption are high, no middle class, people living in shanty towns as long as GDP is booming the country is considered a success.
If you ask people what is makes a country good, they wouldn't care much about GDP, they would point to healthcare, crime, lack of corruption.
Unfortunately the news and the reports you get in the traditional media don't talk about that. All those analysts,"experts" and economists only care about the metric that large corporation care about. How many time have you seen on the news about "the average rate of depression in Argentina has gone up?". Not much right. But you might hear about how GDP is suffering.
- philwelch 15y ago>> people don't have the means to keep themselves healthy. > Isn't that true only for US. Is employment also dysfunctionally tied to health insurance as it is in US? Diet, stress, mood, motivation, and physical activity all have impacts on health, and all are affected by employment status. Doctors and medications, while undoubtedly important, aren't the whole picture. Most people are healthier without doctors but with a good diet, a decent amount of physical exercise, and a motivated, happy life than they would be with doctors but without all the other things.
- rdtsc 15y agoBut also once someone loses their job, diet, stress, mood & motivation would go down the hill. So the chance of getting sick and needing a doctor would go up, which, interestingly enough is when Americans get denied access to health care. They eventually end up in emergency care and then declare bankruptcy because of the cost (therefore me using the "dysfunctional" label for it). But the point was that it is hard to compare the two countries simply on unemployment just because more ties into it. Being unemployed in Japan and breaking a leg is not as terrible as being unemployed in US an breaking a leg. Does it mean Americans are more likely to be stuck working in shitty jobs, afraid to quit and move because they don't want to expose their families to the risk of having no insurance? I don't know. I suspect it plays a role.
- philwelch 15y agoI'm just saying that it's one of many factors, and I'm skeptical about overstating its importance because topical political issues are almost always overstated in importance. If we didn't spend a good chunk of the last four years, as a country, angrily arguing about socialized medicine, then socialized medicine would likely not be the first thing to pop in your mind as the most important factor. It's probably just as important that Japanese people eat a healthier diet and are less alienated from their families than Americans, but I wouldn't even claim any certainty there.
- rdtsc 15y agoNot for me. Medicine has been in my mind ever since I made the mistake of going to the emergency room with a terrible cold when I was here as a student. I ended up paying $400 for 1 pill of codeine, waiting 2 hours and be seen by some intern. $400 in 1995 for a student who makes $6.50 in a university library part time -- is fucked up. I don't care how it is justified and explained. And that is just my experience. There are a lot worse. So I would have been railing about it anyway whether we had the debate or now. I have been mentioning that for years.
- philwelch 15y agoThe fact that you personally had that kind of experience makes it even more likely that you're overstating the effect of the US health care system.