6 ms·
I feel the covid fearmongering by governments, medical companies, medical authorities, and the media has made public discourse in general (let alone specificall
by Dalewyn 4y ago
I feel the covid fearmongering by governments, medical companies, medical authorities, and the media has made public discourse in general (let alone specifically medical) even more prohibitive.
Today, we aren't supposed to question or otherwise so much as discuss something if it goes against or strays from any established narratives. At one point, so much as uttering the word "corona" could get you silenced by the powers-that-be regardless of the context.
This is all ridiculous because the foundation of science (protip: medicine is a science) is to always remain skeptical and engage in rich discourse. Blind trust in science is no different from worshipping a religion or cult.
We are the Galileo against the Church's Geocentric Model, but far more precarious and farther gone.
- pjc50 4y agoRunning about 6.7 million dead so far, so there's little tolerance for fantasists. https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/ https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/
- bluescrn 4y agoFewer than 1 in 1000, mostly elderly, on a planet of almost 8 billion. Obviously not good, but it's not apocalyptic either. (Not bad enough to justify writing off 'freedom' as an awful selfish far-right concept that should be purged from society entirely?)
- onion2k 4y agoObviously not good, but it's not apocalyptic either. That's the death count with the measures put in place. If C-19 hadn't been taken as seriously as it was then you might be adding a zero to that death count. Maybe two.
- iso1631 4y ago[flagged]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bigbillheck 4y ago> However unlike in 1920 the majority were not economically active. I really hope this is the most ghoulish thing I read all week, because I don't want to imagine the alternative.
- onion2k 4y agoThis is a fascinating thought experiment - how well do you think people would cope if their government just decided that half of everyone over 60 dying is an acceptable loss? What would the fallout from the collective trauma be? How disastrous would the impact on the sudden collapse of most pension funds as most of the capital is withdrawn be? As someone who's interested in systems thinking and the impact of feedback loops in large scale systems, I can't even begin to fathom how badly society would be damaged if this had actually happened.
- eropple 4y agoThis is actively ghastly chin-stroking under the guise of intellectualism and should have no place here.
- pjc50 4y ago9/11 killed fewer than 1 in one million of the world population and look at the response to that. Including impacts to freedom. Maybe that was the event that completely broke everybody's sense of proportion. 100ml liquid bottle? Can't take it on a plane. Airborne pathogen? Sure, why not, bring it aboard.
- wuiheerfoj 4y agoPoliticians felt they had to (or seized the opportunity to?) enact a disproportionate response to 9/11 because it’s (politically ) better to fail by going too far than not going far enough. I suspect the same is true of covid, but how do we break the cycle? Is it innate in politics?
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoSame way we break any cycle. We vilify those who peddle it and shun those who support them.
- saiya-jin 4y agoWhich freedoms are you missing currently? This obviously depends on location, but apart from few closed venues (which was good decision during height of pandemic) and few months of limited cross border travel (choice of every state) no freedoms were curtailed here in Switzerland, and absolutely 0 are curtailed now. Same applies for whole EU AFAIK. Unless you mean obvious a-holes that back then refused to put on masks in shops and public transport and made it a political issue, which it was not, simply a security one. It was wonderful to see all those slightly weird quiet types suddenly go full blown nuts and dive head first into various redneck conspiracy theories, if they weren't drowning in them before. Reasonable mankind lost those for good probably, but they were never truly part of it so at least now we see situation more clearly and can manage expectations more realistically.
- iso1631 4y agoSwitzerland closed schools, hardly "a few" venues, it was pretty much every venue. They banned gatherings of more htan 5 people, unless it was financially beneficial (say people building something for money)
- andrepd 4y ago>Not bad enough to justify writing off 'freedom' as an awful selfish far-right concept that should be purged from society entirely Why the ridiculous straw man?
- bananapear 4y agoAnd we do them a disservice if we fail to examine what went wrong
- roenxi 4y agoI estimate 8 billion people [0] are going to die of something; if we shut the economy down every time 7 million people die there will be nothing left. Up until COVID there was a pretty good social contract going on where we'd all promised never to do the things that the authorities then went and did. 7 million deaths doesn't justify that, WWII alone was 70-80 million people lost trying to promote the opposite of the COVID response. Liberty is important. And might turn out to be a better policy depending on how bad the shock of the COVID response turns out to be (see, for example, the article). [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_population https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_population
- danabrams 4y agoDuring WWII, in the place least impacted (USA) there were substantial, government imposed interruptions to daily life and business: government mandates on production, rationing, a military draft, curfews, the literal internment of Japanese Americans. Of course, these interruption were tiny compared to those of life in England or France or other battlefields of the the war. There’s an entire genre of literature and film devoted to lives ripped apart by the interruption of World War II. The lesson of WWII isn’t that we never need to impose individual sacrifice, but rather that the preservation of our liberty requires deep collective sacrifice on occasion, and to work to protect it not just for ourselves but for our friends who by virtue of luck are in a worse situation than we are.
- roenxi 4y agoYeah, WWII was a much bigger deal than COVID. And we come out of COVID to discover what? Suddenly we've got war in Europe involving the country with the world's biggest nuclear arsenal. We've got some terrifying tensions in the Pacific with the worlds largest manufacturing superpower that is going to rip the region a new one of they go haywire. We should have been focusing on war and peace, not trying to innovate new ways of torpedoing basic liberties. Signs suggest we might be about to lose a lot more human lives than just 7 million in the next 10-20 years. I hope not. But that wasn't the point I really wanted to make; what I'm trying to say is that we should be dealing with a substantially bigger emergency before the COVID response was justified. Seriously; how hard is it to just leave people alone to make their own decisions, and pass information to them to try and help them make the best decisions?
- bequanna 4y agoYou should express that as a percentage of the population and also show precisely which groups died. Specifically, it was very old and otherwise very sick people. A large percentage of the deaths were simply pulled forward a couple years. Tragic and awful, yes. But worth 2 years of major disruptions to life and the huge lingering economic impacts? At this point, I think most would say no. It was absolutely not worth it.
- ourlordcaffeine 4y ago> we aren't supposed to question or otherwise so much as discuss something if it goes against or strays from any established narratives I guesss you are referring to vaccine scepticism. Comparing anti-vaxxers to galileo is ridiculous.
- mikrotikker 4y agoComparing anti vaxxers to vaccine sceptics is ridiculous.
- notahacker 4y ago> Blind trust in science is no different from worshipping a religion or cult. > We are the Galileo against the Church's Geocentric Model, but far more precarious and farther gone. This sounds far more like the utterances of a cult than even the most dismissive "listen to doctors, they know better than you" media commentary...
- pas 4y ago> always remain skeptical The appropriate amount of skepticism is exactly proportional to the probability that the theory is false. Since a lot of people are very certain about vaccines, they are very un-skeptical about them. And therefore don't want to spend time on "skepticism". (Of course if one's prior distributions are very whacky, it's no surprise that they end up with bad posterior distributions after reading/seeing new data/information.) > and engage in rich discourse. There's definitely room for improvement. Especially when some folks throw out sentences like "At one point, so much as uttering the word >corona< could get you silenced by the powers-that-be regardless of the context."
- jcbrand 4y agoThe MRNA vaccines that were introduced were novel and used a mechanism that hasn't been used at scale before and without long term human studies. And increased amount of skepticism in such a case is completely warranted.
- pas 4y agoSkepticism of every and each human mRNA vaccine was completely warranted before we had data. That's why there were (and are) clinical trials, all of which do post-treatment data collection (some for 2 years). Exactly to get solid reliable data about effects of mRNA vaccines, exactly so that we can definitively say whether it was a good call or not, whether the continued skepticism is warranted or not. (Or more precisely, how much skepticism is warranted.) Appropriate amount of skepticism about long-term (5+ years) consequences is still warranted, though as time goes on that amount is seriously decreasing. What's your point?
- jcbrand 4y agoIf the current clinical trials find potential negative consequences, that hardly helps the people who already took the vaccines, many who were pressured against their will. If skepticism is warranted, then it's wrong to be pressured to go through with a health procedure.
- bayesian_horse 4y agoMillions have died. Are still dying, especially in China. More could have died if there hadn't been a robust world-wide response. How do you illicit a robust world-wide response? By making the potential consequences of not acting abundantly clear, aka "fear-mongering".
- danuker 4y agoBut you should address citizen concerns, rather than oppress them. For example: yes, the vaccine has side-effects. But here is the data on which we decided to still approve it: a much better aggregate health outcome and lower risk of death.
- bayesian_horse 4y agoThat has been done. Ad nauseam. If you didn't notice that you had to actively ignore it or live under a rock or something.
- naasking 4y ago> That has been done. Ad nauseam. Has it? Because Pfizer said they needed 75 years to release the vaccine trial data, and that was just a few months ago. Things were not as transparent as you imply.
- fastaguy88 4y agoIt is hard to tell whether you seriously believe this, or simply want to make an argument. Pfizer said they needed 75 years to redact a particular set of vaccine trial data given the resources they had allocated. They had already released an enormous amount of data, but were subjected to a nuisance suit asking for more. The statement that they wanted 75 years to release vaccine trial data is misleading.
- naasking 4y agoTransparency is not a "nuisance", it's a requirement. Dismissing people's concerns as immaterial or nuisances is a big reason why people have lost trust in institutions. As for whether my claim was misleading, are you suggesting that the proposed schedule for releasing the vaccine safety data would not have taken 75 years? The fact that Pfizer released aggregated data based on their own analyses is immaterial if third parties can't analyze the raw data replicate the results.
- alltheworlds 4y ago> I feel the covid fearmongering by governments, medical companies, medical authorities, and the media has made public discourse in general (let alone specifically medical) even more prohibitive. The fact that you still call it "fearmongering" with nearly 7 million people dead and how many others with negative long term health conditions from the virus tells you why there is a backlash against anti-intellectualism. You are certainly not prohibited from challenging the status quo. You know that because there are thousands and thousands of anti-mainstream videos and blogs that tell us viruses aren't real, or covid is just the flu, or vaccinations cause more issues than covid itself, and, and, and.... Engaging in rich discourse happens while scientists are trying to form a consensus. But eventually a consensus is formed and then the outliers who mostly only generate noise tend to get ignored. 1 in 1000000 times then may be correct and successfully challenge the status quo, but mostly they're wrong but convinced beyond any reasonableness that they are not wrong. You cannot argue against all of these people, it is just too tedious, so in the end they just get ignored or stopped from spreading nonsense on certain forums.
- GiorgioG 4y agoMy wife was in nursing school during/after the pandemic. One of her classmates/friends (37 year old mother of 3) was skeptical of the vaccines and wasn’t sure she was going to continue the nursing program because they were requiring vaccination. She contracted C-19 over the summer of ‘21, spent 2 months in the hospital before dying. Would she still be here for her kids if she’d taken the jab? It’s impossible to know, but more than likely she would have fared better than she did without it.
- lawn 4y ago> I feel the covid fearmongering by governments, medical companies, medical authorities, and the media has made public discourse in general (let alone specifically medical) even more prohibitive. A opposed to the fearmongering that vaccines are to be avoided at all costs, and that they only exist to control the masses and further enrich the rich?
- mistermann 4y agoI don't think it would be "as opposed to", both are manifestations of the same/similar underlying cognitive bugs in the brain/mind, the same sort of issues can be seen in many of the comments in this very thread, written by genuinely smart people who sincerely believe that what they say is true.
- cmsonger 4y ago> Blind trust in science is no different from worshipping a religion or cult. Let me translate this: "Blind trust in the best recommended knowledge science has at the current moment in time is no different from worshipping a religion or cult." No. This is wrong. Science's recommendation at any given time is based on assembly and analysis of evidence. It evolves over time in the presence of additional evidence. Religion or cults do not. OTOH, paying attention to what the "my uncle got COVID, spent a week in only pink lighting, and subsequently recovered!" most recent FB post in your feed is wrong. The internet mob is not following the scientific method. They are posting anecdotes. Those anecdotes are filtered by the mediums for ability to create attention in others; and then those are presented. I am reminded of the somewhat grim "Facebook COVID researcher" joke: https://i.redd.it/ovumfo3f48ca1.jpg https://i.redd.it/ovumfo3f48ca1.jpg
- wnkrshm 4y agoI think in a benevolent reading, you have to read it as: "Scientific facade hides many charlatans." Engineering and applied science are entire universes removed from the ideal of science that gets painted here in defense of them. Yes, scientists who pursue science in the way highlighted exist (and they are often not well paid for it) and it is a very respectable and admirable pursuit. But there is a way larger mass of people and companies who strike a balance between profit and being scientifically backed enough, with incentives to tilt the balance into the direction of profit.
- FormerBandmate 4y agoThe whole point of science is that you’re supposed to question things intelligently, which inherently means you’re allowed to question things. Censoring “disinformation” in the name of science is how you get Galileo and the rest to roll over in their graves, and it didn’t even work. 30% of America is still unvaccinated, and a huge portion of them were probably radicalized by people being censored for spreading disinformation, because deliberately making yourself out to be Big Brother doesn’t convince anyone that you’re right (even though they mostly were). That being said, you should look at things intelligently, but you can’t force people to do that, or you get situations where you can’t question that the Sun revolves around the Earth because that’s not seen as intelligent. The “mRNA vaccines will kill you” crowd are idiots, but censoring them only makes their point seem stronger and goes against the principles of scientific inquiry. Proving them wrong, which is easy, is better
- iso1631 4y ago> always remain skeptical Do you remain skeptical about whether the earth is a mostly roundish ball of rock or a flat disk on the back of some elephants? How much effort do you put into that scepticism. How often do you re-evaluate your view?
- pif 4y ago[flagged]
- ben_w 4y agoVenting feels good, but is seldom persuasive on the receiving end.
- _Algernon_ 4y agoThe bad faiths attempts at "skepticism" are at least in large part to blame for that response. It's as if I yell fire in a crowded theater, then when there is no fire and my speech rightly faces consequences I complain about "the-powers-that-be" limiting my future attempts at yelling "fire". Scientific skepticism is good, but requires a certain level of being informed. Good, scientific skepticism does not occur on the internet in 99+% of instances. Usually what is actually occurring is politicking and spreading disinformation. Conflating that with the good kind of scientific skepticism is quite dishonest, intellectually speaking.