4 ms·
Promise of No Child Left Behind falls short after 10 years
- quanticle 15y agoThe problem with No Child Left Behind wasn't the testing. It's that it was an unfunded mandate. The Federal Government was requiring the states to do something, but at the same time not providing the resources to do it with. Given that, can we really be surprised that NCLB was a failure? This criticism, by the way, isn't new. Opponents of NCLB were (correctly) bringing up the "unfunded mandate" charge when the bill was still in consideration.
- skore 15y agoYes, it was underfunded (not 'unfunded' - it's just that there weren't additional funds injected for it), but that still doesn't make the testing part a good idea. What you end up, even if the resources are there, are pupils who pass tests, not necessarily pupils who are fit for a job or even for life. Pupils who pass tests are not necessarily what you want to boost your economy.
- anamax 15y agoThere are bad tests. However, we have a problem. Most of us would like kids to get as much education as possible given the money we spend. Very few of us are willing to spend money on "education" that doesn't actually educate kids. So, how do you propose we figure out how to spend money on education? If your answer is "spend more", my question is "how do I know what I'm getting for said money?"
- tokenadult 15y agoThe Education Next blog includes some thoughtful responses to the tenth anniversary of the No Child Left Behind Act (NCLB). http://educationnext.org/five-thoughts-about-nclb-on-its-tenth-anniversary/ http://educationnext.org/five-thoughts-about-nclb-on-its-ten... Like the blog author, Michael Petrilli, who notes that the trade-offs build into the law were real from the beginning, "Personally, I’d prefer a policy that aims for more balance: achievement gains across the performance spectrum, not just at the bottom; and a more holistic view of what it means for students to be well educated. Literacy and numeracy are (obviously) not enough." AFTER EDIT: Other comments here write about the funding level for some of the federal government inducements to school change at the state level that were built into the No Child Left Behind Act. To be sure, the act never promised that the federal government would pick up the full tab to fund the state school system of any state, or anything near that. The United States federal government devotes substantial resources to K-12 education through various programs, but the main funding of primary and secondary schooling in the United States has always come from local and state governments. http://www2.ed.gov/about/overview/fed/10facts/index.html http://www2.ed.gov/about/overview/fed/10facts/index.html (A FAQ prepared by the previous administration) http://www2.ed.gov/about/overview/fed/role.html http://www2.ed.gov/about/overview/fed/role.html (A FAQ prepared by the current administration) http://nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/display.asp?id=66 http://nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/display.asp?id=66 (Current National Center for Education Statistics page on spending for public elementary and secondary schools) If states are in earnest about raising student achievement, they could of course target the larger amounts of money they spend on activities that are best evidenced as activities that raise student achievement. To do that, of course, the states would have to have some kind of reliable data on what activities of their school systems best raise achievement, which is part of what NCLB was about.
- dctoedt 15y agoOK, so NCLB wasn't a perfect-from-the-start solution. Few initiatives of that scale ever are. Time for a pivot, not for going back to the bad old days.
- cantastoria 15y agoBut a return to the "bad old days" is exactly what the education establishment wants. I think the reporter here buried the lede. This was the most interesting paragraph for me: "People were stunned because they were always led to believe that things were going fine in this particular school. And the fact of the matter was, for huge numbers of students that was not the case," Miller said. "That led to a lot of anger, disappointment. That led to embarrassment. In many instances, the schools were being held out as exceeding in their mission, when it fact they were failing many, many of the children in those schools." Test scores are hard to argue with so they repeat this "teaching to the test is bad" mantra endlessly. Of course, when they start talking about other countries school systems as being better what's the first metric they cite? Test scores. I have yet to here an alternative way of measuring performance that didn't amount to "trust us".
- ams6110 15y agoMassive federal program falls short of goals. Astonishing.
- tbeseda 15y agoA related documentary, "Waiting for Superman", is available on Netflix Watch Instantly. I found it very well produced and informative, if not a little bias (nature of the medium) and a bit disheartening.
- thewileyone 15y agoNCLB was designed to fail from the get-go.