3 ms·
There are some points in there but it's pretty blunt and full of strange assertive statements. >Residential high-rises, too, are often fully glazed. Meir says
by Gigachad 4y ago
There are some points in there but it's pretty blunt and full of strange assertive statements.
>Residential high-rises, too, are often fully glazed. Meir says all that glass serves no practical purpose (except possibly boosting curtain sales). Who wants thousands of passersby looking at them in their pajamas?
What, You can't see why people like big windows? I have floor to ceiling windows in my apartment and I love them. I have all my lights off and my living room and home office are super bright with incredible views. They have a mirror like coating which blocks the vast majority of heat and makes them mostly one way so I can walk around naked knowing it's basically impossible to see anything from the ground. The insulation of my apartment is superb so cooling uses minimal power. I run my air con all day every day and it uses far less power than I used to use conservatively using air con in the house I was in previously.
I agree that super tall 300m buildings are not strictly practical. They are a monument, which humans have always loved all throughout history. A more practical monument than the pyramids imo. My building is 100m tall and I feel that's roughly ideal. 3 elevators which is perfect and doesn't take up too much of the floor space.
- tormeh 4y agoI heard somewhere that 50 stories (so about 150m) is the tallest we can economically build, even on very valuable soil. Not sure why the bean counters allow architects to build higher...
- mouse_ 4y agoOzymandias can do whatever he wants!! He'll never die! Haha
- Gigachad 4y agoMost of the super tall buildings are funded by the government. They symbolize success and make up a huge part of how people see a city. Similar to sports stadiums, they aren't economical on their own but they can be when placed in a wider city scale strategy.
- voisin 4y ago> Most of the super tall buildings are funded by the government This is complete and utter nonsense. You must be thinking of somewhere like Dubai? China? Nowhere in the western world is this true at all, let alone in “most” instances.
- mouse_ 4y ago[flagged]
- Gigachad 4y agoLiving in a highrise has enabled me to go completely car free, lets me buy food at the markets daily which reduces my food waste to basically nothing, and reduces the amount of stuff I have to buy since there are shared facilities for almost everything. I don't need to build a home gym or get my own pool because it's all available in the city. I'm not really sure how it could get more sustainable.
- notacoward 4y agoDo you need to live in a high rise (defined in the article as greater than 15 stories) for any of those things?
- midoridensha 4y agoA "high rise", no, but a mid-rise, yes. You don't get enough density with everyone living in separate, single-family homes, even if they're packed fairly close together.
- notacoward 4y agoAs I pointed out in another comment, high rise vs. suburban sprawl is a false dichotomy. I asked specifically about high rises, which OP is also about and clearly defines. For the record, I'm in favor of "missing middle" development ( https://missingmiddlehousing.com https://missingmiddlehousing.com), including but not limited to mid-rise buildings. AFAICT the OP author has no issue with that kind of development either. Don't jump to defend high-rise bro by talking about suburban sprawl when you know there's more than one alternative. ETA: "where I live" is anecdata that only makes your arguments irrelevant to this discussion.
- midoridensha 4y ago
- midoridensha 4y ago>They have a mirror like coating which blocks the vast majority of heat and makes them mostly one way so I can walk around naked knowing it's basically impossible to see anything from the ground. Even without such coatings, no one can see inside your windows unless it's significantly brighter inside than outside. This is commonly known by anyone who watches police TV shows (the interrogation rooms take advantage of this effect, with very bright lights inside the room and the lights off in the observation room). So generally, no one can see in your window except at night. But even here, they'd need to be at a similar height in a neighboring building, or you'd have to be close to the ground and standing next to your window. >My building is 100m tall and I feel that's roughly ideal. I agree; too tall and there's too much space used for structure and elevators, and it takes too long to get to your floor. But a building like yours makes good use of the ground area with many dwellings.