3 ms·
You cannot eliminate determination of race in college admission (or nearly any other application process). Sure you can. Just don't show the admissions committ
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
You cannot eliminate determination of race in college admission (or nearly any other application process).
Sure you can. Just don't show the admissions committee real names, inform the committee only of a school ranking (not the specific school), and blank out specific extracurriculars that give away racial information.
Even better, you can just use a point system where everything is objectively measured. Strangely, many colleges dropped point systems after the supreme court ruled you cannot racially bias a point system (but you are allowed to racially bias a non-point system).
AA is specifically intended to discriminate against non-minorities in order to counter balance the discrimination that already exists against minorities.
If this were the true intent, you would expect that the college grades of AA beneficiaries and normal students would be similarly distributed. Do you believe this to be the case?
- OpieCunningham 15y agoIf this were the true intent, you would expect that the college grades of AA beneficiaries and normal students would be similarly distributed. As a natural result of AA or as an AA policy? The existing discrimination is with access/opportunity. The intent of AA is to counter balance access/opportunity discrimination. Over (much) time, results of counter balanced access/opportunity will equalize and AA will become less essential. The goal is equality of opportunity, not equality of outcome. Perhaps college admission practices might be limited to a point system, but then you ignore the bias that exists in primary school. A point system itself is discriminatory against minorities. AA counter balances that.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoThe net result of a biased filter is that the victims of the bias must perform at a higher level to pass through the filter. I.e., suppose the filter were set to exclude students of quality Q < 10, but were biased against black students to the tune of 2 points. Then we'd expect non-black students to have a quality distribution bounded below by 10, and black students to have a quality distribution bounded below by 12. If we gave black students a bonus of 2 points, their quality distribution would again be bounded below by 10. Of course, if our original filter was unbiased, then we expect the quality of black students to drop to 8. What do we see in the real world? A point system itself is discriminatory against minorities. By definition, a point system which ignores race cannot be discriminatory. It literally lacks the ability to discriminate. admitStudent :: Student -> Boolean admitStudent student = -- code does not refer to student.race ... If you disagree, you should be able to provide a pure function for which this test fails: admitStudent ( student { race = Asian}) == admitStudent (student {race = Black}) (In Haskell, x { a=b} takes a record x, makes a copy, and sets field a equal to b.)
- OpieCunningham 15y agoAre you suggesting that blacks have a higher rate of dropout due to AA enabling Q=8 blacks into schools? Firstly, your premise is flawed because if prior to AA only Q=12 blacks were admitted to schools, you would expect a higher rate of dropouts if Q=10 blacks are admitted - assuming we exclude a host of other significant factors for the purposes of analyzing your over-simplified algorithm. Secondly, your premise is flawed because graduation rates for blacks have been steadily increasing for decades. From 28% in 1990 for black males to 35% in 2006 and 34% in 1990 for black females to 45% in 2006 [1]. Harvard itself has an overall graduation rate of 98%, and a black graduation rate of 95% - hardly disparate. Regarding your second point: A point system can, and is, absolutely discriminatory. The points come from somewhere. In this case, lower level education results. The only way a point system admission policy would not be discriminatory is if low level education results were not derived based on racial bias. Unfortunately, they are. Low level education will pre-select non-minorities for higher points values. So a point system college admission policy may be devoid of intentional bias, but only because it ignores the established bias of the pre-selected point values it receives as input. That in itself is therefore bias (and now that you know it, well, it would be intentional). [1] http://www.jbhe.com/features/50_blackstudent_gradrates.html http://www.jbhe.com/features/50_blackstudent_gradrates.html
- yummyfajitas 15y agoAre you suggesting that blacks have a higher rate of dropout due to AA enabling Q=8 blacks into schools? Dropout rates are dependent on a lot of factors, including financial aid and similar things. College GPA is a much better measure. In terms of college GPA, if the admission system is biased in favor of a group, then the GPA of that group should be below average. If the admission system is biased against some group, then their GPA should be higher. If AA nullified existing bias, then the GPA of black students should be more or less the same as the GPA of white students. Is this the case? The only way a point system admission policy would not be discriminatory is if low level education results were not derived based on racial bias. If true, this suggests that there should be a gap between low level education results and standardized test scores (which are immune to racial bias, since the scantron doesn't know the race of the person filling in the bubbles). Does this gap exist? I.e., do black students have systematically low GPAs, but SAT scores comparable to whites/asians? Similarly, if you want to minimize racial bias in the system, you should favor standardizing testing standards as much as possible - i.e., focus more on SAT and AP, less on GPA. Do you favor this?