7 ms·
Let's look at one metric that supersedes all (in my opinion): According to, Japan's unemployment rate has been no higher than 6% over the last 32 years (1980-2
by mbesto 15y ago
Let's look at one metric that supersedes all (in my opinion):
According to, Japan's unemployment rate has been no higher than 6% over the last 32 years (1980-2012).It's currently at 4.5%[1]
Compare that to the US, who's unemployment rate has been at worst 10% over the last 32 years (1980-2012). It's currently at 8.5%[2]
Why does this supersede most other stats? Because we simply need to keep people busy "doing things", otherwise (as you're seeing in the US) riots/protests break out, crime goes up (crime is largely a result of poverty), and people don't have the means to keep themselves healthy. What more do you need from a society? I understand people will say "but we need growth". I ask why? What is the end result of growth that makes societies "better"?
[1]http://www.tradingeconomics.com/japan/unemployment-rate http://www.tradingeconomics.com/japan/unemployment-rate
[2]http://www.tradingeconomics.com/united-states/unemployment-rate http://www.tradingeconomics.com/united-states/unemployment-r...
edit: 32 years...doh!
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- kiba 15y agoBecause we simply need to keep people busy "doing things" I suppose we could employ people to dig holes and pay them for the job of digging holes for no purpose. That's not productive or is a good use of their time, unless it is spent digging useful holes. That's because we have a million other things that people could do help and help out. All we need to do is figure out how to employ people. I ask why? What is the end result of growth that makes societies "better"? Less time spent on farming, manufacturing, servicing, and generally working. More time for leisure and family, increased well being, increased lifespan(more is always better), supposedly. However, we're not good at figuring out what we want in life and thus not spend time on leisure, family, hobbies, and things that are fun. Instead, we seeks certain job because they're prestigious, buy things merely for status symbol effect, and so on.
- mbesto 15y ago"Doing things" was mildly oversimplified. That's because we have a million other things that people could do help and help out. We do? Like what?
- gurkendoktor 15y agoCleaning up all that plastic crap that litters the planet, walking around in shady areas and watching out for each other. Basically all healthcare facilities I've seen were either understaffed or just barely above that, too. I don't think we'd need to dig all those holes...
- derefr 15y ago> However, we're not good at figuring out what we want in life and thus not spend time on leisure, family, hobbies, and things that are fun. Instead, we seeks certain job because they're prestigious, buy things merely for status symbol effect, and so on. Doesn't that just mean that "what we want in life" is status?
- kshatrea 15y agoJust wanted to point one thing out: 1980-2012 = 32 years, not 22.
- xlpz 15y ago> What is the end result of growth that makes societies "better"? The need for constant economic growth is just a side effect of how a capitalist economy works. That's why they all go into deep shit when growth slows down too much or stops. Nothing good or bad per so about it, in my opinion (although the improvement of productivity has obviously some positive effects).
- jl6 15y agoA lot of capitalists also promote growth, but growth is not a necessary condition for capitalism.
- xlpz 15y agoIt's a necessary condition for a functioning capitalist economy. I can go into more details if you want, but the fact that the key economic indicator is GDP growth and that all economies go into turmoil when growth approaches 0 should tell you that this goes beyond the opinion of a bunch of people. It's an emerging effect of the rules of capitalism.
- DrCatbox 15y agoEmployment, I ask why? Seriously, full employment is a threat not a promise. Who wants to really work? For what? Mandatory vacations, 6 months per year, 5 hour work day. Then we can have full employment. As said in another comment, growth is required to spend more time with family, leisure and to do things that we really want. Well thats not the case, since no matter how much growth there is and how much an economy increases, leisure time, vacations and do what you want does not increase. Working more only produces growth so that a few people on this planet can do what they want, while all the others are still required to work more.
- mike-cardwell 15y agoWith six months vacation per year, people would still complain about having to work too much.
- Tycho 15y agoThey would also complain that those who wanted to work 80 hours per week were stealing all of society's wealth, or something.
- mbesto 15y agoWe all have our reasons for working. In some cases I'd much rather be at work than say sit on a beach. I'd get bored after endless days of sitting on a beach right? I think this conversation could easily go into the "whats the meaning of life" topic, so let's try not to go there. My overall point is more so this, what's so evil/bad about the the so-called lost era in Japan? growth is required to spend more time with family, leisure and to do things that we really want. And yet Americans spend more hours at "work" than most other countries. How has our growth shown that?
- DrCatbox 15y ago"I think this conversation could easily go into the "whats the meaning of life" topic, so let's try not to go there." Yes, exactly. What we do with our time here is quite important to discuss, and this is usually the entrance to idologies and political parties. I wish we could talk about that more. Do you really want to work 30+ years of your life, then retire hopefully with a small amount of money (if its not "eaten" by the economy), while the top dogs do whatever they want whenever they want? It would be nice with a more balanced approach to work. Not work for work, but work for play. Free will and all that, work if you will, but I highly doubt most workers today would choose thier situation if they could.
- zeteo 15y ago> What is the end result of growth that makes societies "better"? How about the fact that, when we do well, we are a bit more likely to spend that 1% of our resources on new technology, and get stuff that we later take for granted, like flying through the air, curing nasty diseases, and having immense computing power at our fingertips that can reach any nook and cranny of the Earth within milliseconds.
- bane 15y agoIt reminds me of my first time visiting South Korea. While there I observed people who's job it was to wear a cute uniform and bow to cars entering the parking garage at the local department store, people hired by companies to stand in the aisles at the local supermarket holding packs of coffee or shampoo or whatever and dance to loud techno music (usually young women in short skirts and thigh high boots, bizarre to see families shopping for vegetables, fighting their way around scantily clad 20 year olds in the middle of a dance routine around the cabbage aisle), and other similar, "keep people busy" type jobs. I'd be highly surprised if these folks made more than $3-4/hr, not even remotely a living wage. - checking on the numbers, the minimum wage in South Korea for 2011 was about $3.75. I'm guessing when I first went there in 2003, it was even lower. - in 2006 I visited and remember having to make my way around a gauntlet of guys in doorman uniforms, who's job it was to bow to people entering the hotel, and another guy who's job it was to push the "up" button to request an elevator. That's it, that was his entire job. For eight hours a day, he stood outside of the elevators, waiting for guests, and pushed the only button to request an elevator (there was no down button the hotel I was staying in). So yes, while the unemployment figures were pretty good, the actual "work" that people were doing was essentially meaningless. I've never been to Japan, but I'd be highly surprised if there weren't similar analogues.
- microarchitect 15y agoA general point to keep in mind here is that unemployment numbers are hard to compare. The best example is a country like India which has no social security net to speak of, so if you're unemployed and are not rich you will actually die of hunger. Which means that the unemployment rate is actually the percentage of people who can afford to stay unemployed. A less drastic comparison might be between unemployed people in Sweden and the US. I'd think that being unemployed in Sweden is lot better than being unemployed in the US because of the US's lack of a medical safety net. Similar logic applies to your example of people doing "meaningless work". There are lots of those in India as well. I'm not going to judge whether these jobs are meaningless, but I'm pretty sure they produce a drastic improvement in quality of life for those who are employed in these jobs. Life as a greeter at a mall or a lift-operator is way better than life as a struggling farmer. And this doesn't even consider all the second-order benefits these people enjoy. Life in a big city means better education, more access to information, more opportunities, all of which almost certainly guarantee a much better life for their children. This was a bit of a rambling post, but I guess the point I'm trying to make is that both comparing unemployment rates as well as comparing the types of employment on offer are too simplistic to make any useful judgments about an economy. I think some aggregate quality of life measure is what we really need to look at.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- TDL 15y agoWhere are these riots of which you speak? Crime is at multi-decade lows in the U.S.
- gahahaha 15y agoThe unemployment rate in Japan is low, but the (arguably more important) labor force participation rate has been dropping a lot lately: http://i.imgur.com/WJiUx.jpg http://i.imgur.com/WJiUx.jpg Of course, a big explanation for the lower labor force participation rate is the aging population.
- georgieporgie 15y agoIn addition, the type of employment has changed in Japan. The career job is gone, replaced by temp work.
- rdtsc 15y ago> people don't have the means to keep themselves healthy. Isn't that true only for US. Is employment also dysfunctionally tied to health insurance as it is in US? > What is the end result of growth that makes societies "better"? It depends who you ask. If you ask owners of large corporations they will look as GDP for a metric of how great a country is going. Doesn't matter if life expectancy is terrible, infant mortality, crime and corruption are high, no middle class, people living in shanty towns as long as GDP is booming the country is considered a success. If you ask people what is makes a country good, they wouldn't care much about GDP, they would point to healthcare, crime, lack of corruption. Unfortunately the news and the reports you get in the traditional media don't talk about that. All those analysts,"experts" and economists only care about the metric that large corporation care about. How many time have you seen on the news about "the average rate of depression in Argentina has gone up?". Not much right. But you might hear about how GDP is suffering.
- philwelch 15y ago>> people don't have the means to keep themselves healthy. > Isn't that true only for US. Is employment also dysfunctionally tied to health insurance as it is in US? Diet, stress, mood, motivation, and physical activity all have impacts on health, and all are affected by employment status. Doctors and medications, while undoubtedly important, aren't the whole picture. Most people are healthier without doctors but with a good diet, a decent amount of physical exercise, and a motivated, happy life than they would be with doctors but without all the other things.
- rdtsc 15y agoBut also once someone loses their job, diet, stress, mood & motivation would go down the hill. So the chance of getting sick and needing a doctor would go up, which, interestingly enough is when Americans get denied access to health care. They eventually end up in emergency care and then declare bankruptcy because of the cost (therefore me using the "dysfunctional" label for it). But the point was that it is hard to compare the two countries simply on unemployment just because more ties into it. Being unemployed in Japan and breaking a leg is not as terrible as being unemployed in US an breaking a leg. Does it mean Americans are more likely to be stuck working in shitty jobs, afraid to quit and move because they don't want to expose their families to the risk of having no insurance? I don't know. I suspect it plays a role.
- Anechoic 15y ago> crime goes up (crime is largely a result of poverty) While that may be conventional wisdom, crime rates have actually declined in the USA over the past 20 years: http://www.economist.com/node/18775436 http://www.economist.com/node/18775436
- guruz 15y agoFrom what you write, I think you might be interested in watching the Zeitgeist movies [1] and read about basic income [2] [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zeitgeist_(series) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zeitgeist_(series) [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_Income http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_Income
- borism 15y agoEspecially interesting since Bank of Japan doesn't seem to have dual mandate to guarantee both maximum employment and price stability, unlike Federal Reserve.