3 ms·
That is what attracted me to KDE. However, in recent years there design philosophy has become more aligned with Windows and mobile. It seems more difficult to c
by irthomasthomas 4y ago
That is what attracted me to KDE. However, in recent years there design philosophy has become more aligned with Windows and mobile. It seems more difficult to create skeuomorphic themes, now. The trend seems to be for dizzying, translucent, psychedelic themes, where figuring out what I can and cannot interact with is like a point and click adventure game, only without the joy. But this seems to be in line with KDE's new stated design goals:
Make it easy to focus on what matters --- Remove or minimize elements not crucial to the primary or main task. Use spacing to keep things organized. Use color to draw attention. Reveal additional information or optional functions only when needed.
Make complex tasks simple. Make novices feel like experts. Create ways in which your users can naturally feel empowered by your software. [0]
To me, this feels like dumbing down, and this is disappointing for a powerful desktop. A desktop PC is such a vast and powerful utility that it's interface should be reasonably complex, like the cockpit of an airliner. I'm working with 14 to 30 inch screens, I don't need the same UI as a 5" phone. Instead, we are following Musk's lead and hiding everything behind an Android-like system, with burger menus, disappearing UI elements, brightly coloured icons, and bouncy window animations. And even though KDE is still infinitely customizable, the vast majority of themes out there follow this trend. If anyone knows of a good skeuomorphic theme that still works, I'd love to see it.
[0] https://develop.kde.org/hig/ https://develop.kde.org/hig/
- int_19h 4y ago"Dizzying, translucent, psychedelic themes" is how I would describe KDE pretty much... always? Here's a fairly typical KDE desktop circa 2005: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:SUSE_Linux,_KDE_3_Desktop.jpg https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:SUSE_Linux,_KDE_3_De...
- irthomasthomas 4y agoHoly transparency, batman! I'm guessing KDE 3 introduced the transparency API or something? But that wasn't a default theme was it? I've used trinity, or TDE, which is a KDE 3 fork, but it's built in themes are way more conservative and practical.
- int_19h 4y agoTrue transparency had only just become possible around then thanks to Compiz, so default themes generally wouldn't have it. However, even outside of transparency, look at e.g. how much crystal glare and reflections all the icons have.