4 ms·
This would destroy Hacker News, which employs heavy moderation.
by bryanlarsen 4y ago
This would destroy Hacker News, which employs heavy moderation.
- christkv 4y agoIt would be interesting to know what would happen to sites like Reddit where there is community moderation. Might be still possible as it’s not the company doing it.
- 0x_rs 4y agoI don't know how it would be possible to distinguish between an unaffiliated volunteer and a company. They'd have to sign a statement, I don't see it being feasible. What I think would be a great step forward is moderation transparency, of which there is none on sites like reddit (and it's much needed, their moderation in large communities is embarrassing, see the /r/art thing recently), but I guess that is also without issues due to privacy regulations. What it is not possible to get away with is no user-generated content moderation, it's only going to become more strict with less leniency for platforms, not the opposite, see: EU proposals on the matter pending.
- lumb63 4y agoIf they deem themselves fit to censor their users, why shouldn’t they be liable for the content their users produce?
- kelseyfrog 4y agoBecause the outcome informs the choice. Regardless of the pithiness of the aphorism, if the result of its application is the destruction of a site like HN then it doesn't matter what the aphorism says - it's functionally a HN-destroying bomb. It's a deontological reversal. When someone points out the consequences of the action, the intentions necessarily become the realization of those consequences. So why shouldn't they be liable? Because that liability is yoked directly to its destruction. They are inseparable.