9 ms·
NSA asks Congress to let it get on with that warrantless data harvesting, again
- hunglee2 4y agoBig Tech vs Big Government are the Church vs State of the digital era - they must be kept separate - and preferably somewhat adversarial - so that powers are divided and we the people have some sort of chance.
- xahrepap 4y agoYou just blew my mind. What a great comparison. I love it. Thanks for that thought. What a clear way to describe the problem.
- sysadm1n 4y ago> Big Tech vs Big Government They're so heavily intertwined that bucketing them into distinct categories that don't talk to each other would be a massive ship to turn around.
- friendlyHornet 4y agoAt one point (and even still today in many countries outside the west), so were the church and state.
- _Algernon_ 4y agoThe same can be said about religion and state, at least in the US. Doesn't take away from that being the platonic ideal we should strive for.
- HPsquared 4y agoHow about things like education, healthcare and social services? Historically these were all functions of the church, not of the state. Those functions coming under control of the state means, in effect, the state transforming into the church - or at least functionally becoming church-like. We see how big tech is taking on a lot of functions of a state. Big tech companies are a bit like states. They have something like citizenship, taxes, and laws.
- gsatic 4y agoIt's probably more efficient. Reminds me of some paper about Walmart/Amazon systems getting sophisticated enough to run the country better than the govt - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Cybersyn https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Cybersyn
- paulryanrogers 4y agoWhen you don't need humans it can be very efficient! And opaque once you add arbitration, paid for by these psuedo-governments. Company towns and scrip were super efficient too! Not so great for civil rights though.
- _Algernon_ 4y ago> It's probably more efficient. Yeah, government types which disregard democracy tend to have that attribute.
- DangitBobby 4y agoI 100% do not want to live somewhere run by the people who run Walmart.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- themitigating 4y ago. Big tech companies are a bit like states. They have something like citizenship, taxes, and laws. What taxes, laws, and citizenship is unqiue to tech companies? I assume you mean money to join, rules, and membership. There are business outside of tech that have this
- LinuxBender 4y agoIt may be also worth noting that the "Separation of Church and State" people often quote is from a poem that a politician was reciting. To my knowledge that concept has never been codified in law.
- edgyquant 4y agoIt is in the first amendment. That is, the US explicitly can not force all citizens into a single church as was common in England where they were Catholic for half a millennia and then replaced that with the Church of England. People love to bring up “it’s actually not in the constitution” as if explicitly saying that in anyway detracts from the fact that a foundational principle of the nation /separated/ church from state.
- LinuxBender 4y agoThat does prevent forcing a particular religion on people but it does not in any way prevent the mix of religion and government. As just one example, court rooms still have people swear on Christian bibles. I believe it has recently become optional. There are also many government buildings that fund the creation and installation of religious statues and bible verses on plaques in their halls using taxpayer funds. There are many laws derived from Christian ethics and values. There are also unwritten concepts that are effectively enforced such as prison review boards giving credence to someone that has become a Born Again Christian when considering parole. That is not written anywhere to my knowledge. But you are right, they can not force someone to be Christian.
- edgyquant 4y agoYou’re completely ignoring the fact that the government not forcing a single church is the separation of church and state being talked about
- Spivak 4y ago“We can make Christianity the de facto law of the land, have federal holidays be Christian holidays, have the interests of the church intertwined with that of the state, have “secular” state institutions mirror christian sacraments, have our pledge of allegiance essentially be a declaration of our country being Christian — but hey, they can’t make you go to church on Sunday” is not exactly what one might call a strong separation.
- crawfordcomeaux 4y agoAnd what about a state that integrates all religions, instead? Has that been tried?
- gomizari 4y agoUSSR, perhaps. Really rich with nations and religions.
- crawfordcomeaux 4y agoIf it's only been tried once, it's definitely time to try again, except maybe with a focus on wellbeing this time.
- 64r5384644y 4y agoI'm not convinced this is entirely true. In the USA maybe it holds some degree of accuracy right now but just looking at China and Tencent shows plenty of evidence for how a tech company might find heavy government interference cumbersome at the very least within certain commercial spaces.
- tessierashpool 4y ago> They're so heavily intertwined that bucketing them into distinct categories that don't talk to each other would be a massive ship to turn around. never mind, then. the big thing that moral imperatives have in common with the checks and balances necessary for society to be healthy is that none of these things ever require any effort.
- yucky 4y agoI don't think so. Big Government uses Big Tech as a tool in its arsenal. There is no greater surveillance tool. Trying to keep them separated is like trying to keep Big Government separated from the Military Industrial Complex. They are two sides of the same coin.
- nwallin 4y agoThat's what he's saying. He's not saying that Big Government and Big Tech are separated, he's saying that Big Government and Big Tech ought to be separated. In the West we fight pretty hard to keep the Church and State separated, but this isn't a natural state of being. The Divine Right of Kings, the Pharoahs were gods, Sharia law, the Japanese Emperor is the direct descendant of Amaterasu, the Spanish Inquisition, etc etc etc. History is rife with Church and State being two sides of the same coin. In fact in recent years certain government leaders have been pretty effective at intertwining the US government with Christianity, despite the separation of Church and State being enshrined in the First Amendment; prayer in schools, the repeal of Roe v Wade, etc. The link between big government and big tech (and big ag, big auto...) ought to be fought with similar gusto as we attempt to protect the separation we've won between church and state.
- yucky 4y ago> That's what he's saying. He's not saying that Big Government and Big Tech are separated, he's saying that Big Government and Big Tech ought to be separated. Right, and I'm saying they can't be (as I said, two sides of the same coin). I think this desire comes from a fundamental misunderstanding about the nature of power. It's beyond wishful thinking.
- JumpCrisscross 4y agoIt’s trivial compared to religion.
- mistermann 4y agoA faith-based belief, ironically.
- kupopuffs 4y agoBig government should just be treated as another customer of Big Tech
- speedgoose 4y agoThat would give them too much power, it is dangerous.
- LinuxBender 4y agoThey have been since WWII. In the recent years the CIA has been quite busy in silicon valley. [1] Prior to that many projects funded by DARPA were tested and refined by the general public. The internet was one of the projects. [1] - https://mattermark.com/q-tel-cias-vc-arm-busy-years/ https://mattermark.com/q-tel-cias-vc-arm-busy-years/
- est31 4y agoFWIW CIA involvement is much older than "recent years". https://qz.com/1145669/googles-true-origin-partly-lies-in-cia-and-nsa-research-grants-for-mass-surveillance https://qz.com/1145669/googles-true-origin-partly-lies-in-ci... https://gizmodo.com/larry-ellisons-oracle-started-as-a-cia-project-1636592238 https://gizmodo.com/larry-ellisons-oracle-started-as-a-cia-p...
- sinenomine 4y agoBig Tech vs Big Government vs The Intelligence Community vs NGO blub to be more precise.
- mistermann 4y agoDon't forget the trustworthy totally independent media!
- exabrial 4y agoThe problem is an increasing majority of people in the US treat their political party as a religion.
- edgyquant 4y agoAn increasing minority of democrats do. Republicans tend to have a religion already so they try to leave that stuff to the church.
- doubleg72 4y ago[flagged]
- woodruffw 4y agoWhere does this come from? The religious foundations of the current GOP are well attested[1]. The historical conventional wisdom around the US's political parties is that Democrats fall in love (meaning that they abstain from voting over minor political differences), while Republicans fall in line (meaning that they hold their nose and vote for whoever the party ticket is). That's changed a little bit over the the last decade, but not appreciably so. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_Majority https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_Majority
- TimTheTinker 4y agoIn my opinion, Republicans are less falling in line and more voting against the other side. American politics today are about thesis/antithesis, where the thesis is whatever the latest liberal agenda is and the antithesis is everyone who normally disagrees with each other, but is united in a common disagreement with the Democratic Party. In this environment, there's only one political thesis (not antithesis) that has more than a very small percentage of the vote.
- hobs 4y agoWhat makes you say that when preachers are actively testing the laws regarding non-profit status, widely reported to support GOP legislators who are using their religion as the basis for their platforms on abortion. https://www.texastribune.org/2022/10/30/johnson-amendment-elections-irs/ https://www.texastribune.org/2022/10/30/johnson-amendment-el... https://www.newsnationnow.com/religion/churches-politics-pulpit/ https://www.newsnationnow.com/religion/churches-politics-pul...
- jonnybgood 4y agoSeparation of church and state is about the government not enforcing or favoring one religion over others. I'm having trouble seeing the analogy applied to separation of big tech and big government. The separation of big tech and big government is a different categorical issue. But does this issue actually exist? At the end of the day, the government holds all the power over big tech as it should. And you do have a chance to say how your government should operate.
- bioemerl 4y agoGovernment cannot ask big tech for data on their users. Big tech is not allowed to lobby for the government to pass certain laws or restrictions or whatever else. Big tech is not allowed to voluntarily or in any form shape or a communicate any data with the government unless it is strictly related to government business and employees. The government may not communicate in any form shape or way any data to big tech unless the conditions from the above paragraph apply. Government may continue to regulate technology companies, but the data they collect on their users is considered strictly not in the domain of any form of government. Unless we are talking about court cases with discovery and the defendant being able to defend themselves. If someone uses Facebook to commit a crime Facebook should be liable to reveal data about the messages they sent by court order for a *public* trial.
- jonnybgood 4y agoThere are severe consequences to what you're suggesting with a net negative to society. Before you know it we'll have Big Tech Banks being a money launderer's wet dream. Kinda like how it is now, except all their data is in a bank the government can't touch or will ever know about.
- bioemerl 4y agoI would believe regulations on banking would apply regardless. You would apply these laws only to places where social media companies are dealing with the people's day today data and interactions, not stuff like banking. It's the law, it'll be written by a billion lawyers who consider edge cases like this and this little comic will apply. https://xkcd.com/1494/ https://xkcd.com/1494/
- thraway12 4y agoThose two categories are both random af. Are local police "Big Government" according to even half of the people who use the phrase "Big Government"? Are banks that utilize AI "big tech"? What about government intelligence agencies that have venture wings and invest in these companies? How quick a revolving door between the two blurs your distinction? Are you imagining pitched legal battles between the two based on public court filings? How likely are the filings themselves falsely suggesting some schism between the two that doesn't exist?
- fallingfrog 4y agoYeah but big government put a ton of money into creating these technologies in the first place- why do you think they did it? They’re getting value for their money. Information technology is technology of control.
- LatteLazy 4y agoAt this point, why would anyone believe they ever stopped? No real warrant has ever been required...
- tremon 4y agoHas anyone been held accountable for the previous transgressions?
- adastra22 4y agoOnly the guy who revealed that transgressions were going on.
- godelski 4y agoI'm guessing you're referring to Snowden, but there are plenty of others like Reality Winner that have gone to jail (Reality got the longest sentence ever for this type of crime). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reality_Winner https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reality_Winner
- edgyquant 4y agoThose transgressions were revealed by PBS a couple of years before.
- CWuestefeld 4y agoHas the government ever been held accountable for previous transgressions?
- CrazyPyroLinux 4y agohttps://hasjamesclapperbeenindictedyet.com/ https://hasjamesclapperbeenindictedyet.com/
- tptacek 4y agoIt's not the premise of the article that it ever had. The IC has, and always has had, the broad authority to collect information on foreign nationals abroad, without a warrant. The issue here is much more subtle than that.
- vvovo 4y agoSounds reasonable. A warrant should be needed to query the data, but collecting it in the first place should be unrestricted.
- LatteLazy 4y ago>I'm putting a camera up in your bathroom, but don't worry, no one will look...
- halJordan 4y agoThis describes all lawful intercept. The only thing keeping the police from going through your phone calls rn is a warrant.
- superkuh 4y agoExcept that it doesn't actually keep them from doing it unlawfully. As long as they believe they're acting within the law (despite being wrong) they can do it with no consequences.
- nhchris 4y agoIncorrect. They need a warrant to (legally) even collect phone call audio - they can't tap your line ahead of time, and then get a warrant when they want to listen to the recordings. Unless you meant the metadata of who you called. But that's not the police collecting that data, but the phone company doing it voluntarily for billing purposes. If the company didn't keep those records, the police couldn't (legally) compel them to without a warrant.
- monetus 4y agoI think the legal position is that only data access requires a warrant, not data retention. The in.es.ā. argues this, local police don't have that access - they buy things like location data on the private market though
- cm2187 4y agoWon't change much for us non-US nationals...
- halJordan 4y agoSection 702 is not about Americans. It's only about foreign nationals (with an FI value). So the opposite is true: it will affect non-US nationals and it will not affect US nationals.
- int_19h 4y agoNSA still refuses to answer the question of how many American citizens were "incidentally" surveilled under Section 702. If that number was zero, I don't think stating that would be quite so difficult.
- tptacek 4y agoNo, it won't. It also won't change anything for US nationals who deliberately move their communications to platforms "hosted in Switzerland", which has always been a funny privacy move, because the US IC has blanket de jure authority to surveil foreign services; it's only the US providers that have these procedural protections. The statute we're talking about here, 702, is what enables the IC to compel American communications providers to cough up data (about ostensibly foreign targets).
- kevin_thibedeau 4y ago> it's only the US providers that have these procedural protections. Even that is no guarantee as your packets can be routed into Canada and back if they need to be made foreign.
- tptacek 4y ago702 generally targets stored communications.
- edgyquant 4y ago
- ThinkBeat 4y ago[flagged]
- edgyquant 4y agoPlease keep comments like this to yourself, or find a relevant Reddit thread. We want actual discussion here not “funny memes”
- tomohawk 4y agoGiven the amount of FISA abuse that has occurred, it's time to just admit that people in power cannot be trusted to not abuse the system. They should either abolish it or change the law to put real penalties in place for abusing the system. Puting all of this machinery in place and then not providing a means to hold powerful people accountable for their actions when they abuse it is just asking for trouble. https://www.justice.gov/storage/120919-examination.pdf https://www.justice.gov/storage/120919-examination.pdf The above report is nice, but is anyone going to pay the price for the crimes committed here other than the victims?
- andy_ppp 4y agoI don’t understand why politicians don’t worry that if the NSA are allowed to do this they will have a lot of information on many people in public life including them. Do they not understand the NSA will be harvesting representatives data together with the rest of the citizens? Personally I would struggle to resist reading Biden’s/Trump’s emails, whereabouts and digital footprint for a day, it would be pretty interesting to say the least.
- sinenomine 4y agoSurely various gentleman agreements are in place.
- andy_ppp 4y agoYou can agree things behind the scenes but who holds all the power in that situation?
- sinenomine 4y agoThis could be precisely the reason various groups seek representation not just in parliament, but in important three-letter agencies as well. In the end, the amount of power in the world is finite, and natural power-strivers participate in exercises in game theory over it.
- kmeisthax 4y agoI thought the whole shitshow in 2016 with Obama accidentally spying on the Trump campaign would have, at the very least, lit a fire under the GOP's feet to reign in the government's surveillance apparatus. Who am I kidding? They don't want the boot off their face, they want it on their foot.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoWhy would they do that?. The swamp part of the GOP and the swamp part of the DNC are within a hairs breath of being the same establishment. They just market different things to different customers. They're like a megacorp selling all natural bullshit under one brand and rot your organs energy drinks under another brand. The Bernies and the AOCs and the MTGs and other "out there" politicians they let make noise are just market research so the swamp people know what positions they may need to adopt in the future to keep their products marketable to the masses.
- TigerTeamX 4y agoReminds of a bit of European Union https://europa.eu/europass/en https://europa.eu/europass/en Apparently the EU now started competing with businesses and they try to capture everyone's data. And people love it...
- Arubis 4y ago…had they stopped? Or even slowed down? I’ve presumed that no one being held accountable meant USGov de facto granting permission for this to continue unabated, just please be more careful about being caught.
- colordrops 4y agoThere's no way they've stopped.
- edgyquant 4y agoThey definitely stopped if only to save face. The scrutiny they received from the public was constant and widespread
- colordrops 4y agoWhat's your source? The public has no visibility at all to what they are doing. Their work is classified.
- aSockPuppeteer 4y agoLOL. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=iEh-l_G1Gcs https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=iEh-l_G1Gcs NSA director lies to congress
- edgyquant 4y agoYes they’d stopped. The narrative they hadn’t is peddled by the same people who don’t realize that Bush era torture was also shutdown by congressional oversight. America isn’t perfect but it’s damn sure answerable to its citizens when they decide something is worth having answers for
- lazide 4y agoReally? So who answered for it? Last I heard, literally zero folks went to jail (or even lost their jobs).
- 4y ago
- bamboozled 4y agoThis is why people like Donald Trump get elected, he promises to do thing like "drain the swamp". Of course he is doing it out of self interest but when people promise to help put an end to this horror, other get behind them.
- phpisthebest 4y agoOpen Spying on the American Public is one of the few, if not the only, thing Democrats and Republicans Agree on.. 4th amendment... pish that tired old document needs to go, nothing stands in the way of "national security" not even that pesky constitution.
- nichos 4y agoThat and military spending
- luxuryballs 4y agoThey’ll do it either way, but it’s nice of them for asking.
- eftychis 4y agoIt is troubling (and expected) this is one of the top two comments. We need to do better than accept this.
- CoastalCoder 4y agoWhat do you propose?
- eftychis 4y agoa) Education on the importance of privacy in a democratic nation on its stability and survival. b) Political Accountability. Actually have people removed from office that support such approaches. c) Have actual felony penalties on such violations by the NSA and anyone assisting in coverups with no statute of limitations (or statute starts after declassification). d) Blanket civil and criminal immunity for whistleblowers related to above violations. Plus financial bounty. e) Automate the declassification process. (Add checks extra here.) f) Introduce an Independent Counter-Surveillance and Privacy Agency. (Similar agencies exist in other countries.) It should have the ability to oversee the de-classification process, act as a check and balance on the N.S.A; its sole mandate to protect the privacy and data of inhabitants of the U.S.A. and U.S. nationals. N.B. The necessity of such an agency becomes even more paramount for the U.S. now that individuals' social network data lie abroad and contemporary issues go beyond the jurisdiction of the FBI.
- themitigating 4y agoNot to copy another comment that basically is saying "what do you propose?" There are people who want a revolution or civil war. What happens after, assuming they win? They form another government, why won't the same situations they don't like occur again? Oh because we should have laws about this and enforcement. We have that now and if there isn't a law, like against stock trading, you can vote for that but people don't. The same situation with occur again the only difference being a economic and human disaster of a war.
- rqtwteye 4y agoDon't want to be too pessimistic but I think total surveillance is almost inevitable with increasing technological capabilities. Governments will do it and so will companies. I don't see how to stop this.
- lern_too_spel 4y agoThe same way it has always been stopped. The law.
- looseyesterday 4y agoGiven broad awareness of this taking place I wonder just how effective it still is. Surely motivated bad actors are now making using of encryption and hiding their activity away.