3 ms·
> a term long used to deflect the sophisticated tactical, strategic, technological, and governmental methods of the Mongols Setting aside the fact that the ter
by thaumasiotes 4y ago
> a term long used to deflect the sophisticated tactical, strategic, technological, and governmental methods of the Mongols
Setting aside the fact that the term refers to the Mongols using their own word, why are we describing their governmental methods as sophisticated? How do they perform relative to comparators?
In China, they're not impressive at all; the government before them lasted for about 300 years (traditionally dated 960-1276, though it lost control of the north of China for the last 100 or so years), and the one after them also lasted about 300 years (1368-1644).
If you were paying attention to the dates, that leaves just under 100 years for the Mongols' "sophisticated" government to survive. [In reality, they almost certainly deserve credit for a bit more than that -- transitions of power take place over multi-year periods, not instantaneously.] I tend to make the assumption that the brevity of their rule is related to the fact that they had no administrative tradition -- perhaps you know better?
(I've also read that Mongol rule was extremely beneficial to the economy of Europe -- where they weren't in charge -- [because the pax Mongolica made overland trade economically viable] while being a step backward for China, where they were.)
> technological
This is even weirder. What technological methods? The Mongols couldn't even make metal objects.
- hef19898 4y agoYou are aware that the Mongols replaced dysnaties in China with their own, until those dynasties were replaced centuries later? The Mongol Empire span a huge chunk of continental Asia for quite sometime, their government seems less sohpisticated to Western eyes because we are used to impressive monuments left by local kingdoms. But monuments don't tell you anything about government or bureaucracy.
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> until those dynasties were replaced centuries later? One century later. The Mongols had very little staying power. That's what I'm saying above. What do "sophisticated governmental methods" mean to you? Did the Mongols have them? The relationship of the Russian dukes to their faraway Mongol overlords seems more parallel to the systems of, say, feudal Europe than to those of the Roman empire. There's a clear consensus on which system used more sophisticated methods.